Twitxy Saved

Chris Richardson

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@ChrisEconomist

Chris from Accounts
Sydney Australia richinsight.com.au Joined March 2022
152 Following 7.6K Followers 2.7K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Chris Richardson Verified account @ChrisEconomist
Some key posts –

Why I love budgets – x.com/chriseconomist…

Why solving the cost of living crisis isn’t easy (& why subsidies hurt rather than help) – x.com/chriseconomist…

What caused the surplus – x.com/chriseconomist…

Why inflation is the disease (& cost-of-living problems are the symptoms) – x.com/chriseconomist…

A reasonable ask for the budget – x.com/chriseconomist…

Best case scenario for the budget – x.com/chriseconomist…

And my detailed pre-budget thoughts – x.com/chriseconomist…
Chris Richardson Verified account @ChrisEconomist Apr 30, 2024
What caused the surplus?

On budget night a year ago I said there’d be another surplus this year

That now looks a done deal

How’d that happen? And why did I expect a surplus?
View quoted post on X
22 replies 13 reposts 63 likes 45K views View on X
Chris Richardson Verified account @ChrisEconomist
GOOD STICKY TAPE?? OR NOT??

Allegra Spender suggests changing the new CGT arrangements outside of property - going back to the discount approach, but at 40% rather than 50%

That wouldn't be the best outcome, but it is probably better than what we're otherwise getting

Let me step back for a moment

Remember that it absolutely makes sense to tax capital income differently to how we tax wages

1). Partly that's because we tax wages immediately, but we only tax capital gains after they're realised. So, unless we adjust for it, part of the gain we're otherwise taxing is simply inflation

2). Partly it's because we tax a capital gain as if it has been earned all at once - even though it's usually been earned over some years. As we have a progressive tax system, that lumpiness can unfairly push people into a higher tax bracket

3). And partly it is because we need to save before we can earn a return on those savings, so taxing those returns therefore means we tax savers more than we tax spenders

That backdrop means that ideally we should:
1). adjust for inflation,
2). average out capital gains, and
3). provide a discount relative to the tax on wages

But that's not what the government has done

Yes, it has allowed indexation for inflation. But it didn't allow averaging to smooth out the lumpiness of returns. (Instead, it put in a minimum tax rate). And it didn't allow for any ongoing discount

And, although it has allowed for inflation indexation, that's only on gains - not on losses. That doesn't matter much for property. But it does for shares - effectively boosting the tax rate on portfolios

That backdrop means three things

First, that Australia has gone from taxing capital gains too little to taxing them too much, with both the old and new systems being less than ideal

Second, the Allegra option therefore needs to be compared with the government's legislation - not with perfection. And on that front the Allegra option is, in my view, the better bet

Third, it looks to me as if the government's estimates of the revenue it'll raise through its approach are too low. It has tried so hard to plug potential loopholes that it has overegged its rules and underegged its estimated tax take. In turn, that says to me that the Allegra option won't hurt the bottom line versus the costings in the budget

The bottom line?

The Allegra option isn't perfect

But perfect isn't on the menu

So count me in
40 replies 19 reposts 105 likes 12K views View on X
Chris Richardson Verified account @ChrisEconomist
HELP!!

Can Canberra help in the fight against inflation?

Yes it can. But it's pretty late to that particular party, and government decisions move the dial slowly at best

So you shouldn't expect much

Yet, regardless of inflation implications, there's still a great case for federal and state budget repair anyway - much of our spending is silly, much of our taxing is terrible, and deficits are too high

And the side effect of a bit of help on the inflation fight would be very nice to have

So ... how can you know if Canberra's coming budget update will actually help in the inflation fight or not?

No, a better-than-budgeted deficit isn't what to look for

Despite the cost of elevated interest rates, the combo of higher than budgeted inflation and population has the budget outperforming right now (as both boost the tax take more than they do spending). Solid prices for stuff we sell the world are also helping (especially versus the official estimates of a rapid drop in those prices)

So "budget looks better" would merely be the result of what economists call automatic stabilisers, NOT of government action or inaction

Rather, two other measures could give a rather cleaner measure of how much effort that Canberra makes in its budget update

The first is my old favourite - the Table of Truth

Buried deep in the budget papers, it'll tell you the impact of recent government decisions on the underlying budget deficit in 2026-27

No, it isn't a perfect measure. For example, it excludes off-budget spending, as well as any decisions not taken by Cabinet (such as the cost to taxpayers of wage decisions that the government supports, but with the decision there taken by the Fair Work Commission). But it ain't bad

A second measure of the government's effort would be the change in Treasury's estimate of the structural budget deficit in 2026-27

You'll have to eyeball that off a chart buried even deeper still in the budget papers, and there's lots of measurement questions there. But it provides a top down check on the bottom up numbers implied in the Table of Truth

How much of a difference could government decisions make?

