Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s boldness on the war with Russia puts the NDP to shame. If Mélenchon wins the French presidency, his opposition to NATO will force Avi Lewis to finally criticize the belligerent military alliance.
After reports emerged of French soldiers in Ukraine, Europe’s leading leftist politician posted on Tuesday: “Alert. Under no circumstances must we become a co-belligerent in Ukraine. This issue has been raised, as the La France Insoumise parliamentary group stated in its press release. Furthermore, the Russian Foreign Minister has just issued a warning to Paris regarding the presence of French soldiers in Ukraine, describing such a deployment as ‘direct participation’ in the conflict.”
Polling second in the French presidential campaign, Mélenchon’s statement comes after calling for a referendum on territorial concessions at the launch of his election platform. On November 7 Mélenchon told 20,000 supporters that any exchange of territory should include a referendum for the residents of the Donbas who “have the right to decide whether they want to be Ukrainian or Russian.”
The statement prompted a backlash. But the leader of La France Insoumise reiterated his point and noted that President Volodymyr Zelensky effectively agreed to a similar position.
Mélenchon’s position on the Russia/Ukraine/NATO war is sensible. He immediately opposed the Russian invasion but opposes NATO belligerence and wants a new European security infrastructure that includes Russia.
While Lewis claims a leftist mantle, the head of the NDP appears like a warmongering NATOstan next to Mélenchon. Last year Lewis promoted more arms sales to Ukraine and his party has promoted sending troops through Operation Unifier, expanding NATO to Ukraine and gave the government a blank cheque on sending resources/arms. NDP foreign critic Heather McPherson, who Lewis reappointed, is ultra hawkish on NATO/Ukraine/Russia.
The NDP was silent last year when both the prime minister and defence minister floated the idea of formally deploying Canadian troops to Ukraine. Similarly, they ignored the New York Times report four months into Russia’s illegal invasion that Canadian special forces were there. In June 2022 the Ottawa Citizen published “Canadian special forces don’t deny New York Times report that commandos are in Ukraine.”
During nearly five years of bloodletting, the NDP doesn’t seem to have even once called for diplomatic negotiations to end the war. The party ignored former Prime Minister Jean Chrétien’s criticism of those opposed to talking with Russia and suggestion that expanding NATO provoked the war. As such, they’ll almost certainly ignore an op-ed in Monday’s Financial Times by the former Chairman of Britain’s Joint Intelligence Committee. In “Europe needs to talk to Russia”, Simon Gass writes, “We underestimate at our peril Russian leaders’ belief that Nato expansion threatens their security. They do not accept that Nato is simply a defensive alliance.”
It isn’t. As I’ve documented repeatedly, NATO was set up to blunt the European left, bolster colonial authority and bring the world under the US geopolitical umbrella.
If Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s campaign keeps growing, his call to withdraw from NATO will reverberate across the alliance. If Mélenchon wins the French presidency and acts on his promise Avi Lewis will face enormous pressure to start challenging NATO.
After reports emerged of French soldiers in Ukraine, Europe’s leading leftist politician posted on Tuesday: “Alert. Under no circumstances must we become a co-belligerent in Ukraine. This issue has been raised, as the La France Insoumise parliamentary group stated in its press release. Furthermore, the Russian Foreign Minister has just issued a warning to Paris regarding the presence of French soldiers in Ukraine, describing such a deployment as ‘direct participation’ in the conflict.”
Polling second in the French presidential campaign, Mélenchon’s statement comes after calling for a referendum on territorial concessions at the launch of his election platform. On November 7 Mélenchon told 20,000 supporters that any exchange of territory should include a referendum for the residents of the Donbas who “have the right to decide whether they want to be Ukrainian or Russian.”
The statement prompted a backlash. But the leader of La France Insoumise reiterated his point and noted that President Volodymyr Zelensky effectively agreed to a similar position.
Mélenchon’s position on the Russia/Ukraine/NATO war is sensible. He immediately opposed the Russian invasion but opposes NATO belligerence and wants a new European security infrastructure that includes Russia.
While Lewis claims a leftist mantle, the head of the NDP appears like a warmongering NATOstan next to Mélenchon. Last year Lewis promoted more arms sales to Ukraine and his party has promoted sending troops through Operation Unifier, expanding NATO to Ukraine and gave the government a blank cheque on sending resources/arms. NDP foreign critic Heather McPherson, who Lewis reappointed, is ultra hawkish on NATO/Ukraine/Russia.
The NDP was silent last year when both the prime minister and defence minister floated the idea of formally deploying Canadian troops to Ukraine. Similarly, they ignored the New York Times report four months into Russia’s illegal invasion that Canadian special forces were there. In June 2022 the Ottawa Citizen published “Canadian special forces don’t deny New York Times report that commandos are in Ukraine.”
During nearly five years of bloodletting, the NDP doesn’t seem to have even once called for diplomatic negotiations to end the war. The party ignored former Prime Minister Jean Chrétien’s criticism of those opposed to talking with Russia and suggestion that expanding NATO provoked the war. As such, they’ll almost certainly ignore an op-ed in Monday’s Financial Times by the former Chairman of Britain’s Joint Intelligence Committee. In “Europe needs to talk to Russia”, Simon Gass writes, “We underestimate at our peril Russian leaders’ belief that Nato expansion threatens their security. They do not accept that Nato is simply a defensive alliance.”
It isn’t. As I’ve documented repeatedly, NATO was set up to blunt the European left, bolster colonial authority and bring the world under the US geopolitical umbrella.
If Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s campaign keeps growing, his call to withdraw from NATO will reverberate across the alliance. If Mélenchon wins the French presidency and acts on his promise Avi Lewis will face enormous pressure to start challenging NATO.