Twitxy Saved

Amar Govindarajan

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@amargov

CEO - Swarajya. Coimbatore.
(Views Personal)
Coimbatore swarajyamag.com Joined January 2009
4.9K Following 32K Followers 33K Posts

Latest posts 5

Amar Govindarajan Verified account @amargov
Nobody is arguing support is wrong. Question is: can we review if these cos are serving India’s interests to the max or only partially?

Every rupee/protection is tax payer money. Bang for the buck is necessary.

In addition to market protection players in solar sector ALSO have have support in the form of customs exemption for machines import, a PLI for high end cells, guaranteed demand in form for DCR, state govt level subsidies on capital and possibly power/land concessions.

What can they show in terms of new product development?
The Finthusiast Verified account @thefinthusiast 11h
Your post totally missed the point that Govt has now made it mandatory to use Cell manufactured in India to be used in panels being sold for any Govt project. This is applicable for entire industry including top players. These profits are ultimately used to put the new plants. It is being done in Phased manner. Goal is to backward integrate to the last component. As far as R&D is concerned, it might be an accounting error. Some people capitalise it and some take it through P&L along with regular expenses. Handholding from Govt is very necessary to setup an industry which not only can cater to Indian demand but can export to other nations.
View quoted post on X
0 replies 2 reposts 17 likes 728 views View on X
Amar Govindarajan Verified account @amargov
This is good. We finally have a credible Indian alternative for open router.
Sarvam Verified account @SarvamAI 22h
Today, we are launching Sarvam Token Factory for everyone.

We host our own models, and the full range of best-in-class open-weight models, in India. We match leading inference providers on performance and reliability.

For enterprises, this means more models to choose from, and an AI stack they can own without lock-ins.
View quoted post on X
1 replies 18 reposts 138 likes 2.9K views View on X
Amar Govindarajan Verified account @amargov
When Indian solar cos use protection period to bank profits instead of ploughing it into product development

>China stops solar tech
>Indian cos claim they'll buy from EU
>EU cos know Indian cos have nowhere else to go
>EU cos charge Indian cos a hefty premium?
>Indian customer pays premium for import solar stack.
Krishnan Verified account @cvkrishnan 1d
Rich On Protection, Poor On Research: India's Solar Industry Needs To Invest In Local Technology Development.

Protected from cheap imports, India's solar panel makers earned large profits for years but spent very little on learning to build the machines their factories run.

Five of India's biggest listed solar makers
earned ₹7,300 cr combined profit in FY26. The largest of them made over ₹10 cr profit a day and another kept ₹19 of every ₹100 of sales as profit

All five combined, poured ~₹125 cr on R&D which is under 2% of their profit.
The market leader: 18 R&D staff in a workforce of 10,000+. One company printed no R&D figure at all, in a year it made ₹1,082 cr profit swarajyamag.com/tech/rich-on-p…
View quoted post on X
1 replies 19 reposts 72 likes 3.2K views View on X
Amar Govindarajan Verified account @amargov
The push to scrap capital gains tax for foreign investors rests on one claim:

"FPIs are selling because LTCG went from 10% to 12.5%"

But if you check the numbers it seems the money actually left for the AI trade.

The timeline:
- LTCG returned in April 2018
- FPIs stayed
- 2020-21: a record ₹2.74 lakh crore into Indian equities
- Sept 2024, two months after the hike: ~₹57,700 crore in, the most in nine months

So when did FPI exit come?
- only in Oct 2024
- (analysts back then blamed valuations and China's stimulus; nobody blamed the tax)
- H1 2026: a record $29 bn sold
- mostly to buy Korean and Taiwanese tech hardware

Who actually sold:
- Pension funds DIDN'T.
- They were most exposed to LTCG, often tax-exempt at home, so no offset - kept buying through every selloff
- Sovereign funds and central banks moved with them until the Nov 2024 US election, then split off

Now there's allegedly a rally that is pricing in a rumoured LTCG waiver.

And the rally supposedly pricing in a waiver? It rises when the Nasdaq falls:
- Since 13 Oct, the Nasdaq has fallen on 11 days;
- the Sensex rose the next day on 7 of those days.
- 3 of the 4 exceptions came as crude surged
- 6 Nov: Nasdaq −5.5%, its worst day in 19 months — Sensex closed 2%+ higher

It gets better
- 23 Oct–5 Nov: Sensex up after all five Nasdaq falls
- FPIs bought ₹53,739 crore in the first six sessions of November

The funds that sold were chasing AI and hedging geopolitics.

So careful about a waiver - it costs the exchequer revenue and brings none of them back.

(link in next tweet)
2 replies 13 reposts 44 likes 3.2K views View on X
Amar Govindarajan Verified account @amargov
What's in it for the Indian government and consumer to protect Indian businesses from competition?

If Indian cos are only going to bank the profits and not learn to invest in R&D or reduce foreign dependence...all that protection is doing is giving companies "protected" profits.
Amar Govindarajan Verified account @amargov 1d
For years, Indians have paid well above world prices for solar panels.

A 40% customs duty on imported panels, 25% on cells, and rules letting only Indian-made panels into government-backed projects kept cheap Chinese imports out.

This is sound industrial policy.

CAVEAT: The idea was that Indian makers would use the profits from the import protection to climb up the value chain. You know, learn to not import tech.

Their own annual reports show how that went.

What it earned the companies:
- Five of India's biggest listed solar makers
-~₹7,300 cr combined profit in FY26
- The largest of them: over ₹10 cr profit a day
- Another kept ₹19 of every ₹100 of sales as profit
- The market leader's own annual report credits import duties with helping Indian makers "consolidate their market position"

What they spent on learning (FY26 annual reports):
- All five together
-~₹125 cr on R&D
- under 2% of their profit, or about six days of it
- The biggest spender among them: about 50 paise per ₹100 of sales
- The market leader: 18 R&D staff in a workforce of 10,000+
- One printed no R&D figure at all, in a year it made ₹1,082 cr profit
- Another's parent company reports R&D: "Nil"
- For scale:
-First Solar (US) spends ~₹4.50 per ₹100;
-LONGi and JA Solar (China) ~₹6 - while making heavy losses

What that leaves India with:
- Wafers for only about 1 in every 100 panels it makes
- The market leader's latest technology import: a 10 GW ready-made cell line (2025)
- It is "sending our engineers to China for structured training"
- 16 October: China proposes curbs on exporting 12 solar technologies
- The industry's answer: shop for machines in Germany, Japan and Korea instead

Consumers paid the premium.
The companies banked the profits.
Research got less than 2% of them.

(There is also a identifiable way out - how Indian solar tech players are struggling for orders - etc - this is in the article attached in next link)
View quoted post on X