Twitxy Saved

J Caleb Jones

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@JCalebJones

The world’s leading expert on the Star of the Magi (unfortunately the world doesn’t know it yet). See more at themagistar.com
Virginia, USA jcalebjones.com Joined August 2009
236 Following 1.7K Followers 8.5K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

J Caleb Jones Verified account @JCalebJones
If you’ve ever wanted to know what is happening in the sky in Matthew 2 with the star that the Magi saw, the video that is only available at this website will explain everything that is happening.

And yes, it actually happened exactly as it is described in the text.

The price to watch the video is for you to provide your email address so that you can be informed of future videos, explaining other aspects of the Nativity based on this information about the Star of the Magi.

themagistar.com
3 replies 2 reposts 30 likes 15K views View on X
J Caleb Jones Verified account @JCalebJones
This is a good slide that someone provided from Tyndale University showing why I think the whole academic world is ridiculous.

Apparently, UNINTENTIONALLY using someone else's ideas and claiming them as your own is called "Plagiarism."

Also, INTENTIONALLY using someone else's ideas and claiming them as your own is called "Plagiarism."

That's just ridiculous. We don't even have strict liability (meaning, you have full responsibility regardless of intent) for killing human beings.

The fact that strict liability exists for "stealing" ideas (even when you don't know that they are ideas of another person) is nuts.

It's all about clout and not the dispersal of knowledge.
John Stuart Wilson @JohnStuartWilso 17h
@JCalebJones @StewartP6994 @WesleyLHuff How many more times do you need to be told that conflating plagiarism with IP violations is a giant category error?

The works of Shakespeare are in the public domain. If I pass off one of the sonnets as my own, I have committed plagiarism.
View quoted post on X
30 replies 7 reposts 73 likes 5.2K views View on X
J Caleb Jones Verified account @JCalebJones
This is YET ANOTHER great example of a nothing-burger, proving that the allegations against @WesleyLHuff aren't as bad as people are claiming.

Look below. We're supposed to be shocked by the image on the right from Wikimedia commons and the image on the left from Wes in his 2019 paper.

Smells like plagiarism, right? Looks like stealing, right? I mean, people are yelling that it's plagiarism and stealing on the internet. But....

The image to the right is from Wikimedia commons. Wikimedia commons has an open license to share the image (to copy, distribute, and transmit the work) and to remix (to adapt the work), so long as you give attribution and similar open license. The underlying information for the image comes from a 1968 journal article: Honoré, A.M. (1968). "A statistical study of the synoptic problem". Novum Testamentum 10 (2/3): 95–147. The information comes from table 1 of that journal. You can see the journal article here: doi.org/10.2307/1560364

But importantly, the license is for THE PICTURE AND ONLY THAT PICTURE. For example, if you draw a picture of the statue of liberty, you own the PICTURE you made of the statue of liberty. You don't other images of the statue of liberty because you made one.

The same principle applies to information about the synoptic gospels in the Wikimedia picture below.

As the Supreme Court made clear in Feist Publications, Inc. v. Rural Telephone Service Co., 499 U.S. 340 (1991), you can't copyright facts or data, no matter how much time and effort you expended to collect those facts and data. (That case involved the phone numbers in the white pages of a phone book).

This means you cannot copyright the numbers of words in the gospels and the relative percentages of words in the gospels. All you can copyright and license is the image AND ONLY THE IMAGE. You cannot copyright similar pictures displaying uncopyrightable-information, even if the new picture also appears to be made on Microsoft Paint.

So some guy named "Alecmconroy" copyrighted and then licensed this picture in 2007. He uploaded it with a creative commons license, allowing for all sorts of free, open, sharable use.

What Wes is accused of doing is re-creating the picture (which you can tell is re-created and not copy-pasted by the simplified colors and change in the lines between the graphs). Wes copied the shapes, copied many (but not all) of the labels, and used the same underlying information.

