People often mistake the corroboration of testimony for the corroboration of fact. Confirming that a claim was made consistently only proves what was said, not that the underlying event actually occurred.
This post illustrates the corroboration of testimony, and how easily it can pass for proof of fact.
If I was living in an apartment complex and I told 9 people that I went to the swimming pool on a specific afternoon, that would be like providing an alibi for myself in case somebody accused me of being involved in an event that ALLEGEDLY took place during that same window.
Of course, those 9 people aren’t witnesses that I was at the swimming pool, as they can only testify that I TOLD them I went there.
Having 9 separate people who all confirm I told them I was at the pool that afternoon gives the claim real weight. They can each describe when I mentioned it, how sure I sounded at the time, and any details I may have included about the water or who else was around. When their accounts line up and none of them has a reason to cover for me, the fact that I said I was there has been corroborated across multiple sources, which makes it much harder to dismiss the idea that I actually went.
HOWEVER… notice the glaring issue with that type of evidence?
None of those 9 people actually SAW me at the swimming pool.
All they can do is REPEAT what I told them, which means every single one of their accounts TRACES straight back to the same SINGLE SOURCE: me.
No matter how many people heard the story, how consistent the details were, or how credible they seemed when they repeated it, the underlying claim never gains any independent support. It remains exactly what it started as, which is one person’s word about where they went, simply passed along to others who had no way of knowing whether it was true.
In the end, it’s still a single account that has been REPACKAGED to appear more credible than it is.
Under normal circumstances, this kind of secondhand account is usually fine, but the moment the stakes are high enough that the actual fact has to be established, the gap between what was said and what was seen becomes impossible to ignore.
This post illustrates the corroboration of testimony, and how easily it can pass for proof of fact.
If I was living in an apartment complex and I told 9 people that I went to the swimming pool on a specific afternoon, that would be like providing an alibi for myself in case somebody accused me of being involved in an event that ALLEGEDLY took place during that same window.
Of course, those 9 people aren’t witnesses that I was at the swimming pool, as they can only testify that I TOLD them I went there.
Having 9 separate people who all confirm I told them I was at the pool that afternoon gives the claim real weight. They can each describe when I mentioned it, how sure I sounded at the time, and any details I may have included about the water or who else was around. When their accounts line up and none of them has a reason to cover for me, the fact that I said I was there has been corroborated across multiple sources, which makes it much harder to dismiss the idea that I actually went.
HOWEVER… notice the glaring issue with that type of evidence?
None of those 9 people actually SAW me at the swimming pool.
All they can do is REPEAT what I told them, which means every single one of their accounts TRACES straight back to the same SINGLE SOURCE: me.
No matter how many people heard the story, how consistent the details were, or how credible they seemed when they repeated it, the underlying claim never gains any independent support. It remains exactly what it started as, which is one person’s word about where they went, simply passed along to others who had no way of knowing whether it was true.
In the end, it’s still a single account that has been REPACKAGED to appear more credible than it is.
Under normal circumstances, this kind of secondhand account is usually fine, but the moment the stakes are high enough that the actual fact has to be established, the gap between what was said and what was seen becomes impossible to ignore.