Twitxy Saved

Steve McCormick

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@Quasilocal

Mathematician (Math.DG / gr-qc).

+3 Fire damage.
Luleå, Sverige quasilocal.com Joined February 2013
365 Following 9.3K Followers 45K Posts

Latest posts 5

Steve McCormick Verified account @Quasilocal
Junior people reading this, please disregard this terrible advice.

No AI statement right now is a bad sign -- it says to any reader "I am living under a rock" or "I don't want to be honest about how much AI I used"
Panos Ipeirotis Verified account @ipeirotis 14h
When gatekeepers demand AI disclosure and then treat it as a scarlet letter, rational actors simply omit the disclosure–especially junior people with the most to lose.

Punitive transparency mandates just select for secrecy.
View quoted post on X
6 replies 4 reposts 78 likes 4.2K views View on X
Steve McCormick Verified account @Quasilocal
This drives me mad -- I've had AI check things a bit now, and very often it will want to add a heap of details to stretch out something that the reader already understands, and then cling to that part as the main thing to focus on
Vansh Bhavsar @vanshdot 1d
Human reviewers pull 8.4% of their criticisms from a paper's appendix.
Frontier LLM reviewers: 62%.

A new study had GPT-6 and Claude 5.5 models review ICLR 2027 submissions, then mapped each weakness to the section it came from. The AI critiques keep going past page 30 of the appendix.

They skew toward detail audits: more seeds, significance tests, confidence intervals. Rarely the core idea.

Same pattern via API, web chat or coding agent, which points at the models, not the interface.

arxiv.org/abs/2611.17811

#PeerReview #LLMs #AcademicTwitter
View quoted post on X
4 replies 3 reposts 75 likes 7.9K views View on X
Steve McCormick Verified account @Quasilocal
Just noticed a rather prominant mathematician who posted to arXiv, 0 papers in 2023, 1 in 2024, 1 in 2025, and 8 in 2026 (so far).

I only managed to find one acknowledgement mentioning a little downplayed help from ChatGPT "mainly for exposition"
24 replies 5 reposts 198 likes 24K views View on X
Steve McCormick Verified account @Quasilocal
Mostly interested in mathematicians answers on this one. Where should the AI Disclosure statement go?
  • Front page 59
  • With the acknowledgements 154
  • Nowhere (don't write one) 48
  • ? Show answers 65

Final results