Twitxy Saved

Chris Percy

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@chris_percy

Consulting Researcher (e.g. AI/XAI, careers, philosophy, safer gambling, valence). This account is mainly for exploring AI futures & artificial minds
London Joined July 2010
2.1K Following 9.4K Followers 2K Posts

Latest posts 5

Pinned post

Chris Percy Verified account @chris_percy
🧵Living thread of indicators of consciousness as implied by specific theories of consciousness

(generalised enough to apply to artificial systems and non-human animals/plants)

(both previously published indicators and new work-in-progress ones)
1 replies 0 reposts 9 likes 1.2K views View on X
Chris Percy Verified account @chris_percy
US gvnt grant (NIH) for "Establishing a Research Network to Guide Foundational Research on Human Consciousness"

--> intriguing references to "New Approach Methodologies (NAMs)", e.g. brain organoid, computational brain models, AI etc.

Any thoughts? I'll be keeping an eye out for more detail...
1 replies 0 reposts 12 likes 412 views View on X
Chris Percy Verified account @chris_percy
I love the @getjonwithit interview here - very careful epistemology on physics (temperature doesn't really exist) and elsewhere on maths. It makes me curious about his epistemology on consciousness.

I agree the gut *could* be conscious (at the level of the gut system) given today's weak understanding, but the important question is: how would we form a view on this? Is any level of self modelling enough? Why? Where do software systems fit in his picture?
Sophia Verified account @sopharicks Nov 5
Pressure and temperature don’t really exist, says my guest, mathematician and physicist @getjonwithit.
Look at water closely enough and there is just molecules bouncing around. We invented those properties because we can’t see individual molecules.
Other key moments from our conversation:

>A galaxy-sized intelligence wouldn’t know what we meant by “temperature.” It could track every particle. It would never need our equations. Jonathan thinks all of physics is like this, with space, time and particles dissolving at high enough resolution.

>Relativity and quantum mechanics both came from one realization: the observer is part of the universe, under the same limits as the thing being measured. Once you ask what a limited observer would actually see, both theories become unavoidable.

>Intelligence and consciousness may work against each other. Far more sensory data arrives than your brain can process one piece at a time. That’s why it batches that data (pain, pleasure, the color red etc). AI might become less sentient as it gets smarter, because it stops needing the shortcuts.

>Jonathan says his digestive system is probably conscious. It has enough neurons to model the world and has the same bottleneck as the brain. It just can’t speak (reminded me of Michael Levin).

>General anesthesia may not actually knock you out. As best we understand it, anesthesia makes you calm, paralyzed and unable to remember. It turns off the conscious part of you from the part that can report. This would explain why so many people have PTSD from surgery.

Full interview below
View quoted post on X
Chris Percy Verified account @chris_percy
"In our study, consciousness ceased without a global shutdown of brain activity. Sleep, anesthesia, and disorders of consciousness are typically associated with broad suppression. Extended cessation instead showed selective disengagement of systems that bind perception to feeling, memory, and self-relevance."

Fascinating work! And sure to reignite/precisify debates over access Vs phenomenal consciousness...

Could these advanced meditators (or parts of their brains) actually be conscious in cessation, but disconnected from self models, unable to report it at the time, and unable to remember it afterwards?

And what kind of epistemology/philosophy of science would enable us to have an approximately confident view on this?
Matthew D. Sacchet Verified account @MatthewSacchet Nov 2
For thousands of years, Theravāda Buddhism has described a state known as nirodha samāpatti, which is reported as complete cessation of feeling and perception. In this tradition, it is considered the highest meditative attainment and closely connected to nirvana/enlightenment.

Now, modern brain imaging is opening a window into this extraordinary phenomenon, bringing the deepest aspects of ancient contemplative practices into conversation with science.

I'm delighted to share our new study, now published in Imaging Neuroscience: "Endogenous suspension of phenomenal consciousness during extended cessation: Regional homogeneity analysis of multi-participant 7T fMRI of an advanced meditative endpoint"

This publication presents the first-ever brain imaging study of this unique phenomenon, which we have operationalized and termed “extended cessation” (EC). Practitioners enter and exit EC voluntarily, providing science with a rare, self-generated way to study what happens when awareness disappears.

Using 7T fMRI, we intensively scanned advanced meditators across EC sessions, and also during non-meditative control tasks. Retrospectively describing how they experienced EC, the meditators reported a complete absence of thought, bodily sensation, feeling, and experience during the state. On emerging, participants reported feelings of exquisite clarity, sensory vividness, radical openness, and lasting inner peace and joy.

Our neuroscience findings included:

-- In visual and posterior brain regions, neighboring signals became more synchronized, rising and falling together.

-- Synchrony decreased in areas involved in memory, emotion, and self-related processing, including the hippocampus, insula, and orbitofrontal cortex, and in brainstem nuclei.

-- Against a database of prior brain imaging studies, the EC pattern resembled brain maps associated with attention and perception, and most strongly diverged from maps associated with fear, stress, and pain.

-- EC-related neural changes tracked the distribution of histamine receptors, which are involved in the regulation of arousal and attention.

These findings shed light on an important question: how does brain organization relate to inner peace and consciousness?

In our study, consciousness ceased without a global shutdown of brain activity. Sleep, anesthesia, and disorders of consciousness are typically associated with broad suppression. EC instead showed selective disengagement of systems that bind perception to feeling, memory, and self-relevance.

These findings, although preliminary, converge with practitioners’ reports and offer a starting point for testing theories of inner peace and consciousness against a rare, emotionally and perceptually powerful, voluntary absence of experience.

Sharing congratulations and gratitude with our first author Winson Yang (@winsonfzyang), and co-authors Akila Kadambi, Ruby Potash, and Terje Sparby (@terjesparby). I also thank the meditators and our funders who made this work possible.

Please like and share if you find this work meaningful, our work depends on the support of our incredible global community.

Full article in the comments ⤵️

May this work benefit many 🙏
View quoted post on X