Pinned post
Despotic Inroad
Verified account This account is verified. Learn more@DespoticInroad
Contributing Editor @UnHerd | Former policy hack @NewStatesman | Erratic Marxism with Blue Labour sympathies | EFC | Also: @RenewalJournal + @liverpoolpost
1.9K Following 6.2K Followers 8.9K Posts
Latest posts 5
Wrote about Milburn, & how Labourism became welfarism👇
Doing Nice Labour Things™️ like reducing inequality & combatting poverty used to mean:
👉National economic planning/Industrial Strategy backed by public ownership in key sectors + subsidy/tariff/capital control regimes
👉Large-scale & consistent investment in public capital stock/infrastructure/housing/R&D etc.
👉Fiscal policy oriented around demand management with "Full Employment" as explicit primary aim
👉Broad accommodation/cooperation with powerful trade union movement representing public AND private sector employees
Once you've abandoned that political economy (see New Labour), cash transfers/benefit entitlements become the principle mechanism for doing those Nice Labour Things™️. The modernisers' deal becomes: acquiesce to the basic Thatcherite settlement, leave the mode of production intact, but redistribute the spoils via the DWP + incrementally build up an enormous body of regulation to reign in a privatised, asset-stripped husk of an economy. That model is now broken, and this is the context in which a million young people now find themselves NEET.
Something has to give on welfare reform – it's necessary from the point of view of the current settlement. But the whole exercise tinkers with outcomes without addressing fundamental causes.
unherd.com/2026/11/milbur…
Doing Nice Labour Things™️ like reducing inequality & combatting poverty used to mean:
👉National economic planning/Industrial Strategy backed by public ownership in key sectors + subsidy/tariff/capital control regimes
👉Large-scale & consistent investment in public capital stock/infrastructure/housing/R&D etc.
👉Fiscal policy oriented around demand management with "Full Employment" as explicit primary aim
👉Broad accommodation/cooperation with powerful trade union movement representing public AND private sector employees
Once you've abandoned that political economy (see New Labour), cash transfers/benefit entitlements become the principle mechanism for doing those Nice Labour Things™️. The modernisers' deal becomes: acquiesce to the basic Thatcherite settlement, leave the mode of production intact, but redistribute the spoils via the DWP + incrementally build up an enormous body of regulation to reign in a privatised, asset-stripped husk of an economy. That model is now broken, and this is the context in which a million young people now find themselves NEET.
Something has to give on welfare reform – it's necessary from the point of view of the current settlement. But the whole exercise tinkers with outcomes without addressing fundamental causes.
unherd.com/2026/11/milbur…
The nearby data centre offer for residents is currently: “Would you like an energy-intensive eyesore that provides very few jobs but that helps boost US tech stocks while automating away your kids’ entry-level knowledge work?”🤔
Needless to say, that’s not a very attractive prospect! Yes, AI is here to stay, and yes, consumers/businesses will need massive compute + digital infrastructure very rapidly in order to remain internationally competitive. BUT people can’t be sold on the promise of faster access to generative content without lag+/LLM credits ("YOU GET MUCH QUICKER SLOP!👍👍!").
We need national ownership + true AI sovereignty + public stakes in AI companies/data centre rollouts IF we want AI adoption to reap broader rewards. Stuff like, for e.g:
👉Singapore's GIC/Temasek sovereign wealth fund/state investment vehicles partnering with Equinix to build data centres
👉Saudi PIF launching HUMAIN as fully-state owned AI infrastructure
👉Qatari & UAE sovereign wealth funds doing joint ventures/direct equity stake investments in AI companies
Frustratingly, the UK's National Wealth Fund is guaranteeing loans for data centres in Scotland to "crowd in" private £££, BUT WITHOUT ANY NWF/PUBLIC EQUITY STAKES. If we're on the verge of a Industrial Revolution-style productivity uptick then we need something approaching a Citizens' Dividend to ameliorate the likely labour market disruptions. If we want long-term control/revenues of this new tech to accrue to the British public then public pension funds/NWF etc. should be investing/owning directly, with the state backing projects strategically, not just taking the role of (bad) regulator/de-risker. Public investment should equal public returns. There's a good argument for public equity at the municipal/regional level too. Let a thousand Isambard-AI's bloom!
Needless to say, that’s not a very attractive prospect! Yes, AI is here to stay, and yes, consumers/businesses will need massive compute + digital infrastructure very rapidly in order to remain internationally competitive. BUT people can’t be sold on the promise of faster access to generative content without lag+/LLM credits ("YOU GET MUCH QUICKER SLOP!👍👍!").
We need national ownership + true AI sovereignty + public stakes in AI companies/data centre rollouts IF we want AI adoption to reap broader rewards. Stuff like, for e.g:
👉Singapore's GIC/Temasek sovereign wealth fund/state investment vehicles partnering with Equinix to build data centres
👉Saudi PIF launching HUMAIN as fully-state owned AI infrastructure
👉Qatari & UAE sovereign wealth funds doing joint ventures/direct equity stake investments in AI companies
Frustratingly, the UK's National Wealth Fund is guaranteeing loans for data centres in Scotland to "crowd in" private £££, BUT WITHOUT ANY NWF/PUBLIC EQUITY STAKES. If we're on the verge of a Industrial Revolution-style productivity uptick then we need something approaching a Citizens' Dividend to ameliorate the likely labour market disruptions. If we want long-term control/revenues of this new tech to accrue to the British public then public pension funds/NWF etc. should be investing/owning directly, with the state backing projects strategically, not just taking the role of (bad) regulator/de-risker. Public investment should equal public returns. There's a good argument for public equity at the municipal/regional level too. Let a thousand Isambard-AI's bloom!
