Twitxy Saved

Jamie LeFrak

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@Jamie_LeFrak

Joined August 2024
173 Following 3.1K Followers 732 Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Jamie LeFrak Verified account @Jamie_LeFrak

Replying to @robertgg

You're too kind! I'm just a dumb, unlicensed Civil Engineer and I have to spend all my time earning a living by building buildings, competing to keep them rented, controlling expenses and then rinse'n'repeat. That said, if there's a slightly well known Economist out there who wants to co-author and research a series of articles and some fun, punchy animated shorts, I have an inexhaustible topic called, "Governments are Gangsters and the Whole World runs on Baksheesh: A Unifying Theory of Economics.". DMs are open!
3 replies 0 reposts 31 likes 2.5K views View on X
Jamie LeFrak Verified account @Jamie_LeFrak
So you're managing a town that's got a lot of costly, dilapidated Public Housing. When it was originally built, your "ancient" predecessor thought it was some kind of infinite money glitch where HUD sent him a boatload of money under the 1968 Turnkey I programs to pay his favorite contractors and build gigantic projects. Into the projects he could place his favorite voters who only had to pay 1/3 of their income as rent, even if the rent is zero. HUD knew this was unsustainable, so they also promised to pay a forever Operating Subsidy (expenses + utilities - rent) and formulaic grants via the Capital Fund Program. Over time, the buildings deteriorated well beyond their useful lives, the tenants trended even further towards zero income and successive federal administrations, reacting to public opinion about Public Housing and its general mismanagement, underfunded Capital Fund requests. Today, managing your broken-down Public Housing has become very expensive, its residents are angry about the living conditions and you've got a real problem on your hands. So what are your options?

Under Section 18, you could tear it down like Pruitt-Igoe (St. Louis) or Cabrini Green (Chicago) and suffer immense political blowback from displacing a lot of voters.

You could privatize it via the RAD program and basically turn it into a Section 8 voucher complex, hoping that a for-profit or private NFP developer can fix and run it better and cheaper than you BUT this will diminish the amount of allocable Section 8 available to other social clients to be housed in other private housing around your town. Moreover, recent experience has shown that this too enrages vocal political groups who despise any private participation in public services.

So here is a crazy, radical solution that might satisfy everyone. Just give the apartments to the tenants. If they want to move out, they keep whatever money they get from selling. A jubilee! If they want to stay, let them stay under the Section 8 Homeownership Voucher program (yes, that exists) with supplements from HOME grants and the Section 504 program. If you're worried about the reaction of the jealous neighbors who didn't get a free apartment, then add a deed restriction that requires a significant percentage of every resale to go back into your City's capital fund, or for real estate tax relief. What's more , you're going to collect property taxes from this newly ratable asset. You've turned a problem into a revenue bonanza! Or, if you want to preserve it as Affordable Housing forever, you can impose buyer income restrictions (and tax abatement) via the deed too.

Who would get upset about this? Am I missing something?
38 replies 12 reposts 189 likes 18K views View on X
Jamie LeFrak Verified account @Jamie_LeFrak
Frank Braconi, who is an actual economist, inadvertently asked me a softball question about why the operating expenses of non-profit housing owners are usually double those of for-profit owners. I also note that public housing operating expenses are usually triple those of private, for-profit owners. Amazingly, even with the orders of magnitude of additional spending, the non-profit buildings tend to have worse physical conditions and the public housing buildings are well known to be the worst of all. With apologies in advance that this post may be too technical and into the weeds for some, here we go.

As Frank surely knows, there are these standard economic concepts called Principal Agent and Moral Hazard. Let's examine these in terms of the three kinds of housing ownership.

In for-profit housing, the owner/manager is the Principal Agent and its motivation is the long term maximization of income and return on capital reinvestments. When it comes to "purchased items" this owner carefully negotiates and bids costs with suppliers, minimizes waste, avoids costly violations and fines, fears foreclosure and litigation and reserves capital to reinvest in well-planned component replacement and money saving innovations. Examples include heat timers, utility submetering and complex self-insurance structures, to key off Frank's questions below. Utility submetering, for one, reduces consumption by 2/3 in practice: a huge savings! There is very little Moral Hazard here because the Principal Agent is the direct beneficiary of the cost savings and it is not a judgment-proof entity.

