Twitxy Saved

Colonel PK Choudhary (retd)

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@PkchowIA

Unite🇮🇳 ! संविधान का सिपाही, Lawyer,Scuba Diver, Mountaineer,जननी जन्म भूमिश्च,स्वरगादपि गरीयसि;वसुधैव कुटुम्बकम! SECULAR🇮🇳
Joined January 2021
880 Following 957 Followers 7.3K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Colonel PK Choudhary (retd) Verified account @PkchowIA
Friends often ask me why I get into engagement with such people who have no class?

So why do some of us choose to get into a wrestling match with pigs on Social Media? After all, the SM is an arena where anyone can write anything and get away with it too.

Post 2014, the Bhakts and Right Wingers took over this space and became abusive, vile, combative. People with self respect decided to stay away. That gave these ill bred people even more freedom and they literally became the owners of this space, more emboldened and more abusive.

Now the choice for the real Deshbhakts is just one. This space has to be fought for. If it’s left to these brown shirts the country will be destroyed. Our forefathers gave their lives to build this great Nation and we too have to do our part. This is our Pind Daan to them.

Getting abused by these people shouldn’t deter us. When they abuse they disclose their upbringing, not our’s. These lunatics have to be reined in. The Gen Z has given them a bloody nose and they are now badly rattled. So let’s fight for “ India that is Bharat”.
Rahul Roushan Verified account @rahulroushan Oct 18
@UnSubtleDesi Hello @grok please translate this insult into Bihari hindi using abusive slangs so that @PkchowIA can understand better.
View quoted post on X
36 replies 44 reposts 224 likes 18K views View on X
Colonel PK Choudhary (retd) Verified account @PkchowIA
The biggest flaw with Army is that its policies are very inconsistent & personality based.
Let me illustrate one eg.that has divided the Arny internally permanently. Some day some visionary COAS WILL HAVE TO ADDRESS THIS ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM. The mischief makers were the then COAS, Gen Deepak Kapoor and the later court marshaled Lt Gen Avdhesh Prakash(Inf). The dress issue is a very small one comparatively.

1. Prior to the AVSC Ph 2 implementation( 2009) a FAIR pro rata system of Vac allocation for selection to higher ranks was in vogue. On an average each Corps used to get roughly equal percentage of vacancies based on its officer strength.
2. In the new model called Command Exit Model (CEM) different command tenures were fixed for different Corps. The AVSC justified shorter command tenure for “Operational(Op) Units” but gave command tenures Corps wise in four arbitrary shades- 2.5 Years for Infantry(Inf), 3 Years for two other Arms, 4 for the Support(Sp) Arms & 5 for the services units despite all these units being “operational”- Arty despite being a Sp Arms was kept ahead of the other 3 Sp Arms because Gen Deepak Kapoor was the COAS. The final rec as given in Para 73 of the AVSC gives the age for various ranks equally and without discrimination which is quite at dissonance with CEM. AVSC is a very poor report.
3. Seen innocently, the command tenure of units is an adm matter & a military fn but in reality it’s a mischief on the basis of Corps loyalties rather than loyalty for the Army & the Country. If the command tenure is longer it means blocking of that position for longer duration and hence lesser surplus vacancies for that Corps. For eg it means almost double extra vacancy for infantry viz a viz Services.
4. The AVSC report implementation was objected to by all the Army Commanders & all the heads of the various Arms & Service except inf. Only Gen VK Singh supported it. I have all the letters.
5. The AVSC report is bad in law, principle & consistency. Firstly, it misrepresents the Services as non op. THE AHQ has now admitted this blunder but court disposal remains. The Sp Arms ultimately got relief from the Supreme Court -141 Col Vac. The Sp Arms are again in SC for their rightful claim to higher rks of Brigs & Maj Gens in Appeal after winning in the Ld. AFT,New Delhi .
Now the questions that arise are :
a) If the justifications of shorter command were for Op units then why four different classes within the Op units ?
b) Throughout the AVSC, “Arms” have been treated as one special & specific subset. Why discrimination within Arms with Inf having a tenure of 2.5 while the other two Arms ie Armoured & Mech Inf with 3 years at par with Sp Arms ? It translates to a Vacancy loss of 20%.
c) The colossal RR & AR Vac have not even been factored into what the Inf is shown as getting.
d) Why is the PRV( pro rata vacancy)of Inf hovering at 0.58 for No 3 SB(Selection Boards) 0.5 for No 2 SB (Col & Brig)while it is far less for the other two Arms ?
e) While the pro rata system was converted to Exit model for No 3 SB (promotion to Col), thereby giving immense PRV edge to Infantry at this level, the General cadre Vac were converted from Merit Model to Pro rata because Inf was losing there- Extant policies were changed to reward inf over the others. The higher rk must be Merit based only. As on date the Lt Gen and above rks and the COAS appt are virtually under Infantry control.
f) The above is not just bad for Army but also for the Country because the Equal caliber spread is not happening between the Corps & we are creating many weak links.
g) There is a general loss of morale in 80% of Army and a heavy loss of camaraderie. The multiple litigations on AVSC are a proof.
h) It’s not good for Inf either. The top 30% who would have been promoted anyways are getting diluted with the other 30%. The remaining 40% at the bottom feel more miserable because they are now identified as such (Not promoted despite the uplifting).
Lt Col Sushil Singh Sheoran, Veteran Verified account @sushilskinner 23h
"Let a zebra be a zebra and a mule be a mule.”