But here's the key: 29 C.F.R. § 202.1(a) says that you cannot copyright words and short phrases, familiar symbols or designs, or mere variations of typographic ornamentation, lettering, or coloring. Moreover, the Compendium of U.S. Copyright Office Practices (Third Edition) § 906.1 states: The Copyright Act does not protect common geometric shapes, either in two-dimensional or three-dimensional form," which would be things like curved lines, circles, etc. etc., or the shapes, layout, and colors themselves.

This means that even though the actual picture on the right can be copyrighted, the GENERAL APPEARANCE of what is on the right CANNOT BE COPYRIGHTED. It's as I said before: you can copyright a picture of the statute of liberty, but you cannot copyright the appearance of the statute of liberty.

Wes then credits this picture to himself (WHICH IS TRUE AND WHICH NOBODY IS ARGUING ABOUT), just as Alecmconroy did on the creative commons license. But unlike Alecmconroy, Wes cited to the underlying information in the image itself.

That means that Wes Huff literally did nothing wrong. He did exactly what he was supposed to do.
He didn't violate copyright.
He didn't plagiarize.
And yes, he DOES own the intellectual property of that picture.

This is another reason I think this whole thing is stupid. The people pushing it appear to be ignorant of the law.
www.jstor.org A Statistical Study of the Synoptic Problem | JSTOR A. M. Honoré, A Statistical Study of the Synoptic Problem, Novum Testamentum, Vol. 10, Fasc. 2/3, Apr. - Jul., 1968
@JCalebJones @WesleyLHuff He copied this graph right off of Wikipedia and then claimed it was his own. He was so lazy and careless that he even copied over the numbers incorrectly and in turn had his table adding up to more than 100%. He isn’t even competent at stealing.
View quoted post on X
30 replies 25 reposts 255 likes 9.7K views View on X
J Caleb Jones Verified account @JCalebJones
Okay.

Hey, @WesleyLHuff! DM me!!!
Banjo Skeptic @BanjoAtheist 2d
@JCalebJones @MatthewTanous @Sola_GPT @WesleyLHuff @maklelan @BMcGrewvy Well, maybe you should contact Wes Huff to let him know that all the swings are missing.

Because it sure sounds like he’s feeling them.

Seriously, you puzzle me. Maybe you’re just having fun doing the defense lawyer game.

But it’s getting boring. 🥱
View quoted post on X
6 replies 0 reposts 14 likes 3.9K views View on X
J Caleb Jones Verified account @JCalebJones
Here’s a great example of why I think the plagiarism thing that we’ve seen on @WesleyLHuff is pretty ridiculous.

I can't find the paper below, but I'll go on the face of the picture and comparison:

- Alister E. McGrath (in a 2016 TEXTBOOK, which is not the type of source you're taught to cite) is summarizing the Cappadocian fathers.

- Huff (in a class in which he is forced to write a paper) cites different sources from 2006 and 2009 (which McGrath probably reviewed when looking at his 5th and 6th Edition textbooks from 2011 and 2016) to similarly summarize the Cappadocian fathers.

Why is McClellan (or the AI he used) finding so many similarities between Huff's summary and McGrath's summary? BECAUSE THEY'RE SUMMARIZING THE SAME UNDERLYING INFORMATION.

And is Huff stealing from McGrath as a source? No! THEY'RE BOTH STEALING FROM THE CAPPADOCIAN FATHERS, which is the actual source of the information.

This is a citation of AUTHORITY, not a citation of the source of an idea. This is an example of how citations operate differently in different context. Wes isn't "stealing an idea" he's playing the weird citation game in academia, providing a WELL-REGARDED SOURCE that agrees with his summary of the Cappadocian Fathers to prove that his summary of the Cappadocian Fathers is generally accepted in the weird club of academia.

That's the purpose of citing a source outside the writings of the Cappadocian fathers to make a point about the writings of the Cappadocian fathers.

So, to summarize, academia is weird, and the more I look into specifics of the accusation this, the less I am impressed.
Brandon Westbrook @EastRiver90 2d
@trojanpoet52 @JCalebJones No, he’s being rightly called out because he’s a serial plagiarist who doesn’t know the basics
View quoted post on X