Twitxy Saved

David Bergman

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@TheDavidBergman

Writing on politics, elections, corruption, human rights etc .. with particular interest in Bangladesh. Most recently Netra News, Al Jazeera, Channel 4 News
London, England bangladesh2024justicewatch.org Joined March 2009
881 Following 83K Followers 9.5K Posts

Latest posts 5

David Bergman Verified account @TheDavidBergman
One of the more progressive changes to #Bangladesh’s International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973 is section 11 (8). The interim government introduced it in 2024, and the new BNP-led parliament kept it in 2026. It allows foreign lawyers to appear before the tribunal for the defence or the prosecution. It states:

“Notwithstanding anything contained in the Bangladesh Legal Practitioners and Bar Council Order, 1972 (President’s Order No. 46 of 1972), a Tribunal may allow foreign counsel to appear before it, subject to the prior permission of Bangladesh Bar Council, which should not be unreasonably withheld.”

The provision was written to fix a known problem. In 2011, British lawyers instructed by Jamaat-e-Islami defendants sought permission to appear before the tribunal. The Bangladesh Bar Council refused, saying the 1972 Order gave it no power to grant permission. Section 11(8) overrides the Order and limits the Bar Council’s discretion.

So far it has made no difference. In recent months, several foreign lawyers have applied to the Bangladesh Bar Council for permission to appear. News reports at the end of last month said permission had been refused in at least some cases. More than two weeks later, none of the lawyers who have applied have received any written response and no reasons have been given.

That matters because the law requires that permission “should not be unreasonably withheld.” A refusal with no reasons cannot be tested against that standard. It is also hard to see what reasonable grounds there could be for stopping these lawyers from representing defendants in some of the most serious cases tried in Bangladesh.

Who is making the decision also matters. The Bar Council is not elected. It is currently run by a 15-member ad hoc council appointed by the BNP government in June 2026. The overwhelming majority are pro-BNP lawyers, with just a few aligned with either Jamaat-e-Islami or the NCP. It is chaired by the Attorney General, a senior BNP leader. The question here is whether former Awami League leaders, on trial for crimes against humanity, can be represented by the lawyers of their choice. On a matter that politically sensitive, it is hard to see the council’s decision as independent of the government.

If the Bar Council can still block foreign counsel without explanation, section 11 changes nothing from 2011.
4 replies 3 reposts 14 likes 1.7K views View on X
David Bergman Verified account @TheDavidBergman
The Bangladesh government’s current approach, demanding Sheikh Hasina’s extradition from India while refusing to let her return voluntarily, recalls the Awami League government’s handling of Chowdhury Mueen-Uddin, the UK-based Jamaat-e-Islami leader. In 2013 the International Crimes Tribunal convicted him in absentia of crimes against humanity committed 40 years earlier during the 1971 war of independence, in the same kind of trial Hasina has now faced. Mueen-Uddin has always denied involvement in the crimes, and the UK's Supreme Court, in relation to a defamation claim strongly criticised the fairness of the proceedings.

The Awami League government repeatedly and very publicly demanded that the UK extradite him, but it never made a formal request under the UK’s Extradition Act 2003. It almost certainly knew it would lose in the British courts, on grounds of due process and the death penalty. The public demand, though, served its political purposes.

With Hasina, the government has gone further and made a formal extradition request. But it knows India is unlikely ever to agree, or at least not without legal conditions that Dhaka would struggle to accept. The government can therefore keep demanding her extradition, safe in the knowledge that nothing will come of it.

Hasina’s offer to return and, in effect, surrender herself to the authorities upsets this. For understandable reasons, for reasons I have written elsewhere, the government does not really want her back in Bangladesh.

So the government now insists she can come back only through extradition, a route it knows is closed
15 replies 15 reposts 76 likes 11K views View on X
David Bergman Verified account @TheDavidBergman
There is, I think, no precedent for a government telling one of its own citizens — convicted in absentia and the subject of its own extradition request — that she may not come home voluntarily to submit to its courts, but must instead be extradited. This however is the #Bangladesh government's position, desperate it seems to avoid Sheikh Hasina's return to the country. Read why here.thedailystar.net/opinion/views/…
www.thedailystar.net Why Dhaka doesn’t want Hasina back Seen from Sheikh Hasina’s perspective, deciding to try and return to Bangladesh is clever politics.
14 replies 8 reposts 32 likes 3.9K views View on X
David Bergman Verified account @TheDavidBergman
As has been suggested, those responsible were probably pro-Awami League activists. The party will not regain ground in Bangladesh through further criminality. Such acts will only strengthen those in government and opposition who want a purely retributive response to the Awami League’s years in power.
Naomi Hossain @nomhossain 4d
Terrible. Party thugs of the ousted Awami League regime are targeting NCP, the party that some of the student movement set up after the 2024 monsoon uprising. Sheikh Hasina may have fled to India in shame, and been convicted of grave crimes. But still she stirs the pot.
View quoted post on X