Twitxy Saved

DatPolySciGuy

@DatPolySciGuy

Christian | Ritus Romanus | Liberty promoter | Self Preservation is a Human Right | Private Spaceflight
TN Joined June 2011
737 Following 769 Followers 8.4K Posts

Latest posts 5

DatPolySciGuy @DatPolySciGuy
Mary actually illustrates the Catholic principle beautifully. Grace doesnt compete with freedom, it perfects it. God preserved Mary from original sin, making her more, not less free. She freely answered, “Let it be done to me.” God's sovereignty doesnt require irresistible grace.
Pastor Rick Brennan Jr Verified account @rickbrennanjr Aug 11
Roman Catholics reject the Reformed doctrine of irresistible grace in salvation, yet Catholic dogma teaches that God gave Mary a special grace that preserved her from committing a single sin throughout her entire life. So apparently God can give grace that infallibly accomplishes his purpose without destroying human freedom.

And this isn’t just an argument from Mary. Thomas Aquinas makes the principle explicitly in Summa Theologiae I–II, q.112, a.3, where he state that when God moves someone toward grace there is a necessity “not indeed of coercion, but of infallibility,” because God’s intention cannot fail. If God intends to move someone to grace, Aquinas concludes, “he will infallibly attain to it.”

So, Roman Catholics reject the Reformed doctrine of irresistible grace in salvation, yet Catholic dogma teaches that God gave Mary a special grace that preserved her from committing a single sin throughout her entire life. So apparently God can give grace that infallibly accomplishes his purpose without destroying human freedom.

Thus, the real disagreement between Catholics and Reformed Protestants on irresistible grace isn’t whether God can give grace that infallibly accomplishes what he intends. Catholic theology already says he can. The disagreement is over when and how God does it, with Reformed theologians arguing that God grants it when he wills, while Catholics seem to restrain God’s sovereign choice to issues that support the needs of their tradition that has no scriptural basis.
View quoted post on X
DatPolySciGuy @DatPolySciGuy
Rom 10:13 relates to the Church's covenantal worship which under the New Covenant is concretely realized in Baptism/culminates in Eucharistic participation. Protestants often flatten "call upon the name of the Lord" into "pray to Jesus." But Scripture traces a much richer pattern
DatPolySciGuy @DatPolySciGuy
Ephesians 2 is about union with Christ. St. Paul explicitly teaches elsewhere that baptism is the means by which believers are united to Christ. Ephs 1-4 presupposes Paul’s established baptismal theology. Trying to read Eph 2:8-9 as a proof text for faith alone flattens the text.
DatPolySciGuy @DatPolySciGuy
Ephs 1&2 describe being raised/seated with Christ. Paul explicitly says that happens in baptism elsewhere, the passage assumes a baptismal framework. Its not redefining salvation as faith alone, but explaining that this whole union with Christ is God’s gift, not human achievement