Pinned post
š§µāļøEuropean plate armor was incredibly effective, and a huge force multiplierā¦.
Of course it didnāt make one invincible & isnāt the sole factor for winning wars; The advantage it provides against missile weapons (even firearms in the 16th & 17th C.) alone is enough to be worth it.
Its advantages are undeniable. Here are some historical sources from actual 16th Century soldiers discussing its advantages, and how to defeat it; singlehanded blunt weapons are actually not super effective against plate unless its a polearm-Even then they could withstand multiple blows that would completely incapacitate someone w/o plate armor. But donāt just take my word for itā¦
Battle of Flodden Field in 1513 is a great example.šš»
"The said Scots were so surely harnessed with complete harnesses, Jacks, almain rivets, splints, pavises, and other habiliments that [the] shot of arrows in regard did them no harm, and when it came to hand strikes of bill and halberds, they were so mighty, large, strong, and great men that they would not fall when halberd or v bills struck them on one of them at once[;] howbeit the our bills quit them [the English] very well and did more good that day than bows, for they shortly disappointed the Scots of their long spears, wherein was their greatest trust, and when they came to handstrokes, though the scots fought sore and valiantly with their swords, yet they could not resist the bills that lighted so thick and sore upon them."
- Thomas Ruthall, letter to Thomas Wolsey, 1513
These sources are from veteran soldiers who knew what they were talking about, so as a contemporary source it doesnāt get much better.
āSince, when bearers of weapons are armoured in white and heavy armour and fighting on horseback, they use, above all other weapons, what is called stocchi [estoc] in the vernacular..."
ā¢ā Pietro Monte, 16th century
āFor even though we strike him with a club, [poll]axe, and points, this inflicts little or no harm, especially if he is somewhat wise, for against similar we can never apply great blows when he always turns aside or enters in where we can make a small blow on him; which he who is entirely in white armour cares nothing for.ā
ā¢ā Pietro Monte
āIf we are in armor, we should attack the parts that are less protected, such as the visor, armpit, navel, groin, and feet.ā
ā¢ā Idem
āConcerning the arm-harness, we should pay close attention to the shoulders and armpits, for hammer-blows often strike at the shoulders, while estocs or swords thrust at the armpits.ā
⢠Idem
"And you must hold your lance in your hand and placed in the pouch. And setting off at the gallop, placing your lance in the lance-rest, aim for the enemyās belly, and once the lance is broken, you shall take hold of the estoc [estoque], which should be strapped onto the left-hand side of the front arƧon, secured in place in such a way that when you draw it the scabbard does not come with it.
āAnd when fighting with these weapons, strike at the visor and the voids, that is, the belly and the armpits. After you have lost or broken the estoc, you shall take hold of the arming sword [espada de armas], which shall be girded on your left-hand side, and fighting until you have lost or broken it, you shall take hold of the hammer [martillo], which shall be attached to the right-hand side of the belt with its hook. ā
Reaching down, you shall find it, and pulling upwards, the hook will release and, with hammer in hand, you shall do what you can with it until you lose it. And after it is lost, you shall reach behind you and draw the dagger from behind your back.
And you shall grapple with your enemy with all these weapons that you have at your disposal, striking and aiming at the voids, that is, the belly and the armpits, and at the visor, with the estoc or sword and with the hammer in hand, for by wounding the head and the hands he will inevitably surrender."
ā¢ā Juan Quijada de Reayo
Of course it didnāt make one invincible & isnāt the sole factor for winning wars; The advantage it provides against missile weapons (even firearms in the 16th & 17th C.) alone is enough to be worth it.
Its advantages are undeniable. Here are some historical sources from actual 16th Century soldiers discussing its advantages, and how to defeat it; singlehanded blunt weapons are actually not super effective against plate unless its a polearm-Even then they could withstand multiple blows that would completely incapacitate someone w/o plate armor. But donāt just take my word for itā¦
Battle of Flodden Field in 1513 is a great example.šš»
"The said Scots were so surely harnessed with complete harnesses, Jacks, almain rivets, splints, pavises, and other habiliments that [the] shot of arrows in regard did them no harm, and when it came to hand strikes of bill and halberds, they were so mighty, large, strong, and great men that they would not fall when halberd or v bills struck them on one of them at once[;] howbeit the our bills quit them [the English] very well and did more good that day than bows, for they shortly disappointed the Scots of their long spears, wherein was their greatest trust, and when they came to handstrokes, though the scots fought sore and valiantly with their swords, yet they could not resist the bills that lighted so thick and sore upon them."
- Thomas Ruthall, letter to Thomas Wolsey, 1513
These sources are from veteran soldiers who knew what they were talking about, so as a contemporary source it doesnāt get much better.
āSince, when bearers of weapons are armoured in white and heavy armour and fighting on horseback, they use, above all other weapons, what is called stocchi [estoc] in the vernacular..."
ā¢ā Pietro Monte, 16th century
āFor even though we strike him with a club, [poll]axe, and points, this inflicts little or no harm, especially if he is somewhat wise, for against similar we can never apply great blows when he always turns aside or enters in where we can make a small blow on him; which he who is entirely in white armour cares nothing for.ā
ā¢ā Pietro Monte
āIf we are in armor, we should attack the parts that are less protected, such as the visor, armpit, navel, groin, and feet.ā
ā¢ā Idem
āConcerning the arm-harness, we should pay close attention to the shoulders and armpits, for hammer-blows often strike at the shoulders, while estocs or swords thrust at the armpits.ā
⢠Idem
"And you must hold your lance in your hand and placed in the pouch. And setting off at the gallop, placing your lance in the lance-rest, aim for the enemyās belly, and once the lance is broken, you shall take hold of the estoc [estoque], which should be strapped onto the left-hand side of the front arƧon, secured in place in such a way that when you draw it the scabbard does not come with it.
āAnd when fighting with these weapons, strike at the visor and the voids, that is, the belly and the armpits. After you have lost or broken the estoc, you shall take hold of the arming sword [espada de armas], which shall be girded on your left-hand side, and fighting until you have lost or broken it, you shall take hold of the hammer [martillo], which shall be attached to the right-hand side of the belt with its hook. ā
Reaching down, you shall find it, and pulling upwards, the hook will release and, with hammer in hand, you shall do what you can with it until you lose it. And after it is lost, you shall reach behind you and draw the dagger from behind your back.
And you shall grapple with your enemy with all these weapons that you have at your disposal, striking and aiming at the voids, that is, the belly and the armpits, and at the visor, with the estoc or sword and with the hammer in hand, for by wounding the head and the hands he will inevitably surrender."
ā¢ā Juan Quijada de Reayo