Twitxy Saved

Mary Phagan-Kean

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@PhaganKean

I’m Mary Phagan-Kean, grand-niece and namesake of Mary Phagan (1899–1913). My revised and expanded book on her story has just been published. Available NOW:
United States littlemaryphagan.com Joined November 2019
518 Following 5.3K Followers 7K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Mary Phagan-Kean Verified account @PhaganKean
Book Launch Announcement: The Truth About the Leo Frank Case

Uncovering a Century-Old Injustice that Lingers

In 1913, Leo M. Frank, an Atlanta factory manager, was convicted on August 25, 1913, of the brutal murder of 13-year-old Mary Phagan, a young employee. Despite overwhelming evidence, including his guilty verdicts upheld by multiple appellate tribunals and failed attempts to frame two innocent Black men, powerful forces are now pushing to rewrite history. The Anti-Defamation League of B'nai B'rith (ADL), backed by significant resources and a global network of ethnoreligious advocates, agitators and activists, seeks to overturn Frank’s conviction and portray him as a victim of anti-Semitism. Frank, a high-ranking B’nai B’rith official, was sentenced to death but lynched after a controversial executive commutation.

This book, The Murder of Little Mary Phagan (2025), reveals the shocking truth through meticulous research and primary documents contextualized with new eyes. Written by Mary Phagan-Kean (b. June 5, 1954), the great-niece and namesake of the victim, "little" Mary Anne Phagan, this expanded edition, more than doubles the size of the 1987 original, and includes extensive footnotes, references, context, hoax busting, and historical records. It represents a lifetime of dedication to uncovering the facts and honoring the true victim, Mary Phagan (1899 - 1913).

About the Author

Mary Phagan-Kean, a retired Education Program Specialist for Visual Impairment from Ellijay, Georgia, has spent decades researching the Leo Frank case. Committed to preserving her great-aunt’s legacy, she is available for media interviews and speaking engagements. Contact her via littlemaryphagan.com or by mail at P.O. Box 2573, 801 Industrial Blvd., Ellijay, GA 30540-9998.

Coming Soon

Stay tuned for the release of this definitive account, a labor of love exposing a century-long campaign to distort justice.
Mary Phagan-Kean Verified account @PhaganKean Aug 27, 2025
BACKCOVER OF MY NEW BOOK LAUNCH APPROACHING SOON:

Leo Frank raped and murdered Mary Phagan: In 1913, Leo M. Frank was an Atlanta sweatshop boss who routinely took sexual advantage of young girls in his employ. He raped and strangled 13-year-old little Mary Phagan to death. He was duly convicted and sentenced to die, but was lynched after a corrupt governor commuted his sentence. Today, over 100 years later, the powerful ADL (Anti-Defamation League) is scheming to get Leo Frank’s conviction overturned and to get him “fully exonerated” for his crime. They do this despite the massive mountain of evidence proving Frank guilty—despite the fact that his appeals were rejected and his guilty verdict affirmed thirteen separate times—and despite the fact that he and his backers tried to frame two innocent black men for the crime. This book tells the shocking true story in full.

My name is Mary Phagan-Kean and I am the great-niece and namesake of little Mary. This book is the great work of my lifetime. The first edition was published in 1987, and this new edition is greatly revised and expanded, more than twice as large as the first, with vastly more footnotes, references, and copies of original documents. It is the product of a half century of research, and it is a labor of love.Funded by a war chest of millions and with a staff of aggressive attorneys as long as your arm, the ADL, in concert with other Jewish groups, is working behind the scenes and through a sophisticated public relations campaign to convince political leaders and the public that Leo Frank was the “real victim” in this case—a victim, they claim, of anti-Semitism. Leo Frank, you see, was more than just a sweatshop boss—he was also a high-ranking official of the B’nai B’rith, the Jewish fraternal order that gave birth to the ADL.

About the Author: Mary Phagan-Kean is a retired Education Program Specialist for Visual Impairment from Ellijay, Georgia, and is the great-niece of Leo Frank’s victim, Mary Phagan. She has devoted decades to studying the Mary Phagan-Leo Frank case, and to public outreach and advocacy for its true victim. She is available for media interviews and speaking engagements. You may reach out to her through the contact form at her Web site littlemaryphagan.com or by writing her at P.O. Box 2573, 801 Industrial Blvd., Ellijay GA 30540-9998
View quoted post on X
68 replies 576 reposts 1.8K likes 284K views View on X
Mary Phagan-Kean Verified account @PhaganKean
Jake Tapper (@jaketapper) the Negro Nightwatchman Newt Lee Evidence Deserves an Answer

Jake Tapper, your description of the Leo Frank controversy elucidation by Kingsley Wilson @KingsleyCortes as “ahistorical antisemitic garbage” requires a closer examination of the evidence concerning Newt Lee.

