Pinned post
THE REJOIN DILEMMA by @TomMcTague
Harmonising the way things are done between the island and the continent has been the recurring dream for many on both sides of the Channel over the years, the solution to Britain’s “insular syndrome”, as François Mitterrand put it. The Channel Tunnel, then, was not a mere engineering project, but an act of geopolitics, even of psychology, designed to change how the nation felt as much as how it travelled. History did not work out that way, and yet here we are, once again, wrestling with the same dilemma of how to harmonise with our continental hinterland and remain different; to think about free movement again, while retaining border controls; to accept more European youngsters, but only for a limited period; to move closer to Europe’s regulatory embrace while also “taking back control” of the levers of the British economy, as Andy Burnham told me was the central goal of his premiership.
In what may prove to be the most significant week of his premiership so far, the Prime Minister will meet with EU leaders in Brussels on 20 November to sign up to a package of measures on food, farming, youth mobility and carbon trading that he hopes will be the beginning of a historic rapprochement with the EU. Such a reset could, some hope, lead to Britain’s re-entry into the European Union; a “Breturn”, as it has already been coined in the French press – though one in which new red lines have already started to emerge.
In Westminster and beyond, there is talk of a slow-motion return to the continental order; a one-step-at-a-time approach, prodding and probing as we go, as successive parts of the British economy fall into line with the EU until, at some point, re-entry appears obvious. This way, the argument runs, rather than racing into an all-or-nothing battle over membership, the government would conclude one sensible deal with Brussels after another, painting those who oppose such moves as backward-looking ideologues, and securing a great progressive majority at the next election without having to commit to anything much in particular.
Is this the Burnham plan? No one is quite sure, perhaps not even Burnham himself. When I have spoken to the Prime Minister, his instinctive, familial pro-Europeanism is clear, and yet there is also a notable reticence.
Cover art by André Carrilho
Harmonising the way things are done between the island and the continent has been the recurring dream for many on both sides of the Channel over the years, the solution to Britain’s “insular syndrome”, as François Mitterrand put it. The Channel Tunnel, then, was not a mere engineering project, but an act of geopolitics, even of psychology, designed to change how the nation felt as much as how it travelled. History did not work out that way, and yet here we are, once again, wrestling with the same dilemma of how to harmonise with our continental hinterland and remain different; to think about free movement again, while retaining border controls; to accept more European youngsters, but only for a limited period; to move closer to Europe’s regulatory embrace while also “taking back control” of the levers of the British economy, as Andy Burnham told me was the central goal of his premiership.
In what may prove to be the most significant week of his premiership so far, the Prime Minister will meet with EU leaders in Brussels on 20 November to sign up to a package of measures on food, farming, youth mobility and carbon trading that he hopes will be the beginning of a historic rapprochement with the EU. Such a reset could, some hope, lead to Britain’s re-entry into the European Union; a “Breturn”, as it has already been coined in the French press – though one in which new red lines have already started to emerge.
In Westminster and beyond, there is talk of a slow-motion return to the continental order; a one-step-at-a-time approach, prodding and probing as we go, as successive parts of the British economy fall into line with the EU until, at some point, re-entry appears obvious. This way, the argument runs, rather than racing into an all-or-nothing battle over membership, the government would conclude one sensible deal with Brussels after another, painting those who oppose such moves as backward-looking ideologues, and securing a great progressive majority at the next election without having to commit to anything much in particular.
Is this the Burnham plan? No one is quite sure, perhaps not even Burnham himself. When I have spoken to the Prime Minister, his instinctive, familial pro-Europeanism is clear, and yet there is also a notable reticence.
Cover art by André Carrilho