Pinned post
Suppose there’s a child whose father or mother is abusing them. The cessation of that abuse would be a good end — but this does entail that all means of obtaining that end are morally permissible.
One could, for example, kill the parents and walk away. The abuse will have ended, but apart from the immorality of murder itself, there would be an absence of due consideration for the child’s welfare. Thus, the act would be bad.
The house in which the child lives with their abusive parents could be burnt to the ground. Again, the abuse would cease, but the child would likely be killed along with the parents, or left homeless and destitute were they to survive. So, the act would be bad.
It could also be the case that one recognises the child is being abused, and ostensibly acts to bring the abuse to an end, but the actual motivation – the intention operative in acting – is to take revenge on the parents for some cause other than the abuse of the child. This, too, would render the act bad.
Moral realism requires that any action taken to prevent, mitigate, or terminate a particular evil, must be good in its intention, its aim, and the manner in which one’s objective is achieved. For this, the exercise of prudence is necessary, which involves more than what is merely convenient or emotionally gratifying. It means one must give due consideration to the ramifications that may reasonably be expected to arise from a particular course of action, and to refrain from acting in such way as to exacerbate an already bad situation.
To be incensed, however rightly, is not automatically to be justified in whatever one chooses to do. To say one simply does not care does not absolve them of the responsibility to care for what their actions may cause. To feel a certain way is not an excuse for not thinking, much less not thinking the right way.
Foolishness and fecklessness, hubris and bellicosity, are the fuel of evils — not that which extinguishes them.
One could, for example, kill the parents and walk away. The abuse will have ended, but apart from the immorality of murder itself, there would be an absence of due consideration for the child’s welfare. Thus, the act would be bad.
The house in which the child lives with their abusive parents could be burnt to the ground. Again, the abuse would cease, but the child would likely be killed along with the parents, or left homeless and destitute were they to survive. So, the act would be bad.
It could also be the case that one recognises the child is being abused, and ostensibly acts to bring the abuse to an end, but the actual motivation – the intention operative in acting – is to take revenge on the parents for some cause other than the abuse of the child. This, too, would render the act bad.
Moral realism requires that any action taken to prevent, mitigate, or terminate a particular evil, must be good in its intention, its aim, and the manner in which one’s objective is achieved. For this, the exercise of prudence is necessary, which involves more than what is merely convenient or emotionally gratifying. It means one must give due consideration to the ramifications that may reasonably be expected to arise from a particular course of action, and to refrain from acting in such way as to exacerbate an already bad situation.
To be incensed, however rightly, is not automatically to be justified in whatever one chooses to do. To say one simply does not care does not absolve them of the responsibility to care for what their actions may cause. To feel a certain way is not an excuse for not thinking, much less not thinking the right way.
Foolishness and fecklessness, hubris and bellicosity, are the fuel of evils — not that which extinguishes them.