Very informative.
Anne Diamond, one of the best-known faces on British breakfast television, lost her four-month-old son Sebastian to cot death in July 1991. When she went looking for the reason, the trail led back to the best-selling baby book ever written.View quoted post on X
Benjamin Spock was the most trusted doctor in the world. Baby and Child Care came out in 1946, and for half a century it was said to sell second only to the Bible. Parents on both sides of the Atlantic kept it by the cot and did what it said. In the first edition he told them to put babies down on their backs. In the editions of the 1950s he changed his mind.
His reasoning sounded like common sense. A baby on its back might be sick in the night and choke on it, and might grow a flat patch on the back of its head. Better, he wrote, to get a baby used to sleeping on its stomach from the start. Hospitals adopted it. Midwives taught it. Grandmothers who had put their own babies down on their backs were corrected by daughters who had read the book.
Nobody had tested it. By 1970 the studies already showed babies sleeping on their fronts dying suddenly about three times as often as babies on their backs. The advice did not change. Cot death got its own line on the death certificate that same year, and through the seventies and eighties it climbed until it was the biggest killer of babies between one month and one year old. In 1989, 1,545 babies died of it in Britain.
The evidence finally broke through at the end of the eighties, from a Bristol doctor, Peter Fleming, and from researchers in New Zealand. Anne Diamond put everything she had behind it: her fame, her programme and her grief. In December 1991 the government launched the Back to Sleep campaign. Cot deaths in Britain fell almost overnight. Today there are around 200 a year.
In 2005 researchers in London went back through fifty years of baby books and studies. They concluded that the front-sleeping advice had run against the evidence since 1970, and that it had probably cost more than 10,000 babies their lives in Britain, and at least 50,000 across Europe, America and Australasia.
Spock never meant any harm. He was the expert, and nobody in a position to check his advice thought they needed to.
The parents who followed it did everything right. They read the book, trusted the doctor, and laid their babies down exactly as they were told.