Pinned post
On Nov 2, SEC staff updated the FAQ for the Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets. They say “a crypto system is ‘decentralized’ if it functions and operates autonomously with no person, entity, or group of persons or entities having operational, economic, or voting control of the crypto system.”
The staff looks for anyone who can act alone, outside the network's governance: to limit access, change how upgrades get voted on, pick who runs nodes, change the code or reverse transactions.
Here's how THORChain works on each point.
Operational - Funds sit in vaults run by groups of nodes, and every transaction needs a supermajority of nodes to authorize it. No single node can move funds or undo a swap. If the protocol detects an insolvency, it will automatically halt a whole chain, to protect the network. It can't target a single user. Operational mimirs exist to protect the network from attack or failure. These require a minimum of 3 node votes, but 4 nodes can then vote to reverse, 5 can counter the 4, and so on.
Economic - Fees are automatically charged on all swaps and automatically distributed on the network to the various stakeholders. Changes to fees, tokenomics, etc. are called economic mimirs and need 2/3 of active nodes.
Voting - Anyone can run a node if they bond enough RUNE to be churned into the network. No person picks the nodes. Parameters change only through on-chain node votes. Same with a protocol upgrade. No team or company can change a parameter on its own. Every node vote is recorded on-chain, and anyone can check it.
The staff looks for anyone who can act alone, outside the network's governance: to limit access, change how upgrades get voted on, pick who runs nodes, change the code or reverse transactions.
Here's how THORChain works on each point.
Operational - Funds sit in vaults run by groups of nodes, and every transaction needs a supermajority of nodes to authorize it. No single node can move funds or undo a swap. If the protocol detects an insolvency, it will automatically halt a whole chain, to protect the network. It can't target a single user. Operational mimirs exist to protect the network from attack or failure. These require a minimum of 3 node votes, but 4 nodes can then vote to reverse, 5 can counter the 4, and so on.
Economic - Fees are automatically charged on all swaps and automatically distributed on the network to the various stakeholders. Changes to fees, tokenomics, etc. are called economic mimirs and need 2/3 of active nodes.
Voting - Anyone can run a node if they bond enough RUNE to be churned into the network. No person picks the nodes. Parameters change only through on-chain node votes. Same with a protocol upgrade. No team or company can change a parameter on its own. Every node vote is recorded on-chain, and anyone can check it.