The COAS made an excellent decision by restoring the pre-2023 code for brigadier and above. The original decision was flawed from the outset, shaped by a narrow perspective. After 26 years of wearing a particular uniform and being formed into a capable officer, an officer does not suddenly become someone entirely different upon promotion to brigadier. Regimental spirit, ethos, and excellence do not disappear overnight.

Changing the uniform does not eliminate parochialism or regimental bias. An officer’s service record reveals their background, and it is available to their IO, RO, and SRO. Everyone knows everyone.

What must change is the pro rata system, which is now statutory. There is a form of reservation in the armed forces that few acknowledge: pro rata, with the infantry benefiting most. Merit is not always the deciding factor. An all-arms officer may be considered capable of commanding a company in the RR, even at the risk of their life, yet not qualified to command because the position is reserved for someone else.

A decision made with narrow vision has now been put where it belongs. I am confident that more sensible decisions are forthcoming to reverse actions taken to advance personal agendas. Thank you, Chief. Thank you, Sir.
View quoted post on X
1 replies 4 reposts 14 likes 2.2K views View on X
Colonel PK Choudhary (retd) Verified account @PkchowIA
Quite interesting to see the Bhakts getting outraged by Rahul Gandhi mentioning his mother in his father’s lap. And how do they show their indignation ?

By using obscenities, profanities and bedroom imaginations that are too gross by even today’s standards.

For eg @Iyervval is also a Bhakt. He is also aghast at RG’s statement. Look at how he writes. This is true for most Bhakts. They are the most vulgar and abusive people.
30 replies 37 reposts 158 likes 8.4K views View on X
Colonel PK Choudhary (retd) Verified account @PkchowIA
The Bhakts need to know few basics:

1.I’m not a Congressman. I oppose lack of internal democracy in Congress Party.

2. I would like to defend not just Rahul Gandhi (RG) but everyone’s freedom of expression within the limits defined under Article 19. As such RG talking about the love between his parents in a more overt way than is normal in many households is his business.
3. Surprisingly those who are outraged by RG’s simpler statement are the ones who are publicly arguing with real vulgarity which is actually outrageous.

4. The people who started moving on the slippery slope argument of bedroom scenes of parents’ sex/ personal insinuations of such kinds are displaying their poor analytical capabilities.
5. It’s entirely possible that while I or many others defend RG’s right to express his parental love we may not ourselves be culturally that open.
6. Lastly, it’s a dream for every kid to see his parents in a lovely relationship. Most families are disturbed or broken. Within what’s possible culturally for different families, it’s preferable and covetous to have such a bonhomie in all families rather than a tight environment.
Wow Seems this is normal in your family too, your wife sitting in your lap and your kids watching their mom playing in their father's lap every day.
Italians don't have sanskar is understandble.
Piti Even your parents didn't gave you sanskar.
Wt nxt bedroom stories?
View quoted post on X