Pinned post
Sarah A. Hoyt
Verified account This account is verified. Learn more@SarahAHoyt
Professional mystery, fantasy and science fiction writer
Books: amazon.com/stores/Sarah-A…
Blog: accordingtohoyt.com
Books: amazon.com/stores/Sarah-A…
Blog: accordingtohoyt.com
414 Following 7.8K Followers 25K Posts
Latest posts 5
No indeed. Because I'm neither an establishment writer nor someone dead 100 years. Your point is?
And excuse me, sir, I CAN promote empathy in a three line poem. What I'd like you to prove is that "promote empathy" is now the point of a short story. I think you need to read far more extensively.
And excuse me, sir, I CAN promote empathy in a three line poem. What I'd like you to prove is that "promote empathy" is now the point of a short story. I think you need to read far more extensively.
@DaddyWarpig @SarahAHoyt Many great authors would disagree. If you can't find a way to write a compelling story and characters that promote empathy in a 5k word story, you won't be able to accomplish that in 400k words. No disrespect to Sarah, but she is not a literary great.View quoted post on X
I think she means "WITHOUT" or her post makes no sense.
And whatever. I only have 41 years of seeing various newbies make it to pro, so your opinion is your opinion. Mine might be SLIGHTLY better grounded in experience.
My observation is that some people are naturally long form, some naturally short form. These are DIFFERENT ART FORMS. Becoming excellent at one means diddly squat for the other.
Just because both use words, doesn't mean they're the same thing.
Being an excellent portrait painter doesn't mean you excel at landscapes and no one would expect it to be so. No one would tell you to practice portraits before landscapes because landscapes are "bigger."
BUT people get holes in the head when the means of doing art is words. Because everyone uses words all the time, so of course, they're not a means to art. Of course.
So, whatever.
Also, if anyone can find my eyes before the cats get to them? They rolled somewhere under the couch.
And whatever. I only have 41 years of seeing various newbies make it to pro, so your opinion is your opinion. Mine might be SLIGHTLY better grounded in experience.
My observation is that some people are naturally long form, some naturally short form. These are DIFFERENT ART FORMS. Becoming excellent at one means diddly squat for the other.
Just because both use words, doesn't mean they're the same thing.
Being an excellent portrait painter doesn't mean you excel at landscapes and no one would expect it to be so. No one would tell you to practice portraits before landscapes because landscapes are "bigger."
BUT people get holes in the head when the means of doing art is words. Because everyone uses words all the time, so of course, they're not a means to art. Of course.
So, whatever.
Also, if anyone can find my eyes before the cats get to them? They rolled somewhere under the couch.
@DaddyWarpig @SarahAHoyt Eh, disagree. People who aren't runners shouldn't do a triathalon with running on the treadmill firstView quoted post on X
@elonmusk needs to see this and add it to Starship mood music rotation.View quoted post on X
Ma! Minimalists are being weird on X again!
Note what he considers pluses: "clear concise characterization and scene setting."
This is WONDERFUL if you aspire to write like Hemingway. It's a style. It's NOT the style, no matter what your college professors told you.
You know what? You want to write screen plays, write screen plays. I'm not your mother.
HOWEVER don't expect them to make you a great novelist. They're their own thing.
Note what he considers pluses: "clear concise characterization and scene setting."
This is WONDERFUL if you aspire to write like Hemingway. It's a style. It's NOT the style, no matter what your college professors told you.
You know what? You want to write screen plays, write screen plays. I'm not your mother.
HOWEVER don't expect them to make you a great novelist. They're their own thing.
I disagree. Screenwriting, while heavily visual and dialogue slanted still requires clear, concise characterization and scene setting that informs the actors/directors. It also forces an organization of scenes and exposes logic problems and story gaps. Once you've done through the exercise and learned the lessons, you don't need to write a screenplay before every book.View quoted post on X