Twitxy Saved

Paul Nary

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@ProfPaulNary

M&A/strategy professor @Wharton | Deal junkie | Evidence-based M&A, corporate strategy, PE, and activism | All opinions and errors my own | No investment advice
Philadelphia, PA paulnary.com Joined May 2012
781 Following 23K Followers 3.9K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Paul Nary Verified account @ProfPaulNary
Coca-Cola's misguided $5.1B acquisition of Costa Coffee is my favorite recent example of Total Addressable Market (TAM) abuse and misuse

Hot beverages are a HALF TRILLION DOLLAR TAM opportunity!

Meanwhile it's a totally different business and they have no idea how to even run it, much less create synergies (which Coke's management could not even properly articulate at the time).

$KO announced acquisition of Costa in 2018. After failing to squeeze out any real synergies and mismanaging the business (2024 sales were below 2018), it shopped Costa around to potential buyers, mostly PE firms, in 2025, but no deal materialized.

According to the rumors, they weren't able to get any solid bids above maybe half the original purchase price.

Meanwhile, the TAM is still there.. just saying.
ᯓ➤ Ben M&A Verified account @benperor Sep 9
TAM is the revenue opportunity available if a product captured every customer in a given market.

A software company selling invoicing tools, for example, might calculate TAM by counting every small business on Earth, multiplying by the average annual spend on accounting software.

Most business owners incrrectly treat TAM as validation.

"There are 50 million potential customers out there, so our idea is worth pursuing." The size of the market tells you almost nothing about whether this particular business can win in it.

What actually matters is the wedge you can realistically capture.

Not every company needs a billion-dollar TAM to be profitable and valuable.

The second mistake is confusing TAM with demand.

A massive market means opportunity exists somewhere.

It doesn't mean customers are ready to buy your version of the solution.

A competitor with better distribution, lower prices, or earlier market entry will capture most of the addressable market, leaving newcomers with crumbs.

If the wedge you can realistically target is small enough that reaching profitability requires pricing that customers won't pay, walk away.

If the wedge is big enough to sustain a healthy business given your cost structure and customer acquisition strategy, move forward.

Then focus on the actual execution of capturing your piece.

Many successful businesses operate in markets where the TAM looked unimpressive to outsiders.

They succeeded because they owned their specific wedge better than anyone else, not because they bet on a huge total addressable market.
View quoted post on X
8 replies 10 reposts 97 likes 14K views View on X
Paul Nary Verified account @ProfPaulNary
Skydance elaborated some more specific sources and mechanisms behind its projected $6B in cost synergies, although there is still some ambiguity.

Yet cost synergies are common and more achievable (vs. revenue synergies) for a reason.

Getting all of the projected $6B may be entirely possible. The hard part will be doing so without breaking the business/destroying its value.
Brian Stelter Verified account @brianstelter Nov 9
Skydance (CNN's parent) has put out info about where the promised $6 billion in synergies will come from:

"By combining two global streaming services, two film and TV studio groups, two television portfolios, and overlapping corporate functions, we can reduce duplicative spend across an expense base of more than $50 billion. We have identified multi-billion dollar opportunities in key areas, including non-labor and labor spend..."
View quoted post on X
0 replies 1 reposts 11 likes 2.9K views View on X
Paul Nary Verified account @ProfPaulNary
It may be tempting to dismiss competitive advantage as ambiguous fluff

Yet some firms are able to develop sources of competitive advantage that last, as @RogerLMartin alludes

My friend Prof. Wibbens has a research paper that measures its sourches and persistence in 4000 firms:
Roger L. Martin Verified account @RogerLMartin Nov 9
If you look at the most valuable companies in the world, as I did in this piece (4 yrs old now), you will note that competitive advantages are immensely long and not showing any signs of shortening.
rogerlmartin.substack.com/p/2022-02-21_w…
View quoted post on X
1 replies 2 reposts 9 likes 2.4K views View on X
Paul Nary Verified account @ProfPaulNary
The rush to do big deals may create both opportunities and traps for dealmakers

And although CEOs spent two years learning to navigate the White House, now they need a Congress strategy too

I spoke w/ @Bloomberg's @rngould and wanted to share a few thoughts that did not fully make it into the article:

1) There is a case for selective acceleration for some, but not all firms and deals. Moreover, there are already multiple other factors in place that increase uncertainty in the current M&A landscape, and already serve as constraints or opportunities of their own: interest rates, energy prices, tariffs, Middle East, etc.

2) For better or worse, politicization of M&A is here to stay as both sides now see it as a high-priority battleground.

3) It is still unclear how successful the window strategy will be overall, and I expect a lot of heterogeneity here.

For most firms, the real window is likely shorter than it looks given the need for time to negotiate and close deals as well having enough of a margin of safety, and most deals can now expect a higher level of scrutiny.

But what will that mean in practice? Democrats do not control the regulators, but they have plenty of other tools at their disposal to challenge and stall deals: scrutiny, subpoenas, hearings, etc. And, with states and other parties taking on a more active role.. firms should expect a tougher fight, especially those with political significance or ties to the current administration.

4) Additionally, the deals that are most likely to benefit from using the window may also be the ones that are the most likely to be scrutinized, politicized, slowed down, and potentially challenged later, as the Democrats made it clear that they are willing to look back and challenge deals even if CLEAN Mergers Act may be dead on arrival (although deals in some industries like banking or railroads may be insulated from ex-post challenges).

5) The "now or never" thinking and the rush to get through the window may push some firms into making bad decisions: doing deals that may not make sense, overpaying, etc. We may also expect more complex dynamics emerging. For example, we may see more activists pushing firms to sell now, while there is still a window.

Are any advisors, investors, dealmakers already seeing strong evidence of this rush?
Ryan Gould @rngould Nov 8
Sunday AM read on the state of play for M&A post-midterms with a crazy stat: More than half of all deals worth at least $50 billion and involving a US company over the past two decades have come under Trump.

It’s going to get… interesting. @business

bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
View quoted post on X
1 replies 1 reposts 5 likes 1.4K views View on X
Paul Nary Verified account @ProfPaulNary
Worth mentioning that Trian had been in and out of Wendy's dealings for almost 20 years..

And, the Triarc acquisition of $WEN was valued at ~$2.3B in 2008, which would be over $3.5B today.
Paul Nary Verified account @ProfPaulNary Nov 5
Not surprised that Wendy's rejected Trian's $1.4B offer

It does not mean that $WEN is not for sale, although judging by the newly adoped poison pill, if it negotiates, it wants it to be on its own terms

Trian may very well be right that Wendy's needs a different strategy, and that it would benefit from going private. But the two related factors working against the bid are:

1) Valuation - given $WEN price action over the last year, $7.35 is just a tough sell for the board and the shareholders

2) Wendy's has a new CEO and it only started on its new turnaround strategy a couple of months ago, so it's entirely too early to judge whether it delivers a performance improvement

At the end of the day, everything is negotiable, but this is a logical and predictable response by Wendy's to the current bid.

But hey, if you are a Wendy's shareholder and thought $7.35 was a fine price, let me know. Interestingly, today's price action also suggests the market is either expecting a higher bid, or is convinced that management can create value in its turnaround strategy.
View quoted post on X