Consciousness and Artificial Intelligence
It is a mistake to assume that cows, bats, or other animals might possess consciousness simply because we lack the means to determine whether they do. We have no universally accepted definition of consciousness, and our only direct experience of it is our own. Consciousness, as we know it, is inseparable from what it means to be human. No other species shares that experience with us. Thus, judged against the only consciousness we know firsthand, we have no grounds for attributing it to other beings.
It is a mistake to assume that cows, bats, or other animals might possess consciousness simply because we lack the means to determine whether they do. We have no universally accepted definition of consciousness, and our only direct experience of it is our own. Consciousness, as we know it, is inseparable from what it means to be human. No other species shares that experience with us. Thus, judged against the only consciousness we know firsthand, we have no grounds for attributing it to other beings.