Interesting take - great comments too!
One reason biology is not taken seriously by people trained in quantitative or physics-based science and engineering disciplines is that it often relies on loose or squishy metaphors and analogies to sell the importance of the work.View quoted post on X
The field substitutes loose metaphors, ambiguous biomarkers, and cartoons for quantitative precision, then wonders why people trained in quantitative or physics-based science and engineering disciplines regard it as a soft science.
Terms such as “metabolic demand” and “T cell exhaustion” are stated emphatically in titles and abstracts and presented as cartoons in slide decks, but they are never rigorously measured or even defined.
In economics and physics-based disciplines, where mass and momentum conservation are real principles, demand has a precise quantitative meaning: the total consumption, withdrawal, or output from a defined system or network. In biology papers, “metabolic demand” is usually meaningless.
“Cell exhaustion” has a related problem. It is inferred from biomarkers or loosely measured functional outputs, or phenotypes, that are either far removed from the actual process, may not be rigorously correlated with it, or can have multiple ambiguous interpretations and meanings.
This contributes directly to the reproducibility problem. Many biological claims are difficult to generalize because the central quantities and processes were never rigorously defined or measured in the first place.