Forgive me for a truly huge generalisation here, but in rough terms government decisions that saved $8bn in 2026-27 would allow the RBA to have interest rates 0.25% lower than they'd otherwise have been

Final word? The inflation challenge is here and now, and chances are that any help from government decisions to restrain its reach won't prove make or break in the Reserve Bank's juggle

Regardless, though, there is still a very good case for governments to be more careful, and there are better measures of how hard they're actually trying on that front than the simple test of "we're doing better than we budgeted to do"

(Finally McFinal word - oppositions need to agree to more savings rather than grandstanding, and the states need to act too.)
2 replies 2 reposts 12 likes 1.7K views View on X
Chris Richardson Verified account @ChrisEconomist
SOME THOUGHTS WHILE TRAVELLING

So I'll put them down here ...

No, I don't think government spending is the main driver of inflation in Australia

Yes, I do think that government spending has increased notably, and that it has made the RBA's task of inflation fighting harder (especially so in 2023 and 2024)

Yes, regardless, I do think that the RBA has to bear the brunt of the inflation fight

No, I don't think the RBA's rate rises can stop wars or cause oil prices to fall. But yes, rate rises can reduce demand, getting it closer to supply, and so are still the best way to fight inflation

No, I don't think alternative ways to fight inflation are painless. We get to pick the poison, but it is still poison

Yes, even though inflation in Australia in 2026 isn't particularly driven by government spending any more, there are good reasons for governments to be pulling back (the structural deficit has risen notably in recent years, and the quality of both our spending and our taxing is poor).

Yes, to the extent that pullback by governments happens sooner rather than later, it can help lower inflation

No, savings to help fight inflation aren't the same thing as savings to repair the structural deficit - those two are linked but not an exact match

For example we should tax gas better, but that wouldn't help against inflation here in Australia

And we should be building more and better infrastructure (and also charging for it better). But, especially amid the data centre building rush, there is a good case to slow federal and state infrastructure spending💰. That could be achieved via a reduced federal share of any State construction costs incurred over the next 18 months (meaning there's an incentive for the states to slow down their capex)

Then there is the area of overlap - where savings that could help BOTH longer term structural and fighting inflation

That list would include everything from the WA GST deal, speeding up the reforms to the NDIS, cutting dodgy grant schemes, equalising PHI subsidies for the over 65s, lifting deeming rates for pensioners, reducing the less effective elements of support for housing and for the energy transition, the allied health entitlements of veterans, pulling back from taxpayer bailouts of failing businesses, providing genuine scrutiny to the Future Made In Australia spending, plus an assessment of how to use AI to get much better value from the public service and from consultants

And, if we are willing to tackle our poor spending, we should be equally willing to tackle our poor taxing - there's plenty of that too!
37 replies 29 reposts 131 likes 8.4K views View on X
Chris Richardson Verified account @ChrisEconomist
AN EXTRA $170bn? WE SHOULD HAVE BEEN TOLD ABOUT THAT

There's a new budget story out ...

In brief, it notes the recent improvement in the forecast budget bottom line was way smaller than expected given the large savings recently made by the government.

The gap between those two things is very large, weighing in at around $170bn in the first half of the coming decade.

By way of yardstick, that's roughly the equivalent of adding an extra Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme to the costs taxpayers need to finance every year.

So, umm, yes. That's a lot.

Two things stand out - that

(1) existing policies keep costing more than budgeted, and that

(2) Australians aren't being appropriately informed about that.

Both of those things worry me.

At a lazy extra $170 billion, the dollars are massive. To the government's absolute credit, its decisions on NDIS and CGT saved a lot of money. And they're losing political skin because of those decisions.

But those huge savings only led to a modest improvement in the budget bottom line.

The savings were mostly eaten up. But we don't know what ate them - frustratingly, it was a mystery money monster.

My best guess is that existing policies simply ended up costing more than previously forecast (with hospital costs potentially a part of that).

I've been writing about Canberra's growing challenges with cost forecasting for a while, and this says that problem keeps getting more expensive.

But the mystery is why this had to be such a mystery in the first place. The federal budget is our national social compact, and there could be few things more vital to inform Australians about than a massive extra increase in coming costs.

So why wasn't the public informed? Why did this have to be revealed in a newspaper story rather than in a discussion in the budget papers?

I don't get it.

If the future is more expensive than we thought it was going to be, then we need a national conversation on how to pay for that.

Hiding from that conversation doesn't help anyone.

The cover up usually creates way more problems than it is worth ...