Twitxy Saved

Against Catholic Nonsense

@AnsweringRCs

Joined August 2024
0 Following 367 Followers 4.9K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Against Catholic Nonsense @AnsweringRCs
For @FrMatthewLC and other Catholics, here are Christian theologians and lists that rejected some or all of the apocrypha (“deuterocanonicals”) as incapable of establishing doctrine included:

Pope Gregory the Great (540 [590]-604)
Melito of Sardis (100-170/180)
Fr Matthew P. Schneider, LC🇻🇦 Verified account @FrMatthewLC 1d
"ALL Christian lists of canonical books before Augustine omitted Maccabees"

Augustine converted to Christianity in 386.

Melito, in the 100s, lists Wisdom in the canon, which Protestants reject.

The Codex Sinaiticus (~325-36) is 1 of the earliest complete Bibles in existence and includes Maccabees as canon.

The Cheltenham or Mommsen List (~360) & the Apostolic Canons (~380) include Maccabees.

A Church council in Rome declared Maccabees canonical in 382.

Before 382, there is debate about if Maccabees are canon, but once determined in 382, there is near unanimity among Christians until Protestants remove these books 1000+ years later.
View quoted post on X
Against Catholic Nonsense @AnsweringRCs
Every single Church Father that we know of who made a list in the 350+ years before Augustine rejected some or all of the Apocryphal books. That’s ZERO advocating for a 73-book canon.

The Catholic Church has a man-made canon.

And Pope Gregory the Great rejected Maccabees.
Reformed to Rome Verified account @ReformedToRome 15h
@AnsweringRCs The church never once in history accepted your post Christian rabbinic canon.
View quoted post on X
7 replies 3 reposts 30 likes 707 views View on X
Against Catholic Nonsense @AnsweringRCs
Have you ever heard a solid argument for the infallibility of any aspect of the Catholic Church that doesn’t boil down to “in my opinion the claims of the Catholic Church to infallibility are correct”?
That Catholic Guy 🇻🇦 Verified account @Catholic_bro 1d
Have you ever heard a solid biblical argument or logical reason for sola scriptura that doesn't eventually boil down to someone claiming they have the correct interpretation?
View quoted post on X
Against Catholic Nonsense @AnsweringRCs
Contrary to @garrettham_esq, Peter Abelard from “Sic et Non,” 1120 writes:

“There are many seeming contradictions and even obscurities in the innumerable writings of the church fathers. Our respect for their authority should not stand in the way of an effort on our part to come
Garrett Ham Verified account @garrettham_esq 2d
Attacking the Church Fathers is to admit that the apostles were so hopelessly inept at fulfilling Christ's commission to make disciples that they chose leaders who immediately began to twist and distort their teachings.
View quoted post on X
Against Catholic Nonsense @AnsweringRCs
That is NOT the question.
Scripture makes it clear that the first century churches erred and had to be corrected by the Apostles (from Paul to John).
The issue is that the Catholic Church is fallible and gets things wrong - even when it claims to be speaking infallibly.
Garrett Ham Verified account @garrettham_esq 1d
No church looks exactly like that of the first century; it's foolish to argue otherwise. The question, therefore, is what church's practices and doctrines appear in nascent form from the beginning. That is an historical, not a theological, question.
View quoted post on X