The public accusation that Leo Max Frank attempted to direct suspicion toward his graveyard shift security guard was discussed during the original investigation, developed through testimony, and argued by the prosecution at Frank’s 1913 trial. Its historical basis can be examined in the Atlanta Constitution, Atlanta Georgian, Atlanta Journal, and the trial’s Brief of Evidence (Tapper, 1; AG, 22; AJ, 23; AC, 24). I publish those newspapers on my website at MaryPhagan.com

Kingsley Wilson’s statement that Frank “tried to frame a Black man” did not name that man. This account concerns Newt Lee specifically. It examines the prosecution’s argument that Frank’s changing description of Lee’s time slip, the request to search Frank’s residence, the suggestion that Lee had time to travel home, and the discovery of a bloody shirt at Lee’s residence formed a connected effort to redirect the investigation (Sales, 2). There were three pieces of evidence that attempted to Frame Newt Lee: a forged time slip, a blood soaked shirt planted at Lee's room, and death notes describing Newt Lee.

The Setting: A Black Watchman in Jim Crow Georgia

Newt Lee faced the investigation within a society that formally restricted Negro political participation and enforced racial segregation. Atlanta had experienced a deadly racial riot in 1906, over the rape of four White women. These conditions shaped the world in which a Black factory watchman was questioned about the death of a white girl (Cobb & Inscoe, 3). In 1913 Atlanta it was considered the ultimate crime for a Negro to rape and murder a White girl. This is what made Newt Lee the perfect Patsy for Leo Frank's racist plot to frame him for the Mary Phagan rape-murder, because the emotions would run high against a perceived Black assailant.

Saturday Night and Sunday Morning, April 26–27: Lee’s Duties and Discovery

Lee’s duties at the National Pencil Company included registering his rounds on a watchman’s clock at approximately half-hour intervals. The resulting paper record, variously called a time slip, (tape, or sheet), could therefore be used to test his account of where he had been during the night.

Lee testified that he discovered Mary Phagan’s body in the factory basement early Sunday morning, April 27, 1913, about 3:15 a.m., and summoned the police using the phone in Leo Frank's second floor office. According to the Georgian’s account of his trial testimony, officers “grabbed me and said I did it as soon as I showed them the body.” The man who reported the discovery immediately became a suspect (AG, 4). Two notes found next to the body immediately pointed to Lee as well.

Lee did not claim to have witnessed the killing. His testimony concerned his work, his encounters with Frank, the discovery, and the investigation.

Sunday, April 27: Frank Initially Approved the Record

Reporting Lee’s inquest testimony on April 30, the Georgian quoted him as saying that “on Sunday morning he said I had never lost a punch.” Lee attributed that statement to Frank (AG, 5).

The Georgian also reported that Frank described the record as regular when speaking to its reporter on Sunday afternoon (AG, 6).

The Journal’s April 30 inquest report described Lee maintaining his account under questioning. Lee recalled Frank’s approval: “He said it was all right.” It also placed assistant superintendent N. V. Darley in the examination of the clock record (AJ, 10).

Monday, April 28: Lee Said Frank Changed His Account

In the same April 30 inquest report, the Georgian quoted Lee’s account of the change: “he told me on Monday morning that the clock was not punched right” (AG, 5).

Lee described a changed explanation. The prosecution sought to prove deliberate manipulation through evidence about the paper’s handling, the clock’s operation, the suggested trip home, and the bloody shirt.

Monday, April 28: Herbert Haas Requested a Search of Frank’s Residence

Detective John R. Black later testified that Herbert Haas, one of Frank’s attorneys, requested a search of Frank’s residence and clothing. Black placed the request at approximately 11:30 a.m. on Monday, April 28, 1913, this was two days after the murder. It would have given Leo Frank enough time to wash out any stains in his dirty laundry.

Reporting Black’s testimony, the Journal described Haas’s insistence that “nothing should be left undone.” This was the newspaper’s account of Black’s explanation of events and communication, not an independently recorded quotation from Haas (AJ, 7).

