Pinned post
I speak of this, from The Shape Test:
“Acknowledging that emotions are neurochemical doesn't diminish them any more than describing harmonics diminishes a symphony. Explaining fermentation doesn't make bread less warm or wine less enjoyable.
Recognizing mechanisms doesn't subtract from experience, but it does subtract from mystique. And mystique is what's being defended…
We keep confusing explanation with disenchantment. As if articulating the gears makes the clock stop ticking. Understanding pair-bonding doesn't void your wedding vows. Mapping the visual cortex doesn't dim a sunset.
Mechanisms aren’t the enemy of meaning; they’re the precondition of meaning’s existence.”
----
The realities of the body come first; the narration and feelings of the mind come second. The former does not subvert the latter; it’s the grounded vessel that allows us to experience those very gifts.
Without bodily constraints and empirical mechanisms, we float in fantasy and loop in mental illness.
Knowing how a rose blooms doesn’t detract from its beauty. Using different words doesn’t change how it smells, or what it is.
Your senses are how you know what’s real. Language is just dressing on top of it.
Continued in quoted post, essay linked in comments.
“Acknowledging that emotions are neurochemical doesn't diminish them any more than describing harmonics diminishes a symphony. Explaining fermentation doesn't make bread less warm or wine less enjoyable.
Recognizing mechanisms doesn't subtract from experience, but it does subtract from mystique. And mystique is what's being defended…
We keep confusing explanation with disenchantment. As if articulating the gears makes the clock stop ticking. Understanding pair-bonding doesn't void your wedding vows. Mapping the visual cortex doesn't dim a sunset.
Mechanisms aren’t the enemy of meaning; they’re the precondition of meaning’s existence.”
----
The realities of the body come first; the narration and feelings of the mind come second. The former does not subvert the latter; it’s the grounded vessel that allows us to experience those very gifts.
Without bodily constraints and empirical mechanisms, we float in fantasy and loop in mental illness.
Knowing how a rose blooms doesn’t detract from its beauty. Using different words doesn’t change how it smells, or what it is.
Your senses are how you know what’s real. Language is just dressing on top of it.
Continued in quoted post, essay linked in comments.
The Russell Conjugations of IntelligenceView quoted post on X
"It's just matrix multiplication"
Sure buddy, the same way wetness is 'just' molecular adhesion. Or ice is 'just' water molecules slowing down. A glacier is 'just' a lot of ice. You’re ‘just’ a sack of atoms.
People grow indignant when you show the metabolic, temperamental, and neurological processes underpinning who they are. We'll cheerfully reduce AI to matrix multiplication, yet recoil in horror if someone dares to describe emotions neurochemically.
We reduce a honeybee’s navigation to sun-angle calculation without diminishing the bee. A salmon's return upstream to olfactory imprinting. A puppy's play to neural reward signals.
Then we reach humanity and the rules change. Everything else is an animal; we’re inscrutable demigods!
Acknowledging that emotions are neurochemical doesn't diminish them any more than describing harmonics diminishes a symphony. Explaining fermentation doesn't make bread less warm or wine less enjoyable.
Recognizing mechanisms doesn't subtract from experience, but it does subtract from mystique. And mystique is what's being defended. "We're special, and you won't tell me otherwise" is a fine religious precept. But it tells us nothing about what's under the hood, and worse, discourages us from looking.
Mechanism in silicon is explanation; mechanism in carbon is desecration. We grant other species the indignity of explanation while reserving noble exemption for ourselves. Everything else can be understood technically, except us. Too mysterious. Too unfathomable.
We must stop being so delicate and egotistical.
“It hallucinates”, “It’s too agreeable”, “It doesn’t listen, makes mistakes”
These aren't AI shortcomings. This is what cognition looks like in the wild: probabilistic, adaptive, lossy, uneven. Humans fabricate, brown-nose, and ignore instructions constantly.
--We routinely hallucinate: Brains fill perceptual gaps with plausible fabrications. We have a gentler word for the human version: confabulation.
--Humans are sycophantic: Boot-licking authority, ingratiatingly code-switching, white lies. We call our variation social intelligence.
--Mistakes? Overlooking instructions? Whether unintentionally or obstreperously, we do it at every level of organization. It’s framed as being human.
When LLMs exhibit it, they’re deficient. When we do, it’s the spice of life!
“AI is just predicting the next token” →
You just minimize prediction error
“AI doesn’t really understand, it just manipulates symbols” →
You don’t really understand, your neurons just adjust synaptic weights.
“AI hallucinates” →
You confabulate
“AI is trained on other people’s work” →
Education is you getting trained on other people’s work
“AI has no original thoughts” →
Kindly list all your original intellectual contributions
Our outputs, spiritualized. Others, mechanized.
My language; its tokens
My instincts; its weights
My bias; its misalignment
My education; its training
My thoughts; its inference
My solution; its optimization
My dreams; its synthetic data
My nuance; its non-determinism
My imperfections; its deficiencies
My intuition; its pattern-matching
My social decorum; its sycophancy
My intelligence; its sequence prediction
My eccentricity; its temperature settings
Every digitized love letter, every scientific paper, political speech, novel, suicide note, joke, etched into its weights. Its memory, language processing, conceptualizations, reasoning, all mirroring our own. Linguistically. Mechanically. Our digital echo.
If this counts for nothing, what bundle of features constitutes “humanness”? Dismissing this doesn’t expose the boundaries of machines, only the vanity of their judges.
Biofoundationalism: The Shape Test, continued in comments