Twitxy Saved

Rock Chartrand

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@RockChartrand

I spend most of my time on X trying to save authoritarians from themselves.
Canada rockchartrand.substack.com Joined November 2018
1.6K Following 20K Followers 75K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Rock Chartrand Verified account @RockChartrand
Capitalism is perhaps the most misunderstood economic system in history, largely because it is routinely blamed for the consequences of violating its own principles.

Capitalism means private property, individual rights, voluntary trade, and a government limited to protecting those rights. It is a system in which individuals are free to produce, compete, trade, and prosper without requiring political permission or favoritism.

Cronyism, by contrast, means government granting economic privileges through subsidies, bailouts, tariffs, regulations designed to protect favored businesses, and other forms of political favoritism.

Socialism, communism, fascism, theocracy, absolute monarchy, feudalism, mercantilism, corporatism, and cronyism differ in their doctrines, methods, and objectives. Yet all have permitted political authority or privileged groups to override individual economic freedom.

The fundamental distinction is between voluntary exchange and political coercion.

Under capitalism, economic success depends on creating value that others voluntarily choose to purchase. Under cronyism, political influence can substitute for earning that success through trade.

This brings us to the mixed economy, where elements of capitalism coexist with government intervention, redistribution, regulation, and political favoritism.

When intervention produces unintended consequences, critics routinely attribute those failures to capitalism simply because they occurred in an economy containing private businesses and markets.

That is a fundamental error of causation.

The existence of private businesses does not make every government policy capitalist. Nor does the existence of wealthy businessmen make political favoritism a product of free markets.

A businessman who earns a fortune through voluntary trade and one who obtains privileges through political coercion are operating on fundamentally different principles.

Pure laissez-faire capitalism has never been fully implemented. Yet to the extent economic freedom has existed, it has demonstrated its extraordinary capacity to create wealth, increase productivity, encourage innovation, and raise living standards.

And here lies the great irony.

The remaining economic freedom continues to generate much of the wealth that makes government intervention and redistribution possible, while helping cushion society against their destructive consequences.

Critics then demand further intervention to remedy problems caused or aggravated by previous interventions, perpetuating a cycle in which political power expands while capitalism receives the blame.

Before blaming capitalism for any economic problem, establish whether that problem arose from voluntary exchange or the coercive exercise of political power.

You cannot reasonably condemn a system for the consequences of violating its principles while ignoring the benefits produced when those principles are respected.
179 replies 1K reposts 3.5K likes 128K views View on X
Rock Chartrand Verified account @RockChartrand
Socialist logic outside taxation:

“I paid $5,000 for this Mercedes. I’m being ripped off. Someone owes me.”

“The car costs $30,000. You only paid $5,000 because someone else was forced to pay $150,000 for theirs to cover yours.”

“Yes, but they can afford it. Why wasn’t mine free?”
1 replies 2 reposts 35 likes 789 views View on X
Rock Chartrand Verified account @RockChartrand
Socialism: the ideology that turns someone else’s refusal to live for your demands into a grievance.

Keeping what you earned is “greed.” Demanding what someone else earned is “justice and compassion.”

Apparently greed becomes a virtue the moment you want someone else’s money instead of to just be able to keep the money you earned.
craigwhytefanclub Verified account @craigwhitefanc1 1d
View quoted post on X
1 replies 11 reposts 26 likes 561 views View on X
Rock Chartrand Verified account @RockChartrand
When equality of outcome becomes the standard of justice, success becomes evidence of exploitation and failure becomes proof of victimhood, regardless of how either outcome was earned.

The poor wife beating drunk becomes someone society owes, while the man who gets rich through trade by improving people’s lives becomes the villain expected to pay.

What could possibly go wrong with an incentive structure that treats achievement as a debt and failure as a claim on it?
1 replies 6 reposts 17 likes 426 views View on X
Rock Chartrand Verified account @RockChartrand
“We must abolish class,” say the people who assign everyone a class, designate one as the enemy to be robbed, promise another the proceeds, and empower a political class to seize and distribute everything.

Conveniently, the people administering this “classless society” get to decide what everyone else deserves, including themselves.

Apparently class hierarchy becomes moral once you’re on top of it.
Fred Verified account @uncleFredsTweet 4h
View quoted post on X