Twitxy Saved

Mr. Blueberry

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@MrBlueberryT

Here for the good food, wine and lively repartee…
fieldsfieldsblueberries.com Joined December 2022
785 Following 481 Followers 4.5K Posts

Latest posts 5

Mr. Blueberry Verified account @MrBlueberryT
A good read, slightly fewer words than Atlas Shrugged.
Time Preference Verified account @TimePreference_ Sep 15
"why should capital get the residual claim" is a question that only sounds deep if you ignore what residual means

the residual is what's left after everyone else has been paid. the worker gets his wage whether the business profits or fails. the supplier gets paid. the landlord gets rent. the bank gets interest. all of these are fixed claims

contracted in advance, paid first, guaranteed

the shareholder gets what remains. if the business loses money, the fixed claimants still get paid. the shareholder gets the loss. if the business makes nothing, the shareholder gets nothing. if the business goes bankrupt, the shareholder is last in line

the residual claim isn't a privilege. it's the position of maximum risk. the person who accepts it accepts the most uncertainty. that's why he gets the upside; because he bears the downside

"workers take risks too"

yes. the worker risks losing his job. but the worker keeps the wages he already earned. the shareholder risks losing the entire investment; every dollar he put in. the worker's downside is bounded. the shareholder's is total

"most shareholders bought existing shares, the company got nothing"

the company got the capital when it issued the share. the secondary buyer pays the original investor for the right to the residual claim. without the secondary market, the original investor wouldn't invest

because he couldn't exit. the liquidity of the secondary market is what makes the primary investment possible

"capital doesn't work, think, or create"

capital is stored work. it's the wages someone earned and didn't spend. it's the consumption someone deferred so the resources could go to production instead. to say capital doesn't work is to say the person who saved his labor didn't labor

"we could pay capital a fixed return and give the residual to workers"

this exists. it's called a cooperative. workers can organize firms this way any time. the fact that most workers choose to take a fixed wage instead of the residual claim tells you which they prefer. the worker who wants the residual can have it; by starting a business, buying shares, or joining a co-op. most don't, because the fixed wage is safer

the real question isn't why capital gets the residual. it's why anyone would provide capital without it. the residual claim is the incentive to invest, to monitor, to allocate. remove it and you remove the mechanism that directs resources to their most productive use

the socialist wants to keep the investment but remove the incentive. keep the capital but remove the reward. the result every time is the same; the capital stops flowing, the investment stops happening, and the economy that needed both stagnates

you can redesign the accounting. you can't redesign reality
View quoted post on X