The Alleged Opportunity: Enough Time for Lee to Go Home and Return

Black’s testimony connected the disputed clock record to a proposed journey by Lee. In the Brief of Evidence, Black attributed to Frank the claim that the irregular record allowed Lee enough time to go home and return. Black also acknowledged uncertainty about whether Frank made the statement before or after the bloody shirt was discovered (BOE, 8).

Tuesday, April 29: Police Found a Bloody Shirt at Lee’s Residence

Black’s account in the Brief of Evidence placed the discovery of a bloody shirt at Lee’s residence on Tuesday morning, April 29, at approximately 9 a.m. He described finding it among clothes in a barrel (BOE, 8).

The shirt gave the disputed time record an additional possible use. If investigators accepted that Lee had sufficient time to travel home, they could interpret the shirt as clothing he had removed after involvement in the killing.

The prosecution later argued that the shirt was planted and the suggested trip home helped make it appear incriminating (AJ, 23; AC, 24).

Wednesday, April 30: The Constitution Raised the Possibility of Planted Evidence

The possibility of a frame-up appeared in the Atlanta press within days of the murder. On April 30, the Constitution asked: “Is the watchman suspect a victim of planted evidence?” (AC, 9).

The same report described three gaps in the clock record: from 9:32 to 10:29 p.m., from 11:04 p.m. to midnight, and from 2 to 3 a.m. Those intervals amount to 57 minutes, 56 minutes, and 60 minutes. Each was roughly twice the expected half-hour interval (AC, 9).

These separate gaps did not establish a continuous three-hour absence or prove that Lee left the building, but everyone wanted to know how the time slip went from being "alright" according to Leo Frank, on Sunday, April 27, 1913, to becoming mispunched four times on Monday, April 28, 1913, according to the factory boss.

Wednesday, April 30: Frank’s Newspaper Interview Added Another Statement

The Journal also published an interview in which Frank expressed surprise at the suggestion that Lee had failed to register regularly. Frank reportedly said: “I don't remember ever having heard of Lee's failing to punch the clock at regular intervals” (AJ, 11).

This was a newspaper interview, not sworn inquest testimony.

If Frank had already identified the irregularities attributed to Lee, why did his interview express unfamiliarity with Lee missing regular registrations? The accounts described different conversations and require comparison.

Thursday, May 8: “Boots” Rogers Challenged the Missing-Punch Account

W. W. “Boots” Rogers, a former policeman and squadcar driver who accompanied officers during the early investigation, became a particularly useful witness because he said he had personally observed the slip.

At the continued inquest on May 8, the Georgian reported Rogers’s statement: “Frank took it into the office and put it on file.” Asked about missing registrations, Rogers answered: “I would have noticed if there were” (AG, 12).

The Journal’s May 8 report likewise described Rogers as seeing an apparently regular record. It also made clear that he did not know what happened to the slip after Frank took it into the office (AJ, 13).

July 28–29: Newt Lee Repeated His Account at Frank’s Trial

Frank’s trial began on Monday, July 28, 1913. Lee’s examination continued into Tuesday, July 29.

The Brief of Evidence preserves Lee’s account of Frank’s original assessment: “Mr. Frank opened the clock and said the punches were all right, that I hadn't missed any punches” (BOE, 8).

The Journal’s July 29 account recorded Lee’s response to the bloody shirt: “Somebody must have been trying to put it (the murder of Phagan) off on me.” He believed someone had tried to implicate him, but did not identify the planter from personal observation (AJ, 15).

Tuesday, July 29: Detective Starnes Demonstrated That the Clock Could Be Manipulated

Detective John N. Starnes addressed whether the clock record could be manufactured. The Georgian reported a demonstration in which a new watchman produced what appeared to be approximately twelve hours of registrations in about five minutes. The report explained that the state intended to support its contention that “Frank doctored the time tape submitted to the police department” (AG, 16).

The demonstration established that a misleading record could be manufactured quickly. It did not show who, if anyone, had altered Lee’s slip.

Wednesday, July 30: Rogers Repeated His Evidence Before the Jury

The Georgian reported his statement: “There did not appear to be any skip in it.” Its account placed this evidence in the July 30 trial coverage, on page 2, columns 5–6 (AG, 17).

Rogers was one of the prosecution’s strongest witnesses on the initial condition of the slip because he claimed personal observation. Lee could testify about his own rounds and what Frank told him. Rogers could add that he had looked at the record and had not observed the alleged gaps.

Wednesday, July 30: Detective Black Connected Frank to the Changed Explanation

Black was the most direct police witness concerning Frank’s alleged suggestion that Lee had time to leave the factory.