Imagine you lived in a cold, wet, spacious, economically stagnant country with abundant renewable energy which is currently wasted because you have no customersView quoted post on X
Obviously you would campaign against data centres
~40/50 yrs ago, it was progressive Leftists who campaigned to lower the age of consent. On the more mental end of the London metropolitan New Left, there were people/organisations that saw paedophiles as a sexual category requiring "liberation"/"solidarity" in the same vein as homosexuality etc.
Today, the default, bien pensant Leftist position is:
1) A 9-year old CAN reliably determine that they were "born in the wrong body" and consent to taking life-altering drugs with permanent negative side effects
2) A 16-year old CANNOT reliably determine that they want to have sex with a 25-year-old and thus consent to sex
(And BTW, I'm on the more puritanical restrictionist side on all these issues, but at least that's consistent!)
Today, the default, bien pensant Leftist position is:
1) A 9-year old CAN reliably determine that they were "born in the wrong body" and consent to taking life-altering drugs with permanent negative side effects
2) A 16-year old CANNOT reliably determine that they want to have sex with a 25-year-old and thus consent to sex
(And BTW, I'm on the more puritanical restrictionist side on all these issues, but at least that's consistent!)
It’s absurd to suggest that a 17 year old bloke shouldn’t be allowed to sleep with a 25 year old woman in Britain.View quoted post on X
We’re opening up an insane and unenforceable web of ambiguity.
The sort of which is weaponised by later regret, heartache, or controlling parents who disapprove of certain relationships we consider to be consensual today.
Just look at the horror cases in America of 20 year olds who have faced prison time for *obviously consensual* sex with 17 year olds that parents disapprove of.
We won an absolute and equal age of consent for *everyone* in 2001. This was a progressive victory.
It’s sad that some are now looking at rolling back the absolute rights to bodily autonomy that post-pubescent individuals have enjoyed in this country for a quarter century.
Alan is right here. I think our sensitivity around Liverpool's national portrayal can get tiresome TBH. Also strange to see Mayor Rotheram criticise This City Is Ours when it's the beneficiary of investment from his own Liverpool City Region Production Fund.
Yes, it's about crime, but so are most original UK TV drama series.
And Scousers too often contradict themselves and want it all these ways:
1) We actively try and cultivate our own civic self-image as a gritty, working-class, streetwise, slightly wayward plebeian rebel culture
BUT...
B) We often complain when anyone tries to construct narratives based on this culture, saying they're indulging in "stereotypes"
BUT BUT BUT...
C) At the same time, if Scousers themselves diverge from the "Proper Scouse" norm of 110s & Montirex, Carragher accents, footie + ale pastimes (i.e. being too middle-class-coded, too refined, overly concerned with, say, high art or more bougie pursuits) then they're chastised as "wools", or "South End meffs" or somehow not authentically Scouse. No other city polices their own identity as militantly ("What colour's your bin, lad?!"). I love/hate this aspect of Liverpool – it's what gives the city its character, identity, cohesion, bolshie spirit/energy etc., but also leads to a quite stultifying parochialism
All of this has been distilled in some of the reaction to This City Is Ours (which FWIW I think is an excellent bit of light entertainment). In Liverpool, half the people are saying the characters aren't "Proper Scousers" (wrong clothes, not just the wrong accents), others love the show, and others saying it portrays the city in too negative a light (too much illegal activity). Well, for the latter tribe, guess what?: Nobody wants to watch a nice happy programme about well-adjusted, law-abiding normie Liverpolitans going about their lives. Even Brookside wasn't that. Get over it.
Yes, it's about crime, but so are most original UK TV drama series.
And Scousers too often contradict themselves and want it all these ways:
1) We actively try and cultivate our own civic self-image as a gritty, working-class, streetwise, slightly wayward plebeian rebel culture
BUT...
B) We often complain when anyone tries to construct narratives based on this culture, saying they're indulging in "stereotypes"
BUT BUT BUT...
C) At the same time, if Scousers themselves diverge from the "Proper Scouse" norm of 110s & Montirex, Carragher accents, footie + ale pastimes (i.e. being too middle-class-coded, too refined, overly concerned with, say, high art or more bougie pursuits) then they're chastised as "wools", or "South End meffs" or somehow not authentically Scouse. No other city polices their own identity as militantly ("What colour's your bin, lad?!"). I love/hate this aspect of Liverpool – it's what gives the city its character, identity, cohesion, bolshie spirit/energy etc., but also leads to a quite stultifying parochialism
All of this has been distilled in some of the reaction to This City Is Ours (which FWIW I think is an excellent bit of light entertainment). In Liverpool, half the people are saying the characters aren't "Proper Scousers" (wrong clothes, not just the wrong accents), others love the show, and others saying it portrays the city in too negative a light (too much illegal activity). Well, for the latter tribe, guess what?: Nobody wants to watch a nice happy programme about well-adjusted, law-abiding normie Liverpolitans going about their lives. Even Brookside wasn't that. Get over it.
My take on Metro Mayor Steve Rotherham's criticism of Mersey drama This City is Ours.View quoted post on X