Twitxy Saved

Murray Rundus

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@MurrayRundus

Former Disney Actor, now a Catholic. @pelicancatholic
Joined October 2023
690 Following 2.5K Followers 6.7K Posts

Latest posts 5

Murray Rundus Verified account @MurrayRundus
Struggling to see where Dietrich thinks there is a "massive error" here. I understand that Salza+Siscoe (where this argument is from) are of the understanding that this shows that the SSPX have gone into heresy, as a type of evidence that the SSPX as a limb has fallen off the tree of the Church, now exposed to error via private judgement. I’ve seen this used as a sort of “You see! This is why there is no way His Holiness could accept the SSPX back into the fold.” but I don’t think that this is very strong even if argued forcefully.

The topic in question is quite heady and is not able to be synthesized in an X post, or proof-texted. There’s effectively two things being discussed here. Firstly, the origin of jurisdiction and then whether or not the Pope is a single subject of supreme authority exercising this via two modes, or is a part of a bifurcated authority that exists in the Pope as one subject and the college of bishops (with the Pope) as another. Implicit in this is the question of jurisdiction which either says the Pope is the source of jurisdiction, or that this is obtained by virtue of being a bishop. There are then further debates about whether or not this jurisdiction is merely a potential one or an actual one.

One really has three approaches that you can take here. One can choose to take the one subject position, which you will find backing from the old Code of Canon Law, Cajetan (whom I have not read on this) the praxis of the medieval and post-tridentine Church and a certain reading of Pastor Aeturnus. You can then do what the SSPX does, and just say there seems to be a contradiction between Lumen Gentium and prior teaching if indeed Lumen Gentium is denying this (and this itself is an issue, there is clear ambiguity here!) They have the strength of pointing to the praxis of the post-conciliar era, and it cannot be denied that certain statements and actions of the post-concilliar Popes seems to suggest that the Church is at least in praxis adopting an even more extreme version of collegiality than what Lumen Gentium suggests. Or you can do what the Council itself seemed to do with the Nota praevia, compromise on the two positions and create a synthesis argument which somewhat obfuscates the question and the post-concilliar praxis but essentially leaves the question open. Alternatively you can just say that there is no problem in the pre-concilliar texts with what Lumen Gentium says, assert the two-fold subject theory and say the SSPX is denying a teaching of the Church and use manualists such as Van Noort, Billot, Journet, etc.

As with that second approach, I think the question on the one or two subject issue actually is quite open, and for good reason, there are theological difficulties here. This isn’t some kind of game, it requires a lot of effort on the part of theologians. The Nota praevia would not have covered this issue or tried to “fix” the text if there wasn’t an issue here.

One of the frustrating things that I have encountered when looking at this debate, whether reading Fr. Gleize (where most of the SSPX’s argumentation here originates from, and where I suspect Article 77 is from!) or in anti-SSPX polemics (which also comes from 1 or 2 sources) is that this is not simple, it’s very complicated. Pretending as if one’s salvation hinges on a correct understanding of the one or two-fold subject of authority is simply absurd! I would apply this to both camps. There seems to be an overreach in what is dogmatic here. It is not evidently clear whether this or that opinion even has the magisterial weight to be classified as a dogma. Certainly Lumen Gentium did not make it one. The difficulty with saying that these doctrinal issues will be essential to any kind of canonical regularity for the SSPX is that these are centuries-old issues. But it also forces a double standard. Now if one wants to say that the Church needs to be hyper-rigorist about one or twofold subjects to the point of condemning the SSPX, go ahead, but the Church does not even act this strictly to those in Germany or other parts of Northwestern Europe where the Apostles Creed is actively being denied. In fact, on this very issue, Rahner took a very unusual opinion about this precise matter and the Church had no problem promoting him in the post-conciliar age. These points cannot be dismissed as a whataboutism, because it’s at the heart of what the complaint of the Society is and is at the heart of the current trajectory of the Church.

This is why, I will insist, that the practical stance from the SSPX focusing on how these ideas are impacting the faithful here and now, and how heterodox teaching and praxis is plaguing most parishes simply is going to be more forceful than saying that all of the work of the SSPX is made illegitimate because of a difference of opinion regarding collegiality.
Dietrich 🇻🇦 Verified account @jarldietrich Oct 18
A massive error of the SSPX is that their profession of faith denies a dogma of the Catholic Church that existed before Vatican 2 and was infallibly confirmed at Vatican 2 in Lumen Gentium.

While I completely understand that there is a crisis in the Church and many feel compelled to go to SSPX chapels to escape from liturgical abuse, irreverence and even heterodox preaching by some clergy, their conception of the Church is out of line with what has been infallibly taught and since their excommunication they are officially in schism.

SSPX profession of faith paragraph 77:
"I further recognize that the body of bishops, united with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without that head, can be the extraordinary and non-permanent subject of a full and supreme power over the universal Church, but that this takes place only in the act of an ecumenical council, on the initiative and at the order of the Roman Pontiff alone, and within the limits of his exclusive will."

This contradicts what was previously taught:

"Moreover, nothing is more explicit in the Catholic faith from the beginning than the dogma of the supreme authority of the whole episcopate, whether gathered into an ecumenical council or even dispersed throughout the whole world (Cf. the letter of Pius IX to the Archbishop of Munich, December 21, 1863, in Denzinger, no. 1536). And it is concerning this collegial authority of all bishops cohering with Peter as their head that the saying of Cyprian, De Unitate Ecclesiae, no. 5, is rightly understood.
Billot, Church of Christ, Thesis XXVIII (The apostolic college shares supreme power with Peter; monarchy with episcopal coherence.)"

"The conclusion is rather that this power was promised to the whole apostolic college, including Peter. A comparison of Matthew 16 with Matthew 18 shows that there will be in Christ’s Church a twofold subject, not too sharply distinct, of full and supreme jurisdiction: Peter alone, and the Petro-apostolic college. And this is the Catholic teaching, as Innocent III, among others, testifies:
But should you discover that it was spoken to all the apostles together, still you will recognize that the power of binding and loosing was bestowed not upon the others without him [Peter], but that it was given to him apart from the others, so that what the others could not do without him he could do without the others, and this by reason of the privileges conferred upon him by the Lord and by reason of the fulness of power which had been granted him."

Van Noort, Christ's Church p 67-68

And taught by the Second Vatican Council:

LG 22:
"The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.(27*) This power can be exercised only with the consent of the Roman Pontiff."
View quoted post on X
4 replies 3 reposts 42 likes 3.3K views View on X
Murray Rundus Verified account @MurrayRundus
The idea that the Pope could, for example, just will that the Byzantine Rite is "suppressed" because it is not to his tastes and therefore is never to be used again is quite a scandal.

Catholicism cannot be reduced to a "pay your taxes and be saved" model, where one's chance at salvation is just a reflection on how much you agree with the Pope. The faith has to be based on tradition both doctrinal and liturgical.
Scott Smith @hf_222222 Oct 15
Look, I am not a trad, and a Pope can supress whatever liturgical rite he wants to.

But I really don't like Roche's disingenuous sophistry in this response, which he has deployed in a couple of interviews now. Its not true & he knows its not.
advaticanum.com/article/exclus…
View quoted post on X
14 replies 12 reposts 168 likes 5.3K views View on X