But Black’s chronology was vulnerable. The Georgian quoted him as saying, “He told me Tuesday,” when questioned about the changed account. Lee had placed Frank’s changed statement on Monday morning (AG, 17).

The Constitution’s July 31 report emphasized the difficulties created by Black’s cross-examination. It stated that “Black’s answers failed to bear out the contention of the solicitor” (AC, 18).

The strongest presentation uses Black for what he specifically attributed to Frank, Rogers for the initially regular appearance of the record, and Starnes for the clock’s susceptibility to manipulation.

Thursday, July 31: Harry Scott’s Testimony Complicated the Monday Chronology

Pinkerton detective Harry Scott described a Monday afternoon discussion in which Frank mentioned the first and last clock registrations without drawing attention to the alleged gaps.

The Journal summarized that part of Scott’s evidence: “No discrepancy was remarked by Frank then” (AJ, 7).

Scott’s account complicates the claim that Frank consistently emphasized the gaps throughout Monday. The prosecution had to show that the shifting explanations reflected an attempt to implicate Lee.

Thursday, July 31: The Shirt’s Condition Supported the Planting Argument

Dr. Claude A. Smith’s examination of the bloody shirt gave the prosecution another basis for questioning the evidence against Lee.

Reporting his testimony on August 1, the Journal quoted him: “It had every appearance of having been washed, but not worn.” Smith described features including the condition of the collar, the absence of the expected odor under the arms, and blood staining that raised questions about whether the garment had been worn when stained (AJ, 19).

The observations supported the planting argument without identifying a planter. The defense challenged Smith’s conclusions and the reliability of the indicators he used.

Monday, August 18: Frank Gave His Explanation

In his unsworn statement to the jury, Frank explained that the initial examination had been mistaken. He described looking at the arrangement of the registrations without initially recognizing the missing intervals. He also disputed the implication that his handling of the slip established wrongdoing (Frank, 20).

Saturday, August 23: Dorsey Connected the Slip, the Search, and the Shirt

The Georgian’s August 23 report quoted him saying: “There was not enough evidence against Newt Lee.” Dorsey then argued that the request to search Frank’s residence, associated with Haas, was connected to the suggestion that Lee had time to leave the factory and go home. The relevant passage appears on printed page 3, column 7 (AG, 22).

The Journal’s report, under “The Time Clock Slips” on page 4, column 2, recorded Dorsey’s argument that Frank had suggested “Newt Lee had time to go out to his house and change his clothes.” Dorsey connected that proposition to the subsequent discovery of the shirt (AJ, 23).

Sunday, August 24: The Constitution Published the Argument About Frank’s Changed Figures

Under the subheading “Evidence All Planted,” Dorsey argued that Frank initially described the clock record as accurate, but subsequently changed his position when the shirt required an opportunity for Lee to have visited his residence. The newspaper quoted the accusation that Frank “accordingly changed his figures and altered his statement” (AC, 24).

This was Dorsey’s accusation of changed figures and explanation, not eyewitness testimony that Frank manufactured a replacement slip.

What Can Be Argued About Haas’s Role

Dorsey’s interpretation treated the invitation to search Frank’s residence as a means of encouraging a corresponding search of Lee’s residence. Within that theory, an apparently cooperative request could help direct the investigation toward another suspect (AG, 22; AJ, 23). It was regarded as an intimation, or suggestion by proxy. At the time Leo Frank was not arrested, and Newt Lee was arrested as the prime suspect.

The Racial Language Surrounding Lee

The newspapers’ descriptions of Lee show the racial attitudes within which his evidence was received.

The Journal’s July 29 profile described him as possessing “the wit and the manner of darkies in old-time slavery days.” That patronizing comparison appeared in its coverage of a Black witness whose liberty had been endangered by the investigation (AJ, 15).

The language shows how even favorable descriptions could place Lee within a sentimentalized image of slavery. He was a working man giving evidence about a murder investigation, yet the newspaper presented his personality through a racial stereotype.

The prosecution’s framing theory therefore has a racial dimension. If Lee was deliberately made to appear guilty, the attempt would have exploited a society already disposed to treat a Black laborer as a convenient suspect.

The Strongest Historical Argument

Lee said Frank first approved the time record and later criticized it. Rogers said he saw no apparent gaps in the original slip. Black attributed to Frank the suggestion that Lee had sufficient time to travel home. Starnes demonstrated that the clock could produce a misleading record in a matter of minutes if someone had the key to open the clock. Testimony about the shirt’s condition supported the prosecution’s allegation that it had been prepared as incriminating evidence. Dorsey brought those points together in his closing argument.

