Twitxy Saved

RTC

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@Roblox_RTC

We are the RTC, the largest source for Roblox news on X. Follow us to stay informed! Have any information or questions? Send us a DM!
contact@robloxrtc.com robloxrtc.com Joined October 2018
451 Following 1.4M Followers 30K Posts

Latest posts 5

RTC Verified account @Roblox_RTC
Senator Hawley asks why stopping forced arbitration is so vital, which Professor Gilles states it produces a public record that can demand accountability where arbitration prevents that. It also allows for the court to determine what is fair

Hawley: "Could you just underscore again why it's so important that these cases happen in public, that they go into a real courtroom? That's where there's a jury right that that jury right is accessible. Tell us again why this is so vital."

Prof. Gilles: "I the short answer, Senator, is um that courts produce a public record and arbitration is designed to do the exact opposite, right? It's designed, as you said, to muzzle to to make everything as secret as possible. And public accountability produces reform, right?

We've seen it time and time with with Roblox with also, you know, other companies that have been held responsible under the [Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act], for example.

We see reform whenever companies are sort of forced to justify defend themselves in court. Um, so I think the answer is really simple here and given that we're talking about children, it feels like this is an even easier case uh than the EFAA was a few years ago."

Hawley: "Let me ask you this. I think we have a poster of this effect. the cap on on all damages. I mentioned this in my opening statement and that terms and conditions that Mr. Schlep held up.

One of the terms and conditions is this. It's a limitation of liability and it says when you click that little box, you agree to that forced arbitration, no matter what your age is. And you also agree that any suit, any claim, any damages against Roblox or its affiliated parties for all claims will be limited to $1,000 total.

Can I just ask you, Professor Gilles, do you think that Roblox, let's say they actually do lose an arbitration? We'd never know, but let's say that they wonder Wonders actually lose an arbitration and have to pay a thousand bucks.

They are currently worth 33 billion. The founder and CEO alone is worth 3.3 billion. Is a thousand bucks going to change anybody's behavior in your professional opinion?"

Prof. Gilles: "Absolutely not. And quite frankly, this provision as well as that one-year statute of limitations would not be enforceable in court. Right? So, they know this.

They know that arbitrators are bound to uh to uh to to follow the terms of the arbitration agreement as drafted, but as you know well, no judge is going to listen to thousand dollars in a contract. We don't get to write contracts in this country that simply tell a court what to do, right? And that's what they're trying to do here."
2:13
8 replies 15 reposts 181 likes 28K views View on X
RTC Verified account @Roblox_RTC
Senator Hawley asks why Khari James believes Roblox's designs results in predation, which she points to refusing to do continuous age checks and the developer chat feature. And that they knowingly and intentionally chose to make money, not protect children.

Hawley: "You said earlier that what we're seeing with the predation online is a direct result of Roblox's design. Could you just elaborate on that? I think this is an important point. I think parents need to know this and I think it's important to pierce through the lies that Roblox is telling. They say, 'Well, we're just a neutral platform. We're just we're bystanders and bad people happen onto our platform, you know. Oops. not our fault.' You're saying no, actually it's written into their design. Tell us about that."

Khari James: "That's right. So, Roblox knows that that predators are using its platform. In fact, they talk about it in their SEC report just from last quarter. They know that this is happening and they can do something about it.

They can do continuous age checks. They won't. They can close the developer chat loophole. They won't. And the reason that they won't, and they openly say this in their annual report, they just think nobody's reading it because it's in fine print except for me. They need the developers to make money. And the developers can be children, but most of them are adults. They also say that they need children knowing that they're under 13 predominantly because without children, they don't make money.

The problem is if developers are able to create experiences within the game that are not subject to the safety settings and Roblox knows that children are going to use that, then how can they say that they care about children? That's how we know that they have intentionally made a choice to design their platform to make money, not to protect children."

Hawley: "And shouldn't they be liable for those choices if they've made them intentionally and knowingly?"

James: "Absolutely."
1:40
2 replies 11 reposts 131 likes 20K views View on X
RTC Verified account @Roblox_RTC
Senator Britt asks all testifying what is one thing that could enhance children's safety in general.

Schlep praises Roblox as a concept, but calls out their AI and outsourced moderation, stating that it is not working as intended. Professor Giles states removing forced arbitration will make companies behavior change once its out in public court. Kharl James agrees, and calls for any of the proposed bills, from: KOSA, Stop CSAM, or the Stop Forced Arbitration Act to be passed to give consequence, otherwise nothing would happen. Woody Doe asks for any of these bills to pass.

