Twitxy Saved

Nick

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@badvalorem

Trade lawyer
Joined May 2013
549 Following 207 Followers 379 Posts

Latest posts 5

Nick Verified account @badvalorem
I can’t believe this needs spelling out, but we didn’t have any tariffs during manufacturing’s multi-decade decline. Tariffs - indeed taxes in general - are not what make American manufacturing uncompetitive.

That would be the statist command economy with $400B of annual industrial subsidies and global pricing power. If you think tax cuts are all we need to compete with China on price, you’re not living in reality.

So, if tariffs are off the table, what’s the plan?
Vance Ginn Verified account @VanceGinn 19h
If tariffs are delivering a manufacturing renaissance, the jobs data should show it.

BLS: manufacturing employment was 12.68 million in October (preliminary), about where it was in January 2025 at 12.67 million.

Tariffs are taxes on the inputs our factories buy. Cut them, cut spending, and let real growth follow.

vanceginn.com/letpeopleprosp…

Let people prosper.

x.com/RapidResponse4…
View quoted post on X
11 replies 4 reposts 56 likes 2.3K views View on X
Nick Verified account @badvalorem
Tariffing bananas is often cited as the height of stupidity. They get swept up in our flat 10% global tariff and there's essentially no industrial policy or reshoring justification for tariffing bananas.

But the virtue of a flat tariff is that you don't have to pick winners and losers - you can let the market decide what gets reshored without the government having to plan or predict. It's easy to administer. If you like markets, the flat tariff is actually the most market-friendly option. It's so-called "strategic" or "targeted" tariffs that deviate substantially from market logic.

The downside of a flat tariff is that you end up tariffing things that can't or won't get reshored, like bananas. That cost is graphed below: banana prices are elevated by approximately 2.5 cents a pound over their pre-2025 level.

I'm not going to object if we exempt bananas. But when you begin poking holes in the flat tariff, it makes administrability more challenging, reduces revenue, and invites corruption. Maybe that's worth the 2.5 cents/pound. But we should be clear about the terms of the debate.
Leak Wire Verified account @LeakWireQ 3d
DEAN: What's the tariff on bananas?

LUTNICK: Generally 10%

DEAN: Walmart has already increased the cost of bananas by 8%

LUTNICK: If you build in America, there is no tariff

DEAN: We cannot build bananas in America
View quoted post on X
21 replies 13 reposts 164 likes 13K views View on X
Nick Verified account @badvalorem
People absolutely love this talking point. It’s a complete misrepresentation of reality. Manufacturing construction spend is strongly *up* from its pre-COVID level. The recent drop is an artifact of the CHIPS Act and the IRA pulling forward spend and those projects wrapping up.

Anyone that looks at a graph can immediately see that we’re in a period of elevated manufacturing construction spending. In fact, it’s been rising for the last two months, possibly indicating a new equilibrium at more than twice the 2019 level.
Peter Schiff Verified account @PeterSchiff 2d
Trump claims that because of his tariffs, thousands of manufacturing plants are under construction. Not true. Manufacturing construction spending fell 21.7% in the first nine months of 2026, and spending on computer, electronic, and electrical manufacturing construction fell 45%.
View quoted post on X
3 replies 10 reposts 100 likes 3.6K views View on X
Nick Verified account @badvalorem
This didn't get enough attention. @carney found that the Fed's main economic model, FRB/US, shows that a flat 10% tariff on non-oil goods results in both higher growth and investment over a ten year period if foreign exporters absorb just 4% of the tariff cost.

The mechanism is that higher domestic selling prices act as a spur to investment, and that investment ends up outweighing the cost of the tariff.

The model likely underestimates these effects, for two reasons. First, it doesn't factor in any reshoring effect - it's purely an effect on existing economic relationships. Second, we have seen that foreign exporters have absorbed far more than 4% of the 2025 tariffs - the real number is likely over 40% (source in replies).

One interesting implication: there is now something close to a consensus that tariffs are necessary for certain strategic reasons relating to China or defense, but this is still understood as sacrificing growth to achieve other goals. That's not necessarily the case. Tariffs can actually be pro-growth. Ladies, we can have it all.

There is still a sacrifice in the form of the short-term price increase, but that price signal pulls in investment which results in growth - exactly as protectionists have argued and matching the historical experience of Britain, the US, Germany, the East Asian Tigers, and China, *all* of whom experienced massive growth and industrialization behind high tariff walls. @carney's result shows that, as some have long suspected, this may not have been a coincidence.
Jason Furman Verified account @jasonfurman 5d
A clever piece, literally running FRB/US on tariffs does result in higher investment--as John correctly notes.

I believe that says something about limitations in FRB/US which is why I made the modeling choices I did in simulating the tariffs. But props to @carney for doing this.
View quoted post on X
5 replies 9 reposts 65 likes 1.8K views View on X
Nick Verified account @badvalorem
Somehow, people who think tariffs are bad economic policy always additionally find that they’re unlawful - even under protectionist statutes passed in the 30s.

The economic effectiveness of tariffs and their lawfulness are two separate and unrelated questions, but they always magically end up aligning for the textualists at AAF and Cato. Fortuitous!
Joel Griffith Verified account @joelgriffith 3d
Trump’s Section 338 tariffs on Canada fail to pass legal muster: The conduct, the procedure, the taxing power and the timing are all outside what the 1930 statute allows. @DrewHaleDC @AmericanFreedom @realclearpolicy

realclearpolicy.com/2026/11/12/sec…
View quoted post on X