Pinned post
There are two ways to rehypothecate #bitcoin and IMO TradFi will eventually try both.
1) Coming soon rehypothecation of ETF shares that will absorb more demand then spot market would otherwise. This is what everyone cheering cross collateralization doesn't say. Also any attempt at ETF proof of reserves needs to try to factor in total share rehypothecation using DTCC data, which is not clear cut.
2) Eventually by way of high EFP requirements & changes to their S1s, some ETFs will lend some of their actual coin. In fact this could be done one day to relieve a conceptual stress scenario from #1 above.
Either way TradFi will eventually after being a tailwind for the coming cycle become a headwind to #bitcoin price appreciation at least for a future short to medium term perspective. Especially if price discovery moves to some degree to the ETFs, especially if derivatives markets grow to be many times the size of the spot market and the tail begins to exert it's will on the dog. One reason this could happen quicker than people think is because there isn't enough spot borrow to arb a potentially much larger derivatives markets with the spot market prior to ETF share rehypothecation, soon there will be. If 2022 proved anything it is a death sentence to naked rehypothecate spot #btc. That is why I expect TradFi to use high barriers to EFP (already in place) and a TradFi wrapper backed by force majeure contingencies (already in place), ability to turn off buys (i.e. GME) & ultimately support from the Fed (already in place for all DTCC solvancy scenarios).
To be clear this does not kill #btc and it does not impact the functionality of the network for those holding their own keys.
But if the above does play out some day, the only way to break free from the scenario is for continued protocol level adoption (not TradFi wrappers). If not #bitcoin for all of its advantages becomes gold from a price perspective. And a gold that no BRICs nation will want to monetize ahead of their existing gold bags.
I'm no bear and I'm dedicated to #bitcoin for the long game at play. But we can't fight (or compete) with that which isn't discussed. If anyone thinks I've missed something, happy to discuss to improve upon my thesis.
1) Coming soon rehypothecation of ETF shares that will absorb more demand then spot market would otherwise. This is what everyone cheering cross collateralization doesn't say. Also any attempt at ETF proof of reserves needs to try to factor in total share rehypothecation using DTCC data, which is not clear cut.
2) Eventually by way of high EFP requirements & changes to their S1s, some ETFs will lend some of their actual coin. In fact this could be done one day to relieve a conceptual stress scenario from #1 above.
Either way TradFi will eventually after being a tailwind for the coming cycle become a headwind to #bitcoin price appreciation at least for a future short to medium term perspective. Especially if price discovery moves to some degree to the ETFs, especially if derivatives markets grow to be many times the size of the spot market and the tail begins to exert it's will on the dog. One reason this could happen quicker than people think is because there isn't enough spot borrow to arb a potentially much larger derivatives markets with the spot market prior to ETF share rehypothecation, soon there will be. If 2022 proved anything it is a death sentence to naked rehypothecate spot #btc. That is why I expect TradFi to use high barriers to EFP (already in place) and a TradFi wrapper backed by force majeure contingencies (already in place), ability to turn off buys (i.e. GME) & ultimately support from the Fed (already in place for all DTCC solvancy scenarios).
To be clear this does not kill #btc and it does not impact the functionality of the network for those holding their own keys.
But if the above does play out some day, the only way to break free from the scenario is for continued protocol level adoption (not TradFi wrappers). If not #bitcoin for all of its advantages becomes gold from a price perspective. And a gold that no BRICs nation will want to monetize ahead of their existing gold bags.
I'm no bear and I'm dedicated to #bitcoin for the long game at play. But we can't fight (or compete) with that which isn't discussed. If anyone thinks I've missed something, happy to discuss to improve upon my thesis.