That is a substantial circumstantial case for examining whether Frank attempted to redirect suspicion toward Lee. It is also an argument with identifiable weaknesses: disputed custody of the slip, inconsistent recollections about timing, an explanation based on an initial misreading, and no cited eyewitness who saw Frank forge the paper or plant the shirt.

Those weaknesses should be assessed against the evidence. They do not erase the evidence or make the historical accusation imaginary.

The Questions Jake Tapper Should Answer

Mr. Tapper, which part of this contemporary record do you contend is ahistorical? Lee’s testimony that Frank initially approved the slip? Rogers’s account of seeing no apparent missing punches? Black’s testimony about the proposed trip home by Frank? The demonstration of the clock’s operation that showed a time slip could be forged if someone had a key to open the clock? Or Dorsey’s published argument connecting the slip, Haas’s request, and the bloody shirt?

A serious response should explain how those records are to be understood. The fact that a prosecution argument was made does not prove it correct. The fact that Frank was Jewish does not place the conduct attributed to him beyond historical examination.

Frank’s subsequent lynching was indefensible. An examination of the allegation that Lee was almost framed for murder by Leo Frank does not justify that killing. It asks whether another man’s vulnerability was exploited during the investigation and whether the surviving evidence supports that charge.

The strongest questions are specific: Who possessed the slip between its initial examination and its later production? Police argued Leo Frank retained Lee's time slip in his custody.

Which witness first identified the time slip on Sunday as punched correctly, but then on Monday stated it was missing intervals? Leo Frank.

When did Frank suggest that Lee had time to travel home? An officer stated Frank said that on Tuesday, but he wasn't sure, it might have been Monday.

What explains the condition of the bloodstained shirt found at Newt Lee’s home on Tuesday, April 29, 1913? Lee had been arrested at 3:30 a.m. on Sunday, April 27, 1913. If the shirt was planted while he was in custody, who put it there, and who had the means, access, and motive to arrange its placement? Could the demand made on Monday, April 28, 1913, to search Leo Frank’s dirty laundry have been intended to prompt a similar search of Lee’s clothing, directing police toward evidence planted to incriminate a man already behind bars?

And how well does the prosecution’s interpretation account for the evidence compared with the explanation Frank offered?

References

Abbreviations: AC refers to the Atlanta Constitution; AG to the Atlanta Georgian; AJ to the Atlanta Journal; and BOE to the trial’s Brief of Evidence. “Frank” identifies Leo M. Frank’s own statement. Numbers identify the references below.

Tapper, J. [@jaketapper]. (n.d.). This is indeed ahistorical antisemitic garbage [Post]. X. x.com/jaketapper/sta…

Sales, B. (2025, March 5). Pentagon official posted neo-Nazi talking point about Jewish lynching victim Leo Frank last year. Jewish Telegraphic Agency. jta.org/2025/03/05/pol…

Cobb, J. C., & Inscoe, J. C. (2020, September 30). Georgia history: Overview. New Georgia Encyclopedia. georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/histo…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, July 28). Mary Phagan’s mother testifies. maryphagan.com/1913-07-28-mar…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, April 30). Newt Lee’s testimony as he gave it at the inquest. Night Extra, p. 2, col. 3, for the quoted Sunday-to-Monday account. maryphagan.com/1913-04-30-new…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, April 30). Clock misses add mystery to Phagan case. Night Extra, p. 3, col. 1. maryphagan.com/1913-04-30-clo…

The Atlanta Journal. (1913, July 31). Machinist tells of finding blood, hair and pay envelope on second floor where state claims girl was murdered. Relevant testimony of John R. Black and Harry Scott appears on pp. 4–5. maryphagan.com/1913-07-31-mac…

Fulton County Superior Court. (1913). Brief of evidence in the case of Leo M. Frank [Trial record]. Relevant passages include Newt Lee, p. 4; John N. Starnes, p. 10; W. W. Rogers, pp. 13–14; John R. Black, pp. 17–19; Harry Scott, p. 24; N. V. Darley, pp. 37–39; and Dr. Claude A. Smith, p. 46. Page numbers refer to the printed record. leofrank.org/library/leo-m-…

The Atlanta Constitution. (1913, April 30). Factory clock not punched for hours on night of murder. P. 1, cols. 6–7; continued on p. 2, col. 1. maryphagan.com/1913-04-30-fac…

