There’s not only Eros and Philia in his system/ account!
What of Aristotle’s use of στεργος 🤷
What of Aristotle’s use of στεργος 🤷
I am coming to think that the question of the UNIVOCITY OF LOVE, as proposed by Jean-Luc Marion in terms of a nonmetaphysical renewal of the Augustinian tradition (and self-consciously departing from the Scotist metaphysics of a univocity of being), forms the decisive horizon of intellectual controversy for contemporary theological reflection. It seems that the most formidable contemporary opponents to Marion’s doctrine can be counted as three: William Desmond, @johnmilbank3, and @pickstockc.View quoted post on X
Marion himself elects the 20th-century Lutheran theologian Anders Nygren as his greatest opponent, but it seems that in an important sense, Desmond has developed a metaphysical language (one he calls “metaxological”) for cashing out an ontological distinction in the respective voicing of Eros and Agape (the two most decisive candidates for indicating a plurivocity of love) that is consistent with Catholic hamartiology, while Nygren’s critique of Eros hinges on the Lutheran hamartiology of total depravity (Catholics instead affirm a constitutive created openness of Eros to grace). Milbank and Pickstock, meanwhile, offer bracing critiques of any attempt to submit the task of thought to univocity as such. But does a resolutely nonmetaphysical univocity fall to their critiques of its metaphysical variant?
Already in 1997’s “The Word Made Strange,” Milbank prophetically discerned an unspoken horizon of univocity at work in Marion’s controversial 1982 classic “God Without Being.” As if on cue, in 2003’s “The Erotic Phenomenon,” Marion comes forward to elect a supposition of the univocity of love as the horizon of his thinking, a univocity that he notably situates, however, as resolutely beyond being. In 2008’s “In the Self’s Place,” Marion works to ground this conception of a univocity of love in the doctrine of love on display in the texts of St. Augustine of Hippo, which he fastidiously distinguishes from all metaphysics, in a rigorously nonmetaphysical interpretation of the biblical horizon of creation as beyond being and so irreducible to any system of causes ontologically discernible in the nous.
Notably, however, in the same text, Marion explicitly admits an analogia proportionis, as it is called in the Thomist tradition, at work in the thought of St. Augustine between love and physis or nature, in his doctrine of “the weight of love.” This doctrine of the weight of love would seem at the very least to occupy the PLACE of a metaphysics, and precisely an analogical one at that, of the type advocated by Milbank and Pickstock against univocal metaphysics (drawn out importantly in their reading of St. Thomas Aquinas, and also in critiquing the apparently Scotist drift of scientistic metaphysics through early modernity to the present). It is here significant that the greatest 20th century advocates of a metaphysics of the analogia entis, the German language Catholic school of Erich Przywara, Hans Urs von Balthasar, and Ferdinand Ulrich, expressly situate the analogia entis as a metaphysics of the creation ex nihilo, a biblical doctrine that Marion instead interprets as finally nonmetaphysical. Is it not perhaps the case that analogy is at once the Christian horizon of metaphysics (from the standpoint of being) and beyond metaphysics (once we approach the analogy between love as supernatural and nature as bearing its weight beyond being)?
Much depends on how we interpret Aristotle’s doctrine of nature and so ultimately his physics as well as metaphysics, as all sides must inevitably concede, given the centrality of the Aristotelian reference for the Thomist metaphysics of analogy. It is here that we must ask: IN ARISTOTLE’S OWN TERMS, to what extent is supernatural love ultimately “para physin,” against nature? Is it a “force” that contradicts the pull of natural weight? St. Thomas famously demurred: grace perfects—does not destroy—nature. But what of fallen nature already destroying ITSELF in sin? Is hamartiology beyond metaphysics?