Twitxy Saved

Amitai

@AmitaiFraiman

Abba, husband, Rabbi, MPA-MA.
Joined January 2012
1.2K Following 361 Followers 2.4K Posts

Latest posts 5

Amitai @AmitaiFraiman
We make decisions about Jewish survival in our children’s name. What kind of Jewish life will those decisions leave them?

That question stayed with @ZackBodner and me as we studied Yiftach’s story for this week’s Weekly Zionist.
Z3_Project Verified account @z3_project 17h
Yiftach won the battle but lost his future.

Can we defend ourselves without losing our humanity? Seek acceptance without surrendering our identity?

@ZackBodner and @AmitaiFraiman on the price of victory, in this week's The Weekly Zionist: weeklyzionist.substack.com/p/the-price-of…
View quoted post on X
Amitai @AmitaiFraiman
I understand why the olive, fig, and vine say no. They’re already contributing to the greater good.

Writing this with @ZackBodner left us asking what we still may owe our community when we decline a role but still have strong opinions about whoever takes it.
Z3_Project Verified account @z3_project Nov 13
The olive, fig, and vine refuse the crown. The thorn says yes.

What happens when good people stop searching for worthy leaders?

“We can say no to the crown. We cannot say no to the search.”

@AmitaiFraiman @ZackBodner

weeklyzionist.substack.com/p/who-leads-wh…
View quoted post on X
Amitai @AmitaiFraiman
American Jewish institutions have spent decades organizing around the Jews we fear losing. What if we’ve mistaken rejection for a forecast—and built Jewish life around the people most likely to leave?

My new essay for Mosaic: ideas.tikvah.org/mosaic/columns…
ideas.tikvah.org Jewish Institutions Keep Mistaking Their Fears for Forecasts It’s time to stop trying to appease the Jews turning against the Jewish community.
Amitai @AmitaiFraiman
Deborah was already judging Israel when the people cried out for help.

Whose wisdom do we rely on every day, yet overlook when we imagine who could lead us?
Z3_Project Verified account @z3_project Nov 6
What makes a leader legitimate: being chosen, being recognized, or delivering results?

From Othniel and Ehud to Deborah, the Book of Judges challenges our assumptions about leadership.

This week in The Weekly Zionist, with @ZackBodner and @AmitaiFraiman

Read the article here: weeklyzionist.substack.com/p/can-we-hear-…
View quoted post on X
Amitai @AmitaiFraiman
This exchange gets at something I've been thinking about since the olive harvest incident from a few weeks ago.

Israelis and American Jews keep turning one another into ammunition for political fights at home. What does that cost us?

👇

tinyurl.com/45ru7twk
amitaifraiman.substack.com Apparently, It’s Harvest Season From Brad Lander's detention to the Lapid–Senor exchange, why do Israelis and American Jews keep turning one another into political ammunition?
Dan Senor Verified account @dansenor Nov 5
Yair, I hope you’re right. But your distinction between the “hate us no matter what” crowd and “true friends” is blurrier than most Israelis appreciate.

For instance, you identify Schumer as a sterling example of a true friend. Left to his own instincts, do I think Schumer would probably support ways to protect the U.S.-Israel relationship? Sure. But at the same time he spent between $30mm and $50mm (likely closer to the higher end) via his own Senate Majority PAC to get El-Sayed elected. Schumer didn’t need to do that. He made El-Sayed’s election a priority.

El-Sayed has said all along that Israel and Iran are indistinguishable — that Israel is neither a friend nor an ally of America…and that Israel doesn’t even have a right to exist. He rationalized antisemitic violence against American Jews. (AND El-Sayed will vote AGAINST Schumer for Majority Leader🤦‍♂️.) This is the self-defeating game that Schumer is playing.

Schumer will also be under pressure from a prospective challenge from AOC back in NY (or from another progressive challenger). As he contemplates whether to run for re-election, that will certainly be a factor in how he navigates these issues.

The spirit of your original message was made in good faith. But I think it’s unrealistic that it will be sufficient, or will even scratch the surface of addressing what’s going on here.

Like I said, I hope you’re right and I’m wrong.
-Dan
View quoted post on X