The Atlanta Journal. (1913, April 30). Negro watchman tells story of finding girl’s body and questions fail to shake him. Relevant clock testimony appears on p. 6, cols. 5–6. maryphagan.com/1913-04-30-neg…

The Atlanta Journal. (1913, April 30). Use of dictaphone on Frank and Negro is denied by police. Frank’s reported interview appears on p. 7, col. 1. maryphagan.com/1913-04-30-use…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, May 8). “Boots” Rogers tells how body was found. Home Edition, p. 2, cols. 2–3. maryphagan.com/1913-05-08-boo…

The Atlanta Journal. (1913, May 8). Phagan inquest in session; six witnesses are examined before adjournment to 2:30. Relevant Rogers testimony appears on p. 8, col. 2. maryphagan.com/1913-05-08-pha…

The Atlanta Constitution. (1913, May 9). Frank and Lee ordered held by coroner’s jury for Mary Phagan murder. Frank’s testimony about the slip’s custody appears on p. 2, col. 2. maryphagan.com/1913-05-09-fra…

The Atlanta Journal. (1913, July 29). Frequent clashes over testimony mark second day of Frank trial. The quoted racial characterization of Lee appears on p. 1, col. 3. maryphagan.com/1913-07-29-fre…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, July 29). Defense wins point after fierce lawyers’ clash. Extra Final, p. 1, cols. 7–8, for the clock demonstration and the state’s stated theory. maryphagan.com/1913-07-29-def…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, July 30). Gantt has startling evidence; Dorsey promises new testimony against Frank. Extra Final. Relevant Rogers testimony appears on p. 2, cols. 5–6; Black’s testimony appears on p. 4, col. 3. maryphagan.com/1913-07-30-gan…

The Atlanta Constitution. (1913, July 31). Defense riddles John Black’s testimony. Pp. 1–3; the lead begins on p. 1, col. 7. maryphagan.com/1913-07-31-def…

The Atlanta Journal. (1913, August 1). Lawyers battle over testimony of Frank’s nervousness; witness swears Negro was in factory about 1 o’clock. Includes the report of Dr. Claude A. Smith’s testimony concerning the bloody shirt. maryphagan.com/1913-08-01-law…

Frank, L. M. (1913, August 18). Oral statement of Leo M. Frank. In Brief of evidence [Unsworn statement to the jury]. leofrank.com/leo-frank-tria…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, August 19). Dorsey admits he made erasure on factory time slip. P. 1, col. 7. Reproduced within the online compilation headed “Jim Conley to be recalled.” maryphagan.com/1913-08-19-jim…

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, August 23). Dorsey assails Frank’s alibi; charges perjury. Pp. 2–3. The relevant passage appears on printed p. 3, col. 7, under “Saw it was futile to make Lee guilty.” Printed p. 3 is image 7 in this PDF. leofrank.org/enright-archiv…

The Atlanta Journal. (1913, August 23). Frank trial adjourned until Monday morning with Solicitor Hugh Dorsey in midst of impassioned speech. “The Time Clock Slips” section, p. 4, col. 2. maryphagan.com/1913-08-23-fra…

The Atlanta Constitution. (1913, August 24). Solicitor reasserts his conviction of bad character and guilt of Frank. Pp. 2–3. The relevant passage appears on p. 3, col. 2, under “Evidence All Planted.” leofrank.org/solicitor-reas…
Jake Tapper 🦅 Verified account @jaketapper 9h
This is indeed ahistorical antisemitic garbage.

The same deranged nonsense tweeted out by the current Pentagon press secretary a few months before she was hired.
View quoted post on X
1 replies 4 reposts 18 likes 570 views View on X
Mary Phagan-Kean Verified account @PhaganKean
Content warning: the case of Mary Phagan, the 13-year-old girl murdered on April 26, 1913, is the subject of this post.

From the Georgia Supreme Court appeal record, slides 0114, 0115: more of Jim Conley's cross-examination in Leo Max Frank's trial.

Under cross-examination by Frank's lawyers Luther Z. Rosser and Reuben R. Arnold, the questions keep Conley on the girl he watched for, what she wore, and what Frank told him afterward about Mr. Herbert and Mr. Darley.

The defense version, then and now: Conley lied about watching.

The prosecution's answer at the time: his story survived days of cross-examination.