In non-profit housing, we encounter our first Moral Hazard. The owner is an entity that by virtue of being the owner of last-resort, has an soft loss backstop from the public. The non-profit's manager, acting as Principal Agent, still has to do all the work of a manager but is only compensated by a salary, also a hazard. So in the non-profit scenario, the manager will do everything to maximize its salary but only impose as much careful effort as is needed to prevent the building from literally collapsing. Since this type of property doesn't have to pay real estate taxes, an amount which usually would be around half of net income, all of that money can be squandered on careless and indifferent negotiation and purchasing with suppliers. It should surprise no one that careless purchasing often comes with emoluments for the Principal Agent, another Moral Hazard. This owner is also less risk averse, because when fines and violations arrive resulting in eventual litigation judgments, there is no owner to worry about the outcome. They become just another delayable payable. Conditions naturally deteriorate but at least the building doesn't fall over.

And finally we have the public owner who truly has no "skin in the game." Perversely, the public owner cares mostly about how to MAXIMIZE the operating costs because the Principal Agent and Moral Hazard problems are here in full effect. The salary to manage public housing is a pittance, so the Principal Agent may only earn their fair compensation through emoluments. The legendary graft at agencies like NYCHA is well documented and consistent at public housing throughout the world. Moreover, prevailing wage regulations already force any operating expense that includes a service to cost at least double, even before any mischief takes place. Of recent note, the well publicized case of the NYCHA employee-plumber Jakub Markowski who allegedly earned $465k via overtime rigging. When the property earns fines and violations, develops truly dangerous conditions or employees behave with utter gross negligence, only the taxpayer is on the hook and no one ever loses their job or pension thanks to the representatiion of powerful labor syndicates. With this incentive structure, it should be no surprise at all that building conditions are atrocious and it costs $527k to renovate a single public housing unit.
Frank Braconi @FrankBraconi 5d
@Jamie_LeFrak @IamSean90 Any idea why non-profit operating costs would be 2x that of for-profit owners? A lot of operating costs are just purchased items, like heating oil, water, electricity, insurance, etc.
View quoted post on X
87 replies 281 reposts 2.1K likes 260K views View on X
Jamie LeFrak Verified account @Jamie_LeFrak
You can get upset about the fact that the preponderance of the national wealth is being squandered on costly, super high tech, all-you-can-eat end-of-life health care services for retired Boomers via Medicare and State and municipal pension plans, or you can be smart. As a homebuilder and developer, I can focus on product types and locations that are appealing to retirement, health care services and health service consumption. You too can stop hunting for where Toyota is building a new factory and start looking for the where the hospital system is growing. Stop building traditional office buildings and start converting empty, distressed commercial to medical offices, which unlike the rest of the asset class, have come through the covid disaster unscathed. Stop lobbying your local government to build garden apartments (or data centers ;) in the good school district and start lobbying to get yourself Certificates of Need for new surgery centers. Let this chart below not be a source of frustration but rather a treasure map. Good luck out there, everyone.
Nikhil Krishnan Verified account @nikillinit 5d
I was surprised at how much Medicare/Medicaid/Social Security are now propping up local economies and personal incomes

If you look through the data, Medicare/Medicaid have become the biggest sources of income for particularly non-metropolitan areas. Some stats in the data:

- Government transfers are now 17.6% of all personal income in the US, up from about 8% in 1970. Medicare and Medicaid are 46% of all government transfer dollars!

- 53% of counties get more than 25%+ of their income from government transfers (this covers about 72M people).

- Kentucky seems to be the home of the Colonel and government transfer programs. Twelve of the top fifteen counties receiving government transfers are there. Owsley County gets 63% of personal income from transfers, and Medicaid alone is 32% of all income in the county.

Those government transfers via Medicaid/Medicare get transmuted alchemically into jobs. Phoebe Putney Health System has 6000+ workers and is the largest employer in southwest Georgia. Dougherty County, where it's based, gets 34% of its personal income from government transfers.

In New York we have a program that pays friends and family as caregivers. In 2023 it grew by 57,000 jobs and became 38% of all job growth in the state (they’ve made changes to the program now that have flattened it).

We have become a country of healthcare jobs with a propping of government dollars. Is that fine?

I think this grand bargain worked for a while. We were still seeing economic productivity, government spending hadn’t yet gotten too crazy, etc. But a few things are happening now that suggest the bargain is falling apart.
View quoted post on X
3 replies 8 reposts 173 likes 19K views View on X
Jamie LeFrak Verified account @Jamie_LeFrak
@JKetcham91

The State of New York has now factually zeroed out the value of a collection of previously valuable Rent Stabilized buildings. The auction produced no bids on 14 out of 15 properties. John, does this mean the Penn Central test has been met? Is the law now a facial uncompensated act of eminent domain?

bisnow.com/news/new-york/…
www.bisnow.com Emerald Equity's Rent-Stabilized Portfolio Goes To Auction The Harlem portfolio of rent-stabilized buildings returned to its lender after a rejected $110M offer and distressed foreclosure auctions.