Twitxy Saved

Brian Hernandez

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@CoachBHern

Fort Worth, TX Joined February 2018
3.3K Following 7.2K Followers 446 Posts

Latest posts 5

Brian Hernandez Verified account @CoachBHern
If you need to add a win minimum that overrules the algorithm, you have the wrong algorithm. Start there and get rid of MaxPreps.

In the current 6A format, a win minimum would only add to the problems. When 20 of 29 teams make the playoffs, it is inevitable that some of the teams that qualify will have ugly records. Take 2-8 Casteel: second-hardest schedule, numerous one-score losses, two dominant wins over quality opponents, and no losses to non-playoff teams. It can be argued that they are ranked too high, but there is no doubt they deserve to be in the 20-team field. This is a far cry from 2-8 Boulder Creek, which lacked a signature win and lost every game by at least two scores, including a three-score loss to Corona.
Richard Obert @azc_obert Nov 9
AIA pledges to review HS football ranking system after outcry azcentral.com/story/sports/h… via @azcentral
View quoted post on X
4 replies 1 reposts 20 likes 2.6K views View on X
Brian Hernandez Verified account @CoachBHern
“Cumulative strength of schedule for the teams a school defeats during the season… are part of the final outcome.” Did they use the same MaxPreps AI to write this press release? Does anybody double-check this garbage before it goes out?

Taken literally, this means a school gets credit for the total SOS of every team it beats. That rewards stacking wins against bad teams that happen to play tough schedules, and since it’s a total rather than an average, every win is a big boost no matter who it’s against.

I assume they meant “average rating of the teams a school defeats,” which is just a long way of saying Strength of Victory. That would be valid. The problem is that SOV isn’t a direct input in the MaxPreps formula. SOV is considered indirectly, but not enough to overcome bus bonuses.

For perspective: the sum rating total of BC’s lone 2 wins (74.92) is lower than the rating of Corona’s best win (75.22).
Adam Beadle Verified account @therealbeadle Nov 7
The AIA just sent an email to statewide media regarding the final football rankings and MaxPreps’ formula:

“Following an exciting conclusion to the football regular season for all conferences, the brackets are now live for the 6A and Open Divisions, and each of those teams are set to begin their playoff runs using a rankings formula maintained by MaxPreps that has been utilized all season.
 
The current version of the MaxPreps formula was new this year to the AIA and endorsed by football coaches from around the state.
 
Cumulative strength of schedule for the teams a school defeats during the season and the matchups between two higher-ranked teams at any point during the season are factors that are a part of the final outcome.
 
For more information, the following FAQ page breaks down some aspects of the formula, which is located on the football rankings page on AZPreps365.com.
 
azpreps365.com/rankings/faq
 
The AIA wishes the teams now starting their postseason journeys, as well as the squads making their way through all postseason brackets, the best of luck.”

@AZHSFB
View quoted post on X
1 replies 5 reposts 11 likes 2.5K views View on X
Brian Hernandez Verified account @CoachBHern
The warning signs concerning the integrity of the @MaxPreps algorithm have been there for weeks. MP failed miserably at the one job they had, but the real disappointment is with the AIA, who is complicit in this clown show. They used the very kids they were meant to protect as guinea pigs in an experiment to find a formula that shields them from any blame. Coaches and players are held accountable every day, but there will be no accountability at the AIA. There won’t even be a “We are sorry, we made a mistake.” Instead, they will cite SOS and say this is what coaches and ADs wanted. Within a week this will all blow over, the AIA will rake in the money during the playoffs, and there will likely be a change next season. Meanwhile, there are kids across the state who earned playoff berths…only to have their hopes crushed because the people in charge would not do anything about a system they knew was broken.
9 replies 16 reposts 93 likes 36K views View on X