Twitxy Saved

conundrumer

Verified account This account is verified. Learn more

@conundrumer

abstract nonsense enjoyer - leave no shape unrotated - maintaining linerider.com
nyc conundrumer.com Joined October 2009
522 Following 1K Followers 1.7K Posts

Latest posts 5

conundrumer Verified account @conundrumer
Discourse around AI and creativity always seems to lack the human side. Why is it so implausible that it can invent jazz?

Jazz, like all creative scenes, comes from a densely connected network of humans in conversation with each other, each living their own unique lives and contributing their own idiosyncratic expressions and ideas.

Unless AI has a human like life of its own, in conversation with and learning from other humans, it will never produce creative output that will mean anything to humans

More simply: you either need AI to be sufficiently human like or have a human interpreter to make AI creative output meaningful to humans at all

With jazz specifically: you’d have to exhaustively specify all the qualities to succeed at this thought experiment, and at that point, it’s just implementing the spec, not inventing
Richard D. Bartlett Verified account @RichDecibels 2d
“if you fed a LLM all music composed up to the year 1900 it will never invent jazz”
View quoted post on X
conundrumer Verified account @conundrumer
current queue of megaprojects:
- solve continual learning (my day job lol)
- solve ARC-AGI
- rewrite line rider
- build that DAW from first principles of human musical interaction
- develop a cybernetic theory of psychology informed by prior art (mostly freud)
1 replies 0 reposts 11 likes 300 views View on X
conundrumer Verified account @conundrumer
DAWs are hostile to creativity. You open it up and the interface tells you “your mission is to create one finished song” plus everything needs to fit into tracks

Historically that was exactly the point. Record the tracks from musicians and then mix and master.

How most musicians truly work, I think, is by sketching small ideas and iteratively extending/combining/recombining them (at least mentally) and then optionally arranging into a full song. Thats how musicians improvise: learning many small ideas and then arranging live. I guess like language. Feels like a general optimal creative strategy. And it’s been the most reliable process for me for music production.

Ableton Live made a step in the right direction with clip launchers, but it still imposes the project/track paradigm.

I feel overhead when I have to deal with projects and tracks. I suppose music producers do approximations of this like having ideas in many projects or building up a library or relying on Splice. But I personally can’t tolerate having to manage and organize Things.

I want an infinite canvas as a DAW. Like being surrounded by instruments within arm’s reach, and all these instruments with their own interactions.