Twitxy Saved

Jonathan Haslam

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@HaslamJonathan

Fellow, British Academy; Prof, IAS, Princeton (retired); Life Fellow, Corpus Christi College, Cambridge; Emeritus Prof, Cambridge University.
Cambridge, UK throughrussianeyes.com Joined November 2015
98 Following 1.1K Followers 2.3K Posts

Latest posts 5

Jonathan Haslam Verified account @HaslamJonathan
Russia has a crisis in underinvestment, says Nezavisimaya gazeta today.
The collapse in investment is a record.
So at what point will the Americans and Europeans wake up and use this extraordinary advantage to the benefit of negotiating a peace in Ukraine instead of hyping the image of Russian power and scaring people into thinking we face World War III?

Бюджет сокращает поддержку крупных капитальных вложений
Версия для печати
Обсудить на форуме
Инвестиционный спад в России может оказаться рекордным по глубине и продолжительности
📷 Михаил Сергеев
Jonathan Haslam Verified account @HaslamJonathan
Russia's Economy is Dying. End the War.

A forceful editorial in the Russian daily Nezavisimaya gazeta on 20 October points out that the Soviet Union collapsed because it did nothing but spend money on defence.
The leader begins thus:
"In discussing the perspectives for the Russian budget under conditions of almost zero economic growth one increasingly hears the assertion that 'money for the defence of Russia is sufficient in any circumstances'."
The editors point out that the collapse of the Soviet Union was brought about by misallocating investment in favour of defence and at the expense of the civilian sector of the economy. But that this assertion is completely untrue. In fact by the early 1990s it was obvious that prioritising defence was a disaster.
"Thus at the beginning of the 1990's our society faced the fact that massive budget outlays on defence and security did not guarantee the safety of the state. Thus the thesis declared today that 'there is in any event enough money for the defence of the state' needs to be supplemented by an important condition - 'only if the state itself does not begin to fall apart for internal reasons.'"
As the Soviet Union approached collapse, "it did not enter anyone's head to demand increases in state expenditure on defence or state security." Instead the demand for reform took precedence.
The message to Putin is obvious. The war has to stop or there will be nothing left of the country. And if he takes no action he will inevitably find himself facing demands for reform. And those demands in the early 1990's brought down an entire political system.
Prioritising defence within NATO at the expense of everything else could put us in a similar position.
This will come as bad news to establishment Western commentators - ill-informed Conservative MPs such as Bernard Jenkin and even the newly appointed head at the Centre for Policy Studies Liam Halligan, who usually thinks for himself - encouraged by Whitehall disinformation.
They repeatedly assert that Russia is in fine fettle economically and that it can and will continue fighting the war against Ukraine until the cows come home.
What this means is that the bargaining power of the West in negotiating a peace is far stronger than given credit for. Peace does not have to mean Ukraine surrenders.
It means President Trump has a much greater hope of ending the war than when he was first elected into office and boasted that he could bring peace in 24 hours.

"Проблемы развития не исчезают по причине их игнорирования
Почему чиновники и экономисты забывают опыт финансирования военных расходов во времена Советского Союза"
20.10.2026 18:28:00