Britt: "What's the one kind of thing that you feel like this body needs to know as we're looking at what we do towards the end of the year?"

Prof. Gilles: "There are somewonderful bills. You [Britt] and Senator Blumenthal have a bill. Senators Hawley and Durbin have a bill. Pass one of these bills and just get rid of forced arbitration. You will be amazed by how quickly the company will change its behavior once it is sued in public court."

Khari James: "I agree with my colleague here that there needs to be a consequence and the consequence is being held liable. That's right. And how we can make that happen is through passing legislation. Whether it's Stop SCAM, KOSA, the Forced Arbitration Act, something has to be done. That's also why they're not here, right? There's no consequence. Nothing's going to happen."

Woody Doe: "I completely agree. They're they're protecting themselves from their investors through this forced arbitration. and all their dirty laundry is hidden. The minute that goes out the window, they're really going to feel the repercussions of their actions. All I can ask is please get on those bills."

Schlep: "Yeah, I I fundamentally believe that Roblox needs better moderation and and they they really should improve like you were saying. You know, kids or parents are putting their kids on this because the concept itself is a beautiful concept.

And I think honestly Roblox if they're doing what they're promising can can be something great, but they're not doing that. And some of the stuff that they've released like age estimation and and all of this other stuff is clearly not working. And at the end of the day, their over reliance on stuff like AI moderation when they should be doing stuff in-house here in the United States is something that I really think Roblox needs to do more of."

Britt: "Thank you for everyone for being here and um gentlemen, let's work together and get this done."
1:41
13 replies 17 reposts 261 likes 32K views View on X
RTC Verified account @Roblox_RTC
Senator Britt quotes Schlep, and he follows up stating Roblox is beautiful concept, but the current leadership is putting profits above safety, which he references a decreased moderation budget and statements from Roblox employees.

Britt: "You said, Mr. Schlep, knowingly, you said 'Roblox knows exactly what they're doing', we just heard [from Prof. Gilles] 'delivering predators to children'."

Schlep: "Yes. In fact Roblox bragged to investors in a shareholder announcement that they were decreasing their spending on moderation while their player base was exploding. What context does that even make sense for Roblox to decrease their moderation while their users are going up?

Hindenburg found that Roblox has one of the lowest moderator to user ratios than any other social media website. Not to mention Roblox is outsourcing their moderators to Southeast Asia where where they don't even understand grooming vernacular. And some of these employees who've been interviewed have said that they would never let their children on Roblox. Don't get me wrong, Roblox as a concept is is fundamentally a beautiful idea. It is something that I think could work. I think it is something that that is truly could be beneficial.

There there's stuff like programming, all this other stuff, but the current leadership at the company has truly shown that they are putting profits ahead of safety. And that's not me giving my opinion, that is their own employees saying that."

Britt: "Well, I think you said it in that big pack. There's one one paragraph on child safety and the rest of it is about protecting themselves."

Schlep: "Yeah. So, here actually is the community standards for Roblox. So, this is like what you can and can't do on the platform. Very thin. You see that? And then this is their terms of use legal contract, which you agree to by hitting I agree. And they're saying 8-year-olds are binded to this. 8-year-olds that have committed suicide."

Britt: "So, we we heard Senator Hawley earlier, Chairman Hawley say, parents, if you're watching this, this is this is what you need to know. I think to your point, the concept is something that parents believe is going to be good for their child to learn and to grow and to build and have no idea that the platform has is allowing this to occur and knowingly turning a blind eye to it."
2:19
6 replies 28 reposts 448 likes 33K views View on X
RTC Verified account @Roblox_RTC
Schlep mentions the length of the Terms of Use, which has more than 11,000 words and “16 pages” dedicated to arbitration, but only “a single paragraph in this about child safety.”

Schlep: "Senator, if I may, I just wanted to showcase this. This here is the Roblox terms of use. You can see how thick this is. Um, I mean, it's something like, you know, pretty pretty huge. And Roblox has a single paragraph in this about child safety.

Meanwhile, they have, I believe, 16 pages related to arbitration uh within it. Roblox itself very much they are doing everything in their power to make sure that these victims don't get access to justice."

Blumenthal: "And no, no teenagers going to read through 16 pages."

Schlep: "Not even teenagers. They're saying eight-year-olds. Roblox is legally in court saying 8-year-olds read this, read this entire piece of paper right here. That's ridiculous."

Blumenthal: "And when there is forced arbitration for that 8-year-old or 13-year-old or anyone else, there are virtually no rights of real appeal. Correct?"

Schlep: "Yeah."
0:59