Twitxy Saved

Samuel Loncar | Accelerating Scientific Progress

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@SamuelLoncar

Yale PhD | Philosopher of religion and science | Editor, Marginalia Review | Meanings of Science Institute Director | AI Epistemology | Book w Columbia UP |
Spacetime samuelloncar.com Joined December 2015
873 Following 1.6K Followers 5.5K Posts

Latest posts 5

Samuel Loncar | Accelerating Scientific Progress Verified account @SamuelLoncar
What a beautiful and profound essay. Lyrical, flowing gently, and remarkably clear through its central metaphor. To me as an editor, and philosopher, this is the most helpful essay I’ve read on this crucial topic of math and AI. It gets to the heart of what mathematics is for, what it is becoming, and how its values are shifting. Implicit everywhere in the conversation is: what is the purpose of mathematics? The founders of the contemplative, or pure mathematical tradition, had very different views on this than modern math and science.

Plato, who carried on the Pythagorean tradition in many ways, never defended mathematics for its utility for understanding the natural world, even through he was the first to develop the idea of mathematical physics as the right way to model the visible world. The engineering accomplishments of Archytas of Tarentum speak to how useful the Pythagorean approach to mathematics was, but the value of studying number and ratio was intrinsic and, this is utterly central, spiritual in their tradition.

Although I am not a mathematician, my entrance to the sciences has been a search for the origin, nature, and meaning of the modern scientific tradition, which includes the university system itself. That is a brilliant system that originally combined a competitive reward system with the ancient idea, whose story is the topic of my forthcoming book, that searching for knowledge was a spiritual practice whose reward was intrinsic to the activity itself, and whose purpose was communion with reality and the establishment of a justly ordered self.

This was a unique way of life, codified in Plato, centered on truth, knowledge-acquisition, and the love of harmony, and it led to Euclid, Newton, and Einstein. It is not an accident that Einstein begins his accessible introduction to Relativity with Euclid, and Euclid represents the primary cognitive practice taught by Socrates: the exact definition of form. This is the origin, I show in my work, of science as we know it today.

Where only competition remains, and the last remnants of this founding philosophical vision are relegated to the margins, AI is a true destroyer. The grief witnessed in Szegedy’s essay and many others’ is poignant, but he also has great hope. Why? Because, deep down, I think the mathematical community has preserved more of the ancient tradition of science as a philosophical way of life than any other academic field. Though I don’t specialize in number, I also study form, the form of knowledge itself being my central topic, and I see here the emergence of a new spiritual, meaning holistic, evolution in math, which the other sciences would be wise to heed. Grieve, yes, and then return to the root and ask: what was this originally about, this hunt for truth, for form? Why did humans start doing this? That’s the topic of my work, my book, and it’s awe-inspiring to watch such a revolution in real time, and read the beautiful witness of Szegedy to a return, I believe, to the original Platonic view of math.

As I’ve been teaching all of Plato’s works in the Plato Project, his emphasis on the search for knowledge as a soul-practice has become clearer than ever. We must recover this view, because it is the truth, it is the root of science, and it is only way we can determine what is essential in any area, including math. We are not all mathematicians now, but we are all philosophers, and as math goes, so science will follow, so we all have a stake in how math is understood. My admiration for this community is boundless.
Christian Szegedy Verified account @ChrSzegedy Oct 3
Reading all those recent beautiful essays by Terry Tao, Kevin Buzzard and @wtgowers, I could not resist, but write up my deeply personal perspective on how I perceive and see things:

docs.google.com/document/d/e/2…
View quoted post on X
Samuel Loncar | Accelerating Scientific Progress Verified account @SamuelLoncar
Congratulations!
Dr Francis Young Verified account @DrFrancisYoung Sep 17
It’s incredible to have ‘Silence of the Gods’ shortlisted for The @WolfsonHistory Prize, and I’m so pleased that the largely forgotten history of northern and eastern Europe’s last pre-Christian religious traditions is finally receiving the attention it deserves 📚
View quoted post on X
Samuel Loncar | Accelerating Scientific Progress Verified account @SamuelLoncar
This explains a lot about the book, which I finally read last year. It was an awesome beginning, full of wonder and hope, and a dismaying final arc, leaving me genuinely upset at Hugo for such a terrible ending. His skills as a writer are without doubt astonishing.
Drew Verified account @drewdyck Aug 26
Procrastinating on that writing project? Here’s a hack from Victor Hugo.
View quoted post on X