Pinned post
Pennecilin, the foundation of all antibacterial medicine, was discovered because a human being forgot to clean out his petri dish before going on vacation for two weeks. He came back to find mold and bacteria both growing in the same dish.
Instead of ignoring it and cleaning the dish, Alexander Fleming, took a closer look. When he put the petri dish under a microscope he noticed that at the divide between the bacteria and the mold (penicillin) the bacteria were being killed.
Penicillin was discovered and countless lives saved by a human being doing things that would be considered stupid or a waste of time now.
Why was he wasting his time examining the mold in a petri dish he forgot about for two weeks?? That wasn't part of whatever experiment he was working on at the time! He would have been written up for doing that nowadays!
But the mistake led to some wasted time analyzing the mistake which led to the discovery of penicillin and the entire study of antibacterial medicine.
Go ahead. Use your AI. Blindly trust the computations. I'm good though. I'll be over here examining metaphorical petri dishes.
Instead of ignoring it and cleaning the dish, Alexander Fleming, took a closer look. When he put the petri dish under a microscope he noticed that at the divide between the bacteria and the mold (penicillin) the bacteria were being killed.
Penicillin was discovered and countless lives saved by a human being doing things that would be considered stupid or a waste of time now.
Why was he wasting his time examining the mold in a petri dish he forgot about for two weeks?? That wasn't part of whatever experiment he was working on at the time! He would have been written up for doing that nowadays!
But the mistake led to some wasted time analyzing the mistake which led to the discovery of penicillin and the entire study of antibacterial medicine.
Go ahead. Use your AI. Blindly trust the computations. I'm good though. I'll be over here examining metaphorical petri dishes.
I find it frustrating that AI people fundamentally don't understand how science works.View quoted post on X
Science has never been roadblocked by computation.
Let me give you a concrete example. Nucleic acids (DNA, RNA) were first discovered by the Swiss physician-chemist Friedrich Miescher in 1869. He made an extract from white blood cell nuclei. The extraction technique was one that typically extracted proteins from a cell. But in this case, Miescher noticed that his extracts contained no sulfur. (Proteins contain sulfur.) Also, strangely, the extracts contained phosphorus (something NOT found in proteins). He called his extracts "nuclein" (to distinguish them from "protein").
Miescher measured the pH of his extracts. They were acidic. We now call the macromolecules his discovered "nucleic acids."
There is no way computation would have predicted Miescher's discovery of nucleic acids nor would it have helped Miescher in any way.
For many years (1869 to 1944), proteins were thought to be the genetic material. No one believed nucleic acids were complex enough to encode phenotypes. Work by Avery and his colleagues (in 1944) showed that DNA, not proteins, must in fact be the genetic material. The Avery discovery did not hinge on computation in any way.
In 1950, Austrian biochemist Erwin Chargaff discovered that the amount of guanine in DNA equals the amount of cytosine, and also adenine equals the amount of thymine. This discovery did not hinge on computation and would not have been made easier by AI.
People who think AI will "solve biology" do not understand how scientific discovery works.
Thank you for asking the original question.