Pinned post
For @FrMatthewLC and other Catholics, here are Christian theologians and lists that rejected some or all of the apocrypha (“deuterocanonicals”) as incapable of establishing doctrine included:
Pope Gregory the Great (540 [590]-604)
Melito of Sardis (100-170/180)
Pope Gregory the Great (540 [590]-604)
Melito of Sardis (100-170/180)
"ALL Christian lists of canonical books before Augustine omitted Maccabees"View quoted post on X
Augustine converted to Christianity in 386.
Melito, in the 100s, lists Wisdom in the canon, which Protestants reject.
The Codex Sinaiticus (~325-36) is 1 of the earliest complete Bibles in existence and includes Maccabees as canon.
The Cheltenham or Mommsen List (~360) & the Apostolic Canons (~380) include Maccabees.
A Church council in Rome declared Maccabees canonical in 382.
Before 382, there is debate about if Maccabees are canon, but once determined in 382, there is near unanimity among Christians until Protestants remove these books 1000+ years later.