Twitxy Saved

Clive Bates

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@Clive_Bates

What's right thing to do? Been with IBM, Greenpeace, ASH, Cabinet Office, Environment Agency, UN in Sudan, Welsh Government, DECC and now my own Counterfactual.
London or Derbyshire, UK clivebates.substack.com Joined February 2011
1.5K Following 14K Followers 25K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Clive Bates Verified account @Clive_Bates
Me: Is it possible that something this appalling could happen in fields other than environmental science? 👇

Public health: Hold my beer. We can win this…!

H/t
@TamarHaspel
@ArielleSelya
@FloeFoxon
Tamar Haspel @TamarHaspel 1d
How Crap Science Drives Public Opinion

A story in 3 acts.

Act 1: Enviro group publishes crap study on link between nitrate levels in drinking water & cancer in peer-reviewed journal. (It's not hard!)
sciencedirect.com/science/articl…
View quoted post on X
Clive Bates Verified account @Clive_Bates
Alex is rightly annoyed by coercive measures to control the personal behaviours and preferences of adults. 🧵 👇

I suspect most people still think the Smokefree Generation is about protecting youth (wrong, it’s an adult-only measure) and about smoke (no, it’s more than that).
Alex Verified account @Admalez 2d
This policy is an outrageous violation of personal liberties and it institutionalises blatantly unjust age discrimination. It is also impractical to the point of absurdity. It's a disgrace. Adults should have agency over their own bodies.
View quoted post on X
0 replies 9 reposts 30 likes 695 views View on X
Clive Bates Verified account @Clive_Bates
Just on the basis of the fields I know something about (climate, energy, environment, public health), the science that scientists want to save is rarely the science that challenges their priors or punctures a bubble of groupthink. Calls to elevate or protect science are rarely about replication, data sleuthing, or openness - more often a cry for reinforcements to silence contrarian views. “Science” as practiced is pretty poor as true scientific inquiry. Way too much is pointless, flawed, or misrepresented. The profession seems to be unusually attractive to bullies and narcissists - or maybe the pettiness of academic competition selects for those traits.

@ArielleSelya
Arielle Selya Verified account @ArielleSelya 3d
To be honest, I’ve always found partisan calls for “save the science” and “science is back” cringey, but I had trouble articulating it until I read this post.

Liz hits the nail on the head with how some of it (sounds? is?) elitist and self-serving for the scientists instead of the general public.

But I think that’s only part of it and I will go further. Many pro-science rallying cries just seem to be asking for more science funding without acknowledging the deep problems in science and a plan to address them. People who feel that “the science” has harmed them or is opposing their needs (and this is legitimately happening) are not going to be supportive of more taxpayer dollars perpetuating this.

No, we can’t always know which science will lead to discoveries that will improve quality of life, but in my field alone there is a massive amount of money being spent on research that is unproductive, or worse, opposing and gatekeeping progress. And I don’t believe my field is unique.

More money is not going to help when the whole system is broken and full of perverse incentives.

fromthescienceclass.substack.com/p/can-we-pleas…
View quoted post on X
1 replies 11 reposts 29 likes 898 views View on X
Clive Bates Verified account @Clive_Bates
Awesome debate ahead: who is the worst regulator for nicotine products: the U.S. FDA or the EU? Both can claim the title "most useless regulator", but who has the edge? And will it stay that way?

Visit @quitlikesweden to sign up: evening, 2 Dec, Central London. Should be fun.
Quit Like Sweden Verified account @quitlikesweden 5d
Introducing @Clive_Bates, our second speaker for “Whose Rules? The US, the EU and the Future of Nicotine Regulation”, a live debate taking place in London on 2 December.

He is a public health and sustainability advocate with a diverse background across the public, private, and non-profit sectors. He led Action on Smoking and Health (UK) from 1997 to 2003 and later worked in senior roles in government, including the UK Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit and the United Nations in Sudan. He is now Director of Counterfactual, a consultancy promoting pragmatic approaches to public health and sustainability.

Find out more and register: quitlikesweden.org/event/london20…
View quoted post on X