Twitxy Saved

Mike Holden

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@binaryfootball

Football Decision Architecture — better decisions through pattern recognition, cultural psychology and probability thinking.
Valencia, Spain substack.com/@binaryfootball Joined April 2014
893 Following 7.9K Followers 7.1K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Mike Holden Verified account @binaryfootball
New this week: free 1-24 podcasts covering League Two, League One and the Championship. I'll be doing about three minutes on every club.

Why now, and not August?

90 days of real competitive football, which means 90 days of every manager revealing how he thinks about his team and others in the division through his post-match interviews.

The placings will be determined by a Monte Carlo simulator (or a 'supercomputer' if your a local journo!) but this won't just be a team strength ranking.

We'll also be discussing the situations that bring out a team’s best or worst version.

Subscribe so each episode lands in your inbox: binaryfootball.substack.com/subscribe
binaryfootball.substack.com Subscribe to Mike Holden Remote football consultant focusing on psychology, philosophy and the leadership styles of football managers. Click to read Mike Holden on Substack. Launched 5 months ago.
0 replies 0 reposts 9 likes 1.7K views View on X
Mike Holden Verified account @binaryfootball
Starting to wonder if this could be Steve Evans' last proper job in football management, and if we're now witnessing the final stretch of it.

He's been a pantomime villain in the dugout for as long as I can remember and, credit where it's due, there's not many old-school managers who have managed to stay as relevant in the modern game as he has.

But he appears to be a fading force at this point. I'm not convinced we're going to see him recover his edge now.

He's never been a copy-paste manager in terms of the football he plays. From one job to the next, he has always adapted.

Evans knows whatever the current day trend is, and then basically does some version of the opposite, effectively landing on a system that the rest of the division don't want to play against.

It's a shrewd outlook. You've got to respect it. But he never seems to have found this edge at Bristol Rovers.

Opposition managers new to Evans are being kind in post-match interviews when saying how hard they were to prepare for, because they've played so many different systems. They don't realise it's back-handed criticism.

A Steve Evans team is supposed to be a team where you know exactly what you're going to get and it makes no difference because you're 50/50, at best, in being able to deal with it.

It's a shame because, in many ways, Steve Evans with a club like Bristol Rovers in League Two should have been the perfect swansong.

Get them up, make them competitive in League One again. Then bow out with your head held high.

But it's starting to look like this might have been one job too many for a guy who consulted a cardiologist a few years ago and lost over six stone to live the dream of spending another 20 years with his grandkids.

When you place Rovers' current plight in that context, you start to wonder whether the next few years wouldn't be better spent doing bits of media work and tending to those scrapbooks.

As someone who has been an avid Evans observer for probably 20 years, the grandkids replacing Sir Alex Ferguson as the interaction he wants you to know about is a fairly new development.

He's done the groundwork. Now it might be time for Evans to make a decision about what's really important. It's not like anyone's going to forget him.
Joshua Hemmings Verified account @_joshuahemmings 4d
🎙️ Steve Evans after our 2-0 defeat to Chesterfield:

“My message has always been the same - if I’m not wanted, I’ll leave. I’m not the others that hang in for paydays. Let’s not mince my words.

I sat on the bench for ten seconds to have a conversation with Paul Raynor, some of the shouts when I’ve come out - “He’s come out from hiding”. I answered them - “I don’t hide”. I’m out of the trenches, I don’t hide. I’m not like the others who hide behind the ownership. I don’t do that.

I’m not doing my job, neither is Paul, Byron or Tommo - we are not doing our jobs, but we are being let down by inconsistent players. Poor players in my opinion.”

#UTG ⛽️ | #BristolRovers 🔵⚪️
View quoted post on X
4 replies 5 reposts 58 likes 45K views View on X
Mike Holden Verified account @binaryfootball
Blackpool struck by a violent bug that swept through the camp before today’s game at Wimbledon.

Eight players missing through vomiting and diarrhoea. Others taking medication to ‘block them up’. Evatt insisting the game should have been postponed.

I’m sorry, but if you insist on recording post-match videos that belong in a TV documentary, you’re going to end up with a TV documentary.
Blackpool FC @BlackpoolFC 4d
Ian Evatt on today's match against @AFCWimbledon. 🗣️

🍊 #UTMP
View quoted post on X
1 replies 0 reposts 76 likes 50K views View on X
Mike Holden Verified account @binaryfootball
One of my favourite little quirks in recent weeks has been David Artell refusing to share a tactical secret that suddenly unlocked something in Grimsby.

It started in the 4-1 win at Gillingham, when it was 1-1 at half time.

"We told them a little thing and they carried it out brilliantly, They didn't get anywhere close to our goal second half because of it.

"I'm not going to tell you what it was, because I don't want to reveal my secrets, but one player in particular was outstanding at understanding his role to help us win the game."

Then they put five past York the following weekend and Artell was at it again. Saying, but not saying.

"I won't say what it was. It's a bit like asking McVitie's for their blend of chocolate. You don't give away your trade secrets."

Artell's a bigger picture man. Loves talking in the abstract, throws out analogies and metaphors like nobody's business.

But the logic of OPS would say he gets a bit weird and protective on the other side when he finds a little detail that lights him up, so I'm buzzing to find an example.

My guess is that it's something so trivial, you'd be laughing at the idea that it made all the difference.

But when you're seven games without a win and then suddenly smash two teams the moment you land on a tiny little tweak, you're bound treasure it!
1 replies 4 reposts 66 likes 14K views View on X
Mike Holden Verified account @binaryfootball
Okay, some thoughts.

It took me a while to gather them because it's hard to put a cocktail of different emotions into words — but this interview triggered several things in me all at once.

First of all, let me say: communication is good. This is not about a club making an effort to communicate with its fans.

But if you're suddenly doing this a few days after a 5-0 home defeat, you're either doing it too late or your prior messages haven't been clear enough.

CEOs have fans forums and other opportunities in the calendar to talk publicly about what happens on the pitch. Otherwise, stick to business and stay in the background on football matters.

Execs are responsible for strategy and this interview is nothing to do with strategy, it's pure tactics. Delaying tactics, at that.

Bristol City appears to be a club lost in the weeds with no sense of where they really are, and this guy is pleading with fans for the sake of more thinking time.

This whole interview hints at a club that doesn't know how to execute. People behind the scenes who are better at talking than actually doing. Explaining themselves as a habit. Afraid of making mistakes.

Dangling a manager's future in front of a camera should never be your go-to. Those guys put themselves in the arena every single weekend.

Not every strategy will be a winning strategy but if you operate with clarity, work to a proper structure and know your KPIs, then you hold your nerve when things don't go according to plan.

You take the criticism with broad shoulders and try to learn something from it. You don't come running for forgiveness and you don't feel a need to appease anyone. That's just weak leadership.

There's a phenomenon in psychology known as self-completion theory, whereby you feel a premature sense of accomplishment when you talk about your identity and what you're going to do before you actually do it.

When people talk too much about what they stand for, they get the same dopamine hit of satisfaction as actually living to that standard. Once they feel heard, they subsequently lack the motivation to follow through.

If you truly know what you stand for, then you already know what you need to do to turn things around and it doesn't all boil down to one guy.

But if that one guy really is your only problem, then you already know your next move. Call him in on Sunday morning, look him in the eye and shake his hand.

Instead...

"I want the fans to know that everyone shares their frustrations. From the owners, to the board, to James Ellis. Every single person at this club feels that frustration...

"Michael Skubala, more than anybody, knows we need to improve."

Honestly, go and fuck yourself.
Bristol City FC @BristolCity Nov 11
A message from CEO Charlie Boss.
View quoted post on X