Twitxy Saved

BrickmuppetVT

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@Brickmuppet

Moving onward and upward out of sheer SPITE!
The Internet (Help!) twitch.tv/brickmuppet Joined March 2008
93 Following 108 Followers 1.1K Posts

Latest posts 5

BrickmuppetVT Verified account @Brickmuppet
She nails this.

Besides the instances she mentions, there are vast differences between Northern & Southern Europe, Western, Central, & Eastern Europe and blood feuds between nationalities that go back Millennia.

Some of the more authoritarian cultures are actually trauma responses to things like the 30 Years war (see Prussia, which basically took over northern German culture like a phage).

We gloss over these things because compared to some other cultures, that are built on an entirely different moral and religious framework, these incredibly diverse societies from Europe are much closer to each other by comparison.
Sensurround Verified account @ShamashAran 9h
Oh, honey. No.

Europeans didn't just fight over land and resources. They fought over fundamentally incompatible cultural, religious, and political values.

Let's have a little history lesson, shall we?

The French Wars of Religion (1562–1598):
French Catholics and French Protestants spent decades killing each other over, among other things, which version of Christianity should dominate French society.

Same country. Same broad ancestry. Wildly incompatible religious values.

The Thirty Years' War (1618–1648):
Central Europe was devastated by a conflict involving Catholicism, Protestantism, political authority, and competing visions of European society. Apparently, all that shared European cultural evolution didn't settle the question of whose religion should govern.

The English Civil Wars (1642–1651):
The English literally fought other English people over the authority of the monarchy, the rights of Parliament, and religion. They even chopped their own king's head off.

But sure. Just a little misunderstanding about real estate.

And here's the part that makes your argument particularly entertaining. These weren't simply different European ethnic groups fighting each other. In several cases, people sharing the same nationality, language, ancestry, and centuries of history were killing each other over incompatible beliefs about how society should function.

Now, of course Europeans have shared cultural influences. Nobody disputes that.

But you're trying to turn "European societies share certain historical characteristics" into "European ancestry reliably indicates compatible cultural values."

Those are two VERY different propositions.

A White communist and a White libertarian can have fundamentally incompatible ideas about property, liberty, and government. A Black libertarian and a White libertarian can share nearly identical ones.

Culture isn't determined exclusively by ancestry.

If you're trying to determine whether someone shares your cultural values, perhaps you should examine their actual cultural values. I realize this is a radical proposition, but do try to keep up.
View quoted post on X