Twitxy Saved

Adeel @ MagicSchool AI

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@adeelorama

Lifelong Teacher & Principal. Building @magicschoolai to fight teacher burnout and bring responsible AI to students.
Denver, CO magicschool.ai Joined May 2009
952 Following 2.6K Followers 2.9K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Adeel @ MagicSchool AI Verified account @adeelorama
Stop letting Google buy our children.
It's not hard to imagine what @google was thinking with it's latest decision to force Gemini onto children in schools.

That's because in leaked internal documents, they said the quite part out loud about their K-12 strategy.

In the documents, they imagine a future where:

“Parents ask their children, ‘Why aren’t you watching more YouTube?’”
“School administrators shift budgets from textbooks to YouTube subscriptions.”

I don't know a single school, teacher, or parent who wants this. But Google does.

It's no secret that Gemini is losing in market to to Claude and ChatGPT. But Google has something they don't: profitability and cash reserves. They can play the long game.

Their strategy probably looks something like: hook children in schools, they're native to Gemini when they're adults, slowly take market share from the other guys.

Let's not let them buy our children as their future customers.

It's time to get Google out of schools.
Adeel @ MagicSchool AI Verified account @adeelorama
With all the talk about @google's monopolistic, harmful Gemini decisions in K-12 yesterday, it's a good moment to remind ourselves that this has been Google's playbook all along.

Ever wonder why Google is so interested in getting Chromebooks into K-12 schools?
Getting kids using Google Classroom and Workspace?
Getting kids to use YouTube?

Maybe refer to their own leaked internal documents... or ask Gemini.

When I was teacher and principal, my school used Google Classroom. I never asked these questions. It was designed this way, the only option, infrastructure, a "good enough" product with few alternatives.

I never considered the cost to my students. I didn't consider that Google was using this essential piece of infrastructure to push (then nascent) Google Workspace on kids.

I didn't have the thought that maybe Google was making money of my students' eyes with their YouTube ads and perfect algorithm to make the next video one that kept them watching longer.

It's what a monopoly does, subtly convince you all of this is necessary and required, it's the only option, and slip into the background so you do not consider these things.

I only started considering them 3 years ago when I started leading @magicschoolai and understanding how tech companies work (and making my own decisions about how we would never engage in these practices with students).

We must all start to become conscious consumers of technology. We owe our children an education that gives them agency in the world, not has them succumb to the desires of big tech companies like Google. We need to teach this actively to educators, students, and families.

It's time to get Google out of schools.
4 replies 2 reposts 13 likes 1.3K views View on X
Adeel @ MagicSchool AI Verified account @adeelorama
Google announced that early next year, AI tools in its K-12 products will be off unless a district turns them on. That’s the right default.

But read the fine print. If a district keeps AI off entirely, students also lose Google Search.

So the real choice for schools is:

1. No Google Search
2. Google Search with Gemini

The option districts are actually asking for isn’t on the menu: Google Search with the AI turned off. Los Angeles Unified said exactly this in September. They wanted students to keep searching, just with AI Overviews off.

Google could offer that. It chose not to.

These decisions protect Google’s monopoly and its interest in using schools to onboard students as future customers. They don’t reflect what districts want.

As a former teacher and principal, I believe districts should decide how and when AI shows up for their students. Search is basic infrastructure for learning. It shouldn’t be used as leverage to put a chatbot in every classroom.

I lead @magicschoolai . We build AI for schools, and I want AI in education to succeed. But that only happens when it’s earned through trust, and trust means respecting the choices educators make, including the choice to say “not yet.”

Google, give districts the option they’re asking for: search without Gemini.
Adeel @ MagicSchool AI Verified account @adeelorama
Denver Public Schools spent a year figuring out AI the right way. They ran a real pilot, issued a formal RFP, and let teachers, students, and families shape the decision.

Today @magicschoolai is the only student-facing AI tool approved across the district. Extra special since Denver is home.

Huge thanks to Kali Peracchia, Ph.D. and the DPS team for holding a high bar and leading with care. And thank you to Common Sense Privacy for the rigorous, independent review behind our 95% privacy rating.

District leaders shouldn't have to take a vendor's word for anything, and we're grateful to have someone outside the company checking our work.

Proud of Fiona A. Wright-CIPM, CIPP/E, AIGP, Evan Lapka, and our whole team for earning this trust every day.
Adeel @ MagicSchool AI Verified account @adeelorama
I was honored to join Prince Edward, Duke of Edinburgh, for this conversation at the World Governments Summit in Dubai.

Teachers are the heart of the classroom, AI can help. @magicschoolai
How Will AI Transform Education?

@adeelorama, Founder & CEO of @magicschoolai, explores how AI can help teachers save time, personalize learning, and create better student experiences.

He also explains why human connection should remain at the heart of education.
Watch the full conversation. Link - youtu.be/V-ZT0ErF1AQ
View quoted post on X