Pinned post
We have an opportunity to build a new liberty movement in the Republican Party, but first, we need to figure out why the last one failed.
In 2009, we had enough. Republicans had overseen steel tariffs, runaway deficits, a Middle Eastern war of choice, Patriot Act surveillance overreach, and a general socialization of the party through No Child Left Behind, Medicare Part D, and the 2008 TARP bank and auto bailouts. When Washington followed that up with the 2009 stimulus, the TEA Party rose up. Taxed Enough Already. It wasn't organized. It wasn't top-down. It was organic.
That was its beauty, and also part of the problem.
"Tea Party" candidates were anyone who claimed the label. Some were genuine constitutional conservatives who actually fought to shrink government, like Rand Paul, Mike Lee, Justin Amash, and Thomas Massie. A LOT were grifters. They were careerists who wanted power and rode a grassroots wave to get it.
Fractures happened because there was no way to self-police the movement. Undisciplined, flawed nominees like Christine O'Donnell in Delaware in 2010 and Todd Akin in Missouri in 2012 blew winnable Senate seats, while opportunistic candidates spoiled the national brand.
The 2010, 2012, and 2014 cycles kept bringing in more "Tea Party" politicians, but the more who came in, the more diluted the movement became.
Then 2016 happened. The Republican presidential primary was packed with Tea Party contenders, giving the movement a real shot to nominate a pro-liberty conservative for president.
Going into the race, it was the "Bush establishment" (Jeb Bush, Kasich, Christie, and Rubio) vs. the Tea Party lane (Paul, Cruz, Perry, Carson, Huckabee, Santorum, Fiorina, Jindal, and Walker). But then you had a third option: Donald Trump.
Because of how U.S. presidential primaries allocate delegates, you don't need anywhere near majority support to win. In winner-take-all South Carolina, for example, Trump swept all 50 delegates with 32.5% of the vote while the divided field split the rest. He paired a Tea Party-esque fighter brand with big-government policies, promising tariffs and refusing to touch Social Security or Medicare. He took a chunk from both sides before either camp could coalesce behind an alternative.
Since then, the pro-liberty movement has suffered a slow and painful decline over a decade.
Now we have an opportunity. We can grow the liberty movement again, but do it in a principled and disciplined way.
We can set high standards for the candidates we support, making sure that once elected, they make the movement more popular, not less. We can intervene before pro-liberty candidates run against each other and find spots for them both. And most importantly, we can hold them accountable when they are actually governing.
In 2009, we had enough. Republicans had overseen steel tariffs, runaway deficits, a Middle Eastern war of choice, Patriot Act surveillance overreach, and a general socialization of the party through No Child Left Behind, Medicare Part D, and the 2008 TARP bank and auto bailouts. When Washington followed that up with the 2009 stimulus, the TEA Party rose up. Taxed Enough Already. It wasn't organized. It wasn't top-down. It was organic.
That was its beauty, and also part of the problem.
"Tea Party" candidates were anyone who claimed the label. Some were genuine constitutional conservatives who actually fought to shrink government, like Rand Paul, Mike Lee, Justin Amash, and Thomas Massie. A LOT were grifters. They were careerists who wanted power and rode a grassroots wave to get it.
Fractures happened because there was no way to self-police the movement. Undisciplined, flawed nominees like Christine O'Donnell in Delaware in 2010 and Todd Akin in Missouri in 2012 blew winnable Senate seats, while opportunistic candidates spoiled the national brand.
The 2010, 2012, and 2014 cycles kept bringing in more "Tea Party" politicians, but the more who came in, the more diluted the movement became.
Then 2016 happened. The Republican presidential primary was packed with Tea Party contenders, giving the movement a real shot to nominate a pro-liberty conservative for president.
Going into the race, it was the "Bush establishment" (Jeb Bush, Kasich, Christie, and Rubio) vs. the Tea Party lane (Paul, Cruz, Perry, Carson, Huckabee, Santorum, Fiorina, Jindal, and Walker). But then you had a third option: Donald Trump.
Because of how U.S. presidential primaries allocate delegates, you don't need anywhere near majority support to win. In winner-take-all South Carolina, for example, Trump swept all 50 delegates with 32.5% of the vote while the divided field split the rest. He paired a Tea Party-esque fighter brand with big-government policies, promising tariffs and refusing to touch Social Security or Medicare. He took a chunk from both sides before either camp could coalesce behind an alternative.
Since then, the pro-liberty movement has suffered a slow and painful decline over a decade.
Now we have an opportunity. We can grow the liberty movement again, but do it in a principled and disciplined way.
We can set high standards for the candidates we support, making sure that once elected, they make the movement more popular, not less. We can intervene before pro-liberty candidates run against each other and find spots for them both. And most importantly, we can hold them accountable when they are actually governing.