If you need to add a win minimum that overrules the algorithm, you have the wrong algorithm. Start there and get rid of MaxPreps.
In the current 6A format, a win minimum would only add to the problems. When 20 of 29 teams make the playoffs, it is inevitable that some of the teams that qualify will have ugly records. Take 2-8 Casteel: second-hardest schedule, numerous one-score losses, two dominant wins over quality opponents, and no losses to non-playoff teams. It can be argued that they are ranked too high, but there is no doubt they deserve to be in the 20-team field. This is a far cry from 2-8 Boulder Creek, which lacked a signature win and lost every game by at least two scores, including a three-score loss to Corona.
In the current 6A format, a win minimum would only add to the problems. When 20 of 29 teams make the playoffs, it is inevitable that some of the teams that qualify will have ugly records. Take 2-8 Casteel: second-hardest schedule, numerous one-score losses, two dominant wins over quality opponents, and no losses to non-playoff teams. It can be argued that they are ranked too high, but there is no doubt they deserve to be in the 20-team field. This is a far cry from 2-8 Boulder Creek, which lacked a signature win and lost every game by at least two scores, including a three-score loss to Corona.
AIA pledges to review HS football ranking system after outcry azcentral.com/story/sports/h… via @azcentralView quoted post on X