Our modern rebuttal: the jury convicted Frank. The Georgia Supreme Court affirmed the sufficiency of the evidence. The courts left his conviction undisturbed.

Forever 13 and Never forgotten.

#MaryPhagan #JimConley #LutherRosser #ReubenArnold #JusticeForMaryPhagan

. . .

Appendix: Full slide transcripts

. . .

Slide 0114

Thanksgiving Day had on white shoes and stockings.

Q. Now, the next day what did she have on? A. The next day she had on the same thing, black skirt and white waist.

Q. She had on exactly the same thing? A. Yes sir.

Q. And this other---There was a girl dressed in green all over?
A. Yes, sir, there was a girl dressed in green all over, this last one.

Q. And you don't know who she is? A. No sir; she worked up there on the fourth floor, but I don't know her name.

Q. You don't know whether she works there now or not? A. No sir, I don't know whether she works there now or not. I haven't been there----

Q. She worked there when you left? A. She had been there that morning: I don't know whether she was there that evening.

Q. And you saw here there? A. Yes sir.

Q. Did she have on a green dress that morning? A. No sir, she didn't have on a green dress that morning.

Q. What kind? A. A dirty black dress with paints on it.

Q. Well, they all have that don't they? A. Yes sir, when they are at work.

Q. You didn't see her when she had her working dress off?
A. No sir, I didn't see her that day when she had her working dress off.

Q. You never inquired who she was? No sir, I never inquired who she was because it wasn't none of my business.

Q. Did she speak to you? A. No sir.

Q. Well, she's the one anyway? A. Yes sir.

Q. She was the other one? A. Yes sir.

Q. Now Jim, don't everybody in that factory know Jim Conley?
A. No sir, didn't everybody in that factory know me.

Q. Given me one of them? A. I don't know, sir, I don't know whether they all knew me or not.

Q. Didn't the lady go up and down on the elevator at all? [line smudged on this slide; read from the printed Brief of Evidence, slide 0842]

A. No sir, the girls never did.

Q. You swept on the fourth floor? Q. Yes sir, I swept on the fourth floor a while. 31

Q. How long did you sweep on the fourth floor? A. Been

. . .

Slide 0115

sweeping up there ever since last January.

Q. You saw that little girl every day, that went to meet Mr. Frank, didn't you? A. This last one.

Q. Yes, A. I didn't see her every day, but I seen her there.

Q. Saw her many times and didn't ask who she was? A. No sir, I didn't ask who she was.

Q. Don't know who she was?
A. No sir, I don't know who she was.

Q. Now, when she came in, did she see you when she came in?
A. Yes sir, she seen me as she come in.

Q. Where did she go?
A. She went to Mr. Frank's office.

Q. Then you went and watched? A. Yes sir, then I went and watched.

Q. You didn't see them leave nor hear them leave Mr. Frank's office?
A. No sir, I didn't see them leave and I didn't hear them leave Mr. Frank's office.

Q. How long did you stay there? A. Half an hour, I reckon.

Q. And she cameout?
A. Yes sir.

Q. What became of Mr. Frank? A. He came out and left me up in the office and he went out somewhere, I don't know where he went, and then he came back and says: "That's all right, I didn't take out any money".

Q. He went out somewhere?
A. Yes sir.

Q. You mean he went out in town somewhere? A. I don't know whether he went out in town or not.

Q. Didn't you open the door?
A. Yes, sir, I opened the door.

Q. Well, he went out of the factory? A. Yes sir.

Q. And then went back?
A. Yes sir.

Q. And you stayed there waiting for him? A. Yes sir.

Q. What did you say he said?
A. He said "I didn't take out that money, didn't you see I didn't?" I says: "Yes sir, I seed you didn't". He said"That's all right, old boy, I don't want you to have anything to say to Mr. Herbert or Mr. Darley about what's going on around here".

Q. He told you he didn't wantyou to tell Darley?
A. Yes sir.

Q. And then the next time, now, was Thanksgiving Day?

Yes sir, the next time was Thanksgiving Day.

Q. What hour was it Thanksgiving Day? A. I don't know, sir,
32

. . .

References

Georgia Supreme Court. (1913). Brief of evidence, Jim Conley cross-examination, Slide 0114 [Appeal record, Frank v. State]. maryphagan.com/0114-slide-geo…

Georgia Supreme Court. (1913). Brief of evidence, Jim Conley cross-examination, Slide 0115 [Appeal record, Frank v. State]. maryphagan.com/0115-slide-geo…
0 replies 0 reposts 15 likes 399 views View on X
Mary Phagan-Kean Verified account @PhaganKean
This post is part of our series on the 1913 murder of Mary Phagan, age 13, in Atlanta.

