Pinned post
Philip Goff
Verified account This account is verified. Learn more@Philip_Goff
Philosophy Prof
"One of the most persuasive panpsychists" Stephen Fry.
philipgoff.substack.com/p/my-worst-per…
"One of the most persuasive panpsychists" Stephen Fry.
philipgoff.substack.com/p/my-worst-per…
2.4K Following 37K Followers 34K Posts
Latest posts 5
Correlation and reduction are very different things.
That is not true. There is a large body of cognitive neuroscience data that shows that there are neural correlates of "feelings." See, e.g. Machado, Leonardo, and Amaury Cantilino. "A systematic review of the neural correlates of positive emotions." Revista Brasileira de Psiquiatria 39.02 (2016): 172-179.View quoted post on X
you're missing a premise...
@Philip_Goff 1. If physicalism is true, I am a mechanism.View quoted post on X
2. I have feelings.
3. Therefore, some mechanisms have feelings.
For those wanting the full argument supporting these premises...
1. If physicalism is true, I am a mechanism.View quoted post on X
2. Mechanisms don't have feelings.
3. I have feelings.
4. Therefore, I'm not a mechanism.
5. Therefore, physicalism as false.
Lots to debate on each premise, but in some sense I think it's as simple as that.
Sure, it's the start of the argument rather than the argument itself. But it's a good way to frame the core intuition of my camp:
You can't reduce a feeling to a pattern of behaviour. And ultimately physical science is exclusively a story about patterns of behaviour.
You can't reduce a feeling to a pattern of behaviour. And ultimately physical science is exclusively a story about patterns of behaviour.
@Philip_Goff 2) begs the questionView quoted post on X