"Don't reinvent the wheel" might be the most repeated piece of advice in digital work, and also one of the most dangerous, depending on which wheel you are borrowing. I got to test that theory properly on a sales call with someone pitching me their new booking platform.
He had a market leader in his sights, the kind of business doing a million bookings a month, and his checkout plan was simple. Copy theirs, because it clearly works. Hard to argue with a million bookings. Except a pattern does not become proven in some abstract sense. It becomes proven for a specific business, with a specific audience, doing a specific kind of transaction, at a specific scale, and none of those specifics were his. The market leader built a checkout for someone booking an activity from a stranger they would forget by dinner. He was building one for someone who had already decided, before checkout even started, that they trusted this brand enough to pay a premium for it. Different job, different flow, and the spreadsheet of best practice does not know that.
I told him straight, do not hold onto "it works for them" too tightly, because that is exactly what might stop it working for you. The question worth asking before you borrow anything from a bigger competitor is who it was built for, and whether that is actually you.
Borrow what earns its place in your product. Bin the rest, however many bookings a month the big guy is doing.
#UXDesign #ProductStrategy #DigitalStrategy
He had a market leader in his sights, the kind of business doing a million bookings a month, and his checkout plan was simple. Copy theirs, because it clearly works. Hard to argue with a million bookings. Except a pattern does not become proven in some abstract sense. It becomes proven for a specific business, with a specific audience, doing a specific kind of transaction, at a specific scale, and none of those specifics were his. The market leader built a checkout for someone booking an activity from a stranger they would forget by dinner. He was building one for someone who had already decided, before checkout even started, that they trusted this brand enough to pay a premium for it. Different job, different flow, and the spreadsheet of best practice does not know that.
I told him straight, do not hold onto "it works for them" too tightly, because that is exactly what might stop it working for you. The question worth asking before you borrow anything from a bigger competitor is who it was built for, and whether that is actually you.
Borrow what earns its place in your product. Bin the rest, however many bookings a month the big guy is doing.
#UXDesign #ProductStrategy #DigitalStrategy