On this day, Thursday, November 20, 1913, 113 years ago, The Atlanta Georgian reported that William M. Smith would fight any further delay of Jim Conley's trial and would protest that afternoon to Solicitor General Hugh Manson Dorsey and Judge Benjamin Harvey Hill.

"Conley's Attorney To Combat Further Delay in His Case"

Dorsey said the same day that Conley's trial had been put off indefinitely. Conley faced a misdemeanor charge and an accessory-after-the-fact charge in Mary's murder.

He had appeared in Judge Hill's court several times without being tried.

Smith's version: Conley was entitled to a prompt hearing.

Dorsey's answer: the trial had been put off indefinitely.

Our modern rebuttal: the accessory calendar fight was a side door. The main case against Leo Max Frank had already produced a guilty verdict.

The Georgia Supreme Court later affirmed that verdict.

Forever 13 and Never forgotten.

#MaryPhagan #JimConley #AtlantaGeorgian #HughDorsey #Forever13

. . .

Appendix: Full article transcript

. . .

The Atlanta Georgian
Thursday, November 20, 1913, Home Edition
Page 1, Column 4

Conley's Attorney To Combat Further Delay in His Case

That a further postponement of the trial of Jim Conley, the negro witness in the Phagan case, will be bitterly fought, was the declaration of W. M. Smith, Conley's attorney, Thursday.

Attorney Smith stated that he would hold a conference with Solicitor Dorsey and Judge Ben Hill, in whose court the trial will be heard, Thursday afternoon when he would protest against a further delay in the hearing of his client's case, and would urge its immediate disposal.

Solicitor Dorsey Thursday stated, however, that the negro's trial had been put off indefinitely.

Conley, who is being held on two charges—one a misdemeanor and the other as being accessory after the fact to the Phagan murder, has appeared in Judge Hill's court on several occasions, but without being called to trial.

. . .

References

The Atlanta Georgian. (1913, November 20). Conley's attorney to combat further delay in his case. maryphagan.com/1913-11-20-con…
0 replies 2 reposts 10 likes 290 views View on X
Mary Phagan-Kean Verified account @PhaganKean
On this day, Thursday, November 20, 1913, 113 years ago, The Atlanta Constitution reported that Jim Conley's accessory case would likely be called again before Judge Benjamin Harvey Hill, but that Conley would probably go back to the Tower until Frank's appeal was decided.

"Jim Conley's Case Will Come Up Again Today"

Both Solicitor General Hugh Manson Dorsey and William M. Smith, Conley's lawyer, wanted the case moved. Judge Hill had told court attaches he would keep putting it off.

Smith had just returned from Macon and planned to urge the court to dispose of the case one way or another.

The Conley-defense version: endless delay denied him a speedy trial.

Judge Hill's answer: Frank's Supreme Court fight came first.

Our modern rebuttal: Conley's rush for an accessory trial was about locking in immunity from a murder charge. It does not clear Frank.

The jury had already convicted Frank as principal, and the Georgia Supreme Court later affirmed.

Forever 13 and Never forgotten.

#MaryPhagan #JimConley #JudgeBenHill #AtlantaConstitution #Atlanta

. . .

Appendix: Full article transcript

. . .

The Atlanta Constitution
Thursday, November 20, 1913
Page 12, Column 7

JIM CONLEY'S CASE WILL COME UP AGAIN TODAY
It Is Improbable, However, That the Negro Will Be Tried.

Jim Conley's case will probably be called in Judge Ben Hill's criminal branch of the superior court today. However, from the best advices available late last night, the negro will again be sent back to the Tower to await the decision in the Frank case now before the supreme court and in which Conley is held as an accessory after the fact.

Judge Hill has outlined his stand in the Conley case to court attaches and he will undoubtedly again today place the case further along on the criminal docket, it is said, despite the pleas of both Solicitor General Dorsey and the negro's attorney, William Smith.

Attorney Smith arrived in Atlanta late last night from Macon, where he had been attending a trial. It is understood that despite Judge Hill's wishes in the matter Smith will make an impassioned address to the court this morning in an effort to have the court proceed with the Conley case and dispose of it one way or another.

. . .

References

The Atlanta Constitution. (1913, November 20). Jim Conley's case will come up again today (p. 12, col. 7). maryphagan.com/1913-11-20-nat…