Twitxy Saved

Dave Keating

@DaveKeating

🇺🇸🇪🇺American by birth, European by choice 📘Read my book: TheOwnedContinent.eu ✍️Read my Substack: davekeating.substack.com
Brussels, Belgium DaveKeating.net Joined May 2008
3.3K Following 58K Followers 57K Posts

Latest posts 5

Dave Keating @DaveKeating
Kallas implies EU national leaders are being hypocrites on rule of law when they ignore the EU's treaties and they undermine the union.

But she seems to be ready to move on from their snub against her on Friday.
euronews @euronews 15h
High Representative Kaja Kallas remains defiant after EU leaders rejected her as special envoy for the peace talks.

"I stand by my words and I'm ready to do this job," she told Euronews' @JorgeLiboreiro.
View quoted post on X
7 replies 5 reposts 38 likes 4.2K views View on X
Dave Keating @DaveKeating
5 EU countries (🇩🇪🇦🇹🇩🇰🇳🇱🇬🇷) announced today they're starting a return hub programme with Rwanda – and will start deporting failed asylum seekers there in a few months.

It's the 1st use of the new 🇪🇺returns directive. Unlike in 🇬🇧, they won't deport until all appeals exhausted.
3:54
Dave Keating @DaveKeating
A talking point I've been using at speeches about my book recently is that "The United States of Europe" is perhaps the wrong framing for building European federalism - because this lets opponents say it's impossible because 🇪🇺 doesn't have one language like 🇺🇸.

A better comparison is India: a multilingual, multiethnic and multi-confessional federal state. Despite being made up of states with long histories that were separate for hundreds of years, after independence (other than the Muslim-majority states) India chose to maintain the unity forced upon them by an external power (the British) because they could see how being divided into many small-to-medium sized nations had allowed them to be easily divided and ruled by outsiders.

The same can be said of other countries such as Indonesia and many in Africa. Eurocentrism makes people here think the differences between Europeans are more important than those between the peoples of the Indian subcontinent. But we know where that kind of thinking comes from. Do you think India shouldn't exist because it's made up of different languages and cultures with hundreds of years of separate history? No? Then why do you immediately dismiss the idea that Europe could do the same?

Which language to use?

Here in this video, another interesting comparison emerges. English has been maintained as an official national language of India (along with Hindi) precisely because it is a neutral language that does't benefit any particular group. That's been at the insistence of the southern states, whose languages are not even in the same family as Hindi. That's interesting to think about when we hear French people insist that English should not be used as a lingua franca of the EU because it is now not the official language of any member state (Ireland being Irish and Malta being Maltese).

Now here's a stat that will blow your mind: the proportion of people in India who can speak and understand Hindi is roughly the same as the proportion in Europe who can speak and understand English. And yet, those who make a fetish of "multilingualism" (usually just a quixotic attempt to force French on people) tell us we shouldn't take advantage of this linguistic convergence to help build European federalism.

India should show Europeans two things:

🌏That it is desirable to have a multilingual federation made up of states with separate histories rather than be an irrelevant collection of independent small states.

🗣️That using an "outsider" language (the use of which is over time adapted and evolved to the local situation, just like with the Latin spoken in what became France) can actually be beneficial in serving as a neutral lingua franca and does not automatically mean servitude or influence.

I'd urge everyone in Europe to learn more about India. It's not a perfect country by any means, especially these days, and it is in truth more unitary (or "quasi-federal") than it should be. But the general point of comparison still applies.
youtube.com/watch?v=jGJDz0…
www.youtube.com India Gave English an Expiry Date. Why Is It Still Here? In 1950, India’s new constitution gave English fifteen more years. ...
1 replies 10 reposts 10 likes 2K views View on X
Dave Keating @DaveKeating
Spain's foreign minister criticises what happened in Dublin on Friday, which excluded not only the EU's foreign affairs chief but also Spain - which is left out of the 🇷🇺🇺🇦 negotiations.

He says @KajaKallas should not have been blocked and warns of a European "cacophony".
Emilio Ordiz @EmilioOrdiz 1d
🇪🇺🇪🇸 Albares marca la posición de España sobre el 'equipo' negociador con Rusia: avisa de que hay muchos actores y puede darse una "cacofonía" en el mensaje, asegura que Kallas tiene que estar y advierte que "no se decidirá nada" sin que España esté en la mesa.
View quoted post on X