Senator Hawley asks why stopping forced arbitration is so vital, which Professor Gilles states it produces a public record that can demand accountability where arbitration prevents that. It also allows for the court to determine what is fair
Hawley: "Could you just underscore again why it's so important that these cases happen in public, that they go into a real courtroom? That's where there's a jury right that that jury right is accessible. Tell us again why this is so vital."
Prof. Gilles: "I the short answer, Senator, is um that courts produce a public record and arbitration is designed to do the exact opposite, right? It's designed, as you said, to muzzle to to make everything as secret as possible. And public accountability produces reform, right?
We've seen it time and time with with Roblox with also, you know, other companies that have been held responsible under the [Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act], for example.
We see reform whenever companies are sort of forced to justify defend themselves in court. Um, so I think the answer is really simple here and given that we're talking about children, it feels like this is an even easier case uh than the EFAA was a few years ago."
Hawley: "Let me ask you this. I think we have a poster of this effect. the cap on on all damages. I mentioned this in my opening statement and that terms and conditions that Mr. Schlep held up.
One of the terms and conditions is this. It's a limitation of liability and it says when you click that little box, you agree to that forced arbitration, no matter what your age is. And you also agree that any suit, any claim, any damages against Roblox or its affiliated parties for all claims will be limited to $1,000 total.
Can I just ask you, Professor Gilles, do you think that Roblox, let's say they actually do lose an arbitration? We'd never know, but let's say that they wonder Wonders actually lose an arbitration and have to pay a thousand bucks.
They are currently worth 33 billion. The founder and CEO alone is worth 3.3 billion. Is a thousand bucks going to change anybody's behavior in your professional opinion?"
Prof. Gilles: "Absolutely not. And quite frankly, this provision as well as that one-year statute of limitations would not be enforceable in court. Right? So, they know this.
They know that arbitrators are bound to uh to uh to to follow the terms of the arbitration agreement as drafted, but as you know well, no judge is going to listen to thousand dollars in a contract. We don't get to write contracts in this country that simply tell a court what to do, right? And that's what they're trying to do here."
Hawley: "Could you just underscore again why it's so important that these cases happen in public, that they go into a real courtroom? That's where there's a jury right that that jury right is accessible. Tell us again why this is so vital."
Prof. Gilles: "I the short answer, Senator, is um that courts produce a public record and arbitration is designed to do the exact opposite, right? It's designed, as you said, to muzzle to to make everything as secret as possible. And public accountability produces reform, right?
We've seen it time and time with with Roblox with also, you know, other companies that have been held responsible under the [Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act], for example.
We see reform whenever companies are sort of forced to justify defend themselves in court. Um, so I think the answer is really simple here and given that we're talking about children, it feels like this is an even easier case uh than the EFAA was a few years ago."
Hawley: "Let me ask you this. I think we have a poster of this effect. the cap on on all damages. I mentioned this in my opening statement and that terms and conditions that Mr. Schlep held up.
One of the terms and conditions is this. It's a limitation of liability and it says when you click that little box, you agree to that forced arbitration, no matter what your age is. And you also agree that any suit, any claim, any damages against Roblox or its affiliated parties for all claims will be limited to $1,000 total.
Can I just ask you, Professor Gilles, do you think that Roblox, let's say they actually do lose an arbitration? We'd never know, but let's say that they wonder Wonders actually lose an arbitration and have to pay a thousand bucks.
They are currently worth 33 billion. The founder and CEO alone is worth 3.3 billion. Is a thousand bucks going to change anybody's behavior in your professional opinion?"
Prof. Gilles: "Absolutely not. And quite frankly, this provision as well as that one-year statute of limitations would not be enforceable in court. Right? So, they know this.
They know that arbitrators are bound to uh to uh to to follow the terms of the arbitration agreement as drafted, but as you know well, no judge is going to listen to thousand dollars in a contract. We don't get to write contracts in this country that simply tell a court what to do, right? And that's what they're trying to do here."
2:13