Twitxy Saved

Francesco Maggi

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@Frances01896069

Mathematician
Joined October 2020
28 Following 1.7K Followers 477 Posts

Latest posts 5

Francesco Maggi Verified account @Frances01896069
One thing feels clear to me from Alpöge’s statement claiming a Lean proof of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, see

alpo.ge/remark.pdf

and it is something the various controversies of the past few months hadn’t necessarily made evident to me: he is someone who loves mathematics and will work to advance human understanding.

I can’t reconcile a different reading of the situation with his four-page statement.

I also think that a human showing up with a Lean proof and pledging their time to understanding and explaining it is immensely more productive and appropriate than the mass generation of hundreds of papers for benchmarking/PR purposes. The difference is immense.

Kudos to @__alpoge__ :)
8 replies 8 reposts 139 likes 15K views View on X
Francesco Maggi Verified account @Frances01896069
Exactly! Our good shepherds have been used to create an illusion of peer-review, enough to generate headlines and keep the hype up, but with little more scientific value than a quick opinion.

(Before the United Bots of AI come at my throat— I’m in the camp that thinks LLMs are amazing research tools, but science is not a videogame, and scientific norms are actually a pretty useful thing to adhere to.

BTW want some good shepherding?

Go public only when you understand what you have proved and have an employee who can give a talk and act as the corresponding author for a normal peer-review submission. Everyone will love you.)
Not Even Wrong @notevenwrong Nov 11
New Post: The Yang-Mills Publicity Stunt
math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpres…
View quoted post on X
3 replies 10 reposts 70 likes 4.3K views View on X
Francesco Maggi Verified account @Frances01896069
My impression, based on using LLMs, is that their effectiveness in solving mathematical problems depends heavily on the quality and untapped potential of the existing literature underlying those problems.

If that is correct, I wonder what will happen once that potential has been exhausted, especially if mathematicians become overly reliant on LLM assistants and the literature is not replenished by genuinely new, sufficiently deep insights.

In other words, I’m not entirely sure we aren’t entering a creative rabbit hole.
56 replies 34 reposts 419 likes 21K views View on X
Francesco Maggi Verified account @Frances01896069
This is by far the most honest, informed, constructive, and interesting essay I have read so far about LLMs, AI, etc.

“I Am a Silicon Valley Pioneer. We Are Sabotaging Ourselves.” nytimes.com/2026/11/09/opi…
www.nytimes.com Opinion | I Am a Silicon Valley Pioneer. We Are Sabotaging Ourselves. Artificial intelligence is the latest example of how Silicon Valley ruins great innovations with ridiculous theories about them.
6 replies 28 reposts 202 likes 20K views View on X
Francesco Maggi Verified account @Frances01896069
My two cents: anyone who thinks “math is over,” or picturesque variations on that theme, and who also happens to have a retirement plan lined up, should maybe, just maybe, send an email to HR rather than publicly trashing the future of their younger colleagues.

As a Nobel Laureate eloquently put it just a few decades ago:

Please get out of the new one
If you can’t lend your hand
‘Cause the times
They are a-changing

:)