Twitxy Saved

Keith Robison

@OmicsOmicsBlog

Computational biologist in drug discovery since '96.
Boston, MA omicsomics.blogspot.com Joined February 2010
1.7K Following 10K Followers 116K Posts

Latest posts 5

Keith Robison @OmicsOmicsBlog
To me the more interesting question is why did Fleming basically sit on penicillin?

Only a decade+ later with a war on was septic work done to test it clinically and figure out how to scale up production
Saloni Verified account @salonium 1d
My first column for Works in Progress!

Science isn’t a series of lucky accidents.

I’ve been investigating stories of scientific discoveries for a while and it’s surprising how much the popular retellings flatten the real stories; some are entirely made up.

Alexander Fleming’s discovery of penicillin most likely didn’t come from an open window.

His colleagues testified the window was seldom, if ever, opened. The sequence hasn’t been replicated as he described, because penicillin would have needed to be present on the plate before the bacteria grew, as it blocks bacteria from building their cell walls, rather than killing them once they’ve grown.

Louis Pasteur’s discovery of the chicken cholera vaccine – the second-ever vaccine – is often said to be accidental too.

But historians have found the key experiments were done deliberately by Émile Roux, his assistant at the time, while Pasteur was away for his daughter’s wedding.

Wilhelm Röntgen’s accidental discovery of X-rays? The story was just a hypothesis by others later on.

Röntgen had his notes burned after his death, so it’s unclear what really happened. He had also long been in a dispute with Philipp Lenard over credit for the discovery, so there are reasons to be suspicious.

**

But what really happened? How did Fleming actually discover penicillin? Why burn or hide your notebooks? And most of all, why credit chance events instead of hard work?

For the first time, I’ve decided to come up with some half-cooked theories. Read them here and tell me what you think:
worksinprogress.co/issue/accident…
View quoted post on X