J.J. McCarthy top-10 QB agenda starts now
Latest posts 5
Idiots keep saying “Quenton Nelson is a rental!!!” as if it would’ve mattered even remotely for us.
Guy grew up in New Jersey as a massive Giants fan. He would’ve taken an extension to stay here the minute the trade went through, maybe even a team-friendly discount.
Guy grew up in New Jersey as a massive Giants fan. He would’ve taken an extension to stay here the minute the trade went through, maybe even a team-friendly discount.
I would genuinely lose my fucking mind if the Giants gave up any day 2 pick for Jonathan Taylor after Quenton Nelson was traded for a late 2027 3rd and a late 2027 5th.View quoted post on X
Jonathan Taylor:
- Turns 28 in January at a position where almost everybody is washed up by then (unless your name is Derrick Henry)
- Ridiculous amount of mileage in BOTH the NFL and CFB
- Sharply declining production (worse YPC than Skattebo this year and 20th in the NFL)
- Our run blocking is absolutely deplorable (FAR worse than the Colts’ run blocking) and that’s always the limiting factor for rushing production
- Colts are asking for an absolutely ridiculous trade price (he’s not even worth a day 2 pick, especially not to this team)
- This team is NOT a RB away nor anywhere near being a RB away
- 2027 draft is loaded and we already have barely any draft capital as it is
Just an absolutely and utterly awful trade idea. Especially when you consider the fact that you could’ve gotten the best guard in the entire NFL a few days ago for only a 2027 3rd and a 2028 5th. That guard is only 30-years-old and likely has ~5 years left of elite play due to the position he plays. He also grew up a huge Giants fan, so there’s no doubt that he would’ve taken an extension to stay here.
- Turns 28 in January at a position where almost everybody is washed up by then (unless your name is Derrick Henry)
- Ridiculous amount of mileage in BOTH the NFL and CFB
- Sharply declining production (worse YPC than Skattebo this year and 20th in the NFL)
- Our run blocking is absolutely deplorable (FAR worse than the Colts’ run blocking) and that’s always the limiting factor for rushing production
- Colts are asking for an absolutely ridiculous trade price (he’s not even worth a day 2 pick, especially not to this team)
- This team is NOT a RB away nor anywhere near being a RB away
- 2027 draft is loaded and we already have barely any draft capital as it is
Just an absolutely and utterly awful trade idea. Especially when you consider the fact that you could’ve gotten the best guard in the entire NFL a few days ago for only a 2027 3rd and a 2028 5th. That guard is only 30-years-old and likely has ~5 years left of elite play due to the position he plays. He also grew up a huge Giants fan, so there’s no doubt that he would’ve taken an extension to stay here.
I would genuinely lose my fucking mind if the Giants gave up any day 2 pick for Jonathan Taylor after Quenton Nelson was traded for a late 2027 3rd and a late 2027 5th.
Trading a day 2 (or God forbid day 1) pick for Jonathan Taylor only makes sense if you’re a true Super Bowl contender with an elite run-blocking OL.