The judges who think we’re wrong can’t even agree with each other on why. Today’s splintered decision in the Fourth Circuit, which includes three separate contradictory opinions, is just the latest example. There is no unified, coherent legal argument against prediction markets. But amidst all the confusion in today's ruling, Judge Benjamin said it best:
“The special rule’s authority over gaming necessarily means that there can be event contracts around gaming. Based on the special rule and the above colloquy, it’s the CFTC’s responsibility to differentiate swaps used for gaming from those which can be used for legitimate risk avoidance. Just because the CFTC isn’t exercising discretion to the degree Maryland would like under the CEA, doesn’t mean that sports-related contracts don’t qualify as swaps.”
“The special rule’s authority over gaming necessarily means that there can be event contracts around gaming. Based on the special rule and the above colloquy, it’s the CFTC’s responsibility to differentiate swaps used for gaming from those which can be used for legitimate risk avoidance. Just because the CFTC isn’t exercising discretion to the degree Maryland would like under the CEA, doesn’t mean that sports-related contracts don’t qualify as swaps.”