Twitxy Saved

Jonathan Shedler

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@JonathanShedler

Professor, psychologist, author. Tweets about psychology, psychiatry, psychotherapy.
Writings, podcasts, talks👇
San Francisco and Vail linktr.ee/jonathanshedler Joined August 2013
756 Following 76K Followers 40K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Jonathan Shedler Verified account @JonathanShedler
1/ One of most important things I've learned:

Severe personality problems find *camouflage.* No one thinks “I’m a sadist” or “I'm a malignant narcissist.”

They find a belief system/social group that validates their most hateful, destructive impulses & construes them as virtues.
121 replies 1K reposts 4.1K likes 1.1M views View on X
Jonathan Shedler Verified account @JonathanShedler
“Projective identification begins with the defense of projection and takes it a step further. In addition to projecting disavowed parts of themselves, the person works to induce and evoke the feelings they have projected, so the other person comes to feel and act in accord with the projection.

This transfer of thoughts and feelings from patient to clinician is not mysterious or mystical. Observable behavior pulls, pushes, coaxes, and coerces the clinician into their assigned role, although both clinician and patient may be unaware of this as it happens. Generally, countertransference comes first and understanding emerges after the fact.”

(from “The Personality Syndromes”; Oxford University Press)
jonathanshedler.com/wp-content/upl…
Jonathan Shedler Verified account @JonathanShedler Aug 6, 2024
1/ One of most important things I've learned:

Severe personality problems find *camouflage.* No one thinks “I’m a sadist” or “I'm a malignant narcissist.”

They find a belief system/social group that validates their most hateful, destructive impulses & construes them as virtues.
View quoted post on X
5 replies 17 reposts 137 likes 7.7K views View on X
Jonathan Shedler Verified account @JonathanShedler
In-depth therapy is possible only when the therapy relationship is private and protected from outside intrusion.

This is not just ethics. These are basic requirements for doing in-depth psychological work.

Whose interests are served by cloud-based, AI-assisted electronic health records?
jordan Verified account @jordanticus 2d
Pen and paper charts for patients are now seemingly more ethical than digital ones. I'm thinking of switching back.

Remember, many EHRs sell patient data, which is allowed by HIPAA if the information is 'de-identified'. However it isn't difficult to re-identify the patient and AI is making this increasingly easier to do. And this is just what's legal, who knows the full extent of what's actually happening. And the more you look into this the more disturbing it is.
View quoted post on X
6 replies 7 reposts 97 likes 6.3K views View on X
Jonathan Shedler Verified account @JonathanShedler
Many therapists think they’re supposed to know what to say.

Most would do well to focus less on what to say and more on how to listen.

If a patient expects an answer, it’s all right to say “I don't know” or “I don't understand yet. Let’s keep talking and see where it leads.”

I wish more therapists recognized that “I don't know” can be a constructive intervention in its own right. It’s not punting or buying time. The meta-message is: it’s okay to experience the unknown. It’s okay to sit with feelings we don’t yet understand, to create more space to notice and reflect, to allow ourselves to be fallible humans. It’s okay to resist the seductive allure of imagined omnipotence.

“I don't know” is sometimes the most effective intervention.

A therapist who always knows what to say is not doing the work of psychotherapy because that’s not how the work goes. I’m not sure what they’re doing, but it